[RFC 5/8] Aufs2: wbr_policy

hooanon05
2009-02-23T07:36:49Z

> This is my second trial to ask incorporating aufs into mainline.

Policies to Select One among Multiple Writable Branches
----------------------------------------------------------------------
When the number of writable branch is more than one, aufs has to decide
the target branch for file creation or copy-up. By default, the highest
writable branch which has the parent (or ancestor) dir of the target
file is chosen (top-down-parent policy).
By user's request, aufs implements some other policies to select the
writable branch, for file creation two policies, round-robin and
most-free-space policies. For copy-up three policies, top-down-parent,
bottom-up-parent and bottom-up policies.

As expected, the round-robin policy selects the branch in circular. When
you have two writable branches and creates 10 new files, 5 files will be
created for each branch. mkdir(2) systemcall is an exception. When you
create 10 new directories, all will be created on the same branch.
And the most-free-space policy selects the one which has most free
space among the writable branches. The amount of free space will be
checked by aufs internally, and users can specify its time interval.

The policies for copy-up is more simple,
top-down-parent is equivalent to the same named on in create policy,
bottom-up-parent selects the writable branch where the parent dir
exists and the nearest upper one from the copyup-source,
bottom-up selects the nearest upper writable branch from the
copyup-source, regardless the existence of the parent dir.

There are some rules or exceptions to apply these policies.
- If there is a readonly branch above the policy-selected branch and
the parent dir is marked as opaque (a variation of whiteout), or the
target (creating) file is whiteout-ed on the upper readonly branch,
then the result of the policy is ignored and the target file will be
created on the nearest upper writable branch than the readonly branch.
- If there is a writable branch above the policy-selected branch and
the parent dir is marked as opaque or the target file is whiteouted
on the branch, then the result of the policy is ignored and the target
file will be created on the highest one among the upper writable
branches who has diropq or whiteout. In case of whiteout, aufs removes
it as usual.
- link(2) and rename(2) systemcalls are exceptions in every policy.
They try selecting the branch where the source exists as possible
since copyup a large file will take long time. If it can't be,
ie. the branch where the source exists is readonly, then they will
follow the copyup policy.
- There is an exception for rename(2) when the target exists.
If the rename target exists, aufs compares the index of the branches
where the source and the target exists and selects the higher
one. If the selected branch is readonly, then aufs follows the
copyup policy.