[BUG] PLEXTOR DVDR PX-740A drive not ready for command

[BUG] PLEXTOR DVDR PX-740A drive not ready for command

[Richard Genoud]

Hi!
On ubuntu bug tracker, there's some bug reports about DVD drives that don't respond anymore.

The affected drives are:
PLEXTOR DVDR PX-740A
BENQ DVD DD DW1620
PHILIPS DVDR14P
SS-SAMSUNG SCR-3232
Matsushita SR-8584-B
(for now)

the error message is :
hda: status error: error=0x00 { }
ide: failed opcode was: unknown
hda: drive not ready for command
hda: status error: status 0x59 { DriveReady SeekComplete DataRequest Error }

more details on the ubuntu bug-tracker:
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/179336
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/182996
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/181561

I bisect to find out where the bug was and I found that this commit is:

b140b99c413ce410197cfcd4014e757cd745226a is first bad commit
commit b140b99c413ce410197cfcd4014e757cd745226a
Author: Bartlomiej Zolnierkiewicz <bzolnier@gmail.com>
Date:   Sat Oct 13 17:47:51 2007 +0200

    ide: change master/slave IDENTIFY order
    
    Need to probe slave device first to make it release PDIAG-
    (this is required for correct device side cable detection).
    
    Based on libata commit f31f0cc2f0b7527072d94d02da332d9bb8d7d94c.
    
    Thanks to Craig for testing this patch.
    
    Cc: Craig Block <chblock3@yahoo.com>
    Signed-off-by: Bartlomiej Zolnierkiewicz <bzolnier@gmail.com>

:040000 040000 fa17f9e66a6e551184b1ec00049cea6fb87f7a1c 89a175312afe235fbdb04a3a593a4b981bdd9188 M      drivers



The bisect log is:

git-bisect start
# good: [bbf25010f1a6b761914430f5fca081ec8c7accd1] Linux 2.6.23
git-bisect good bbf25010f1a6b761914430f5fca081ec8c7accd1
# bad: [c9927c2bf4f45bb85e8b502ab3fb79ad6483c244] Linux 2.6.24-rc1
git-bisect bad c9927c2bf4f45bb85e8b502ab3fb79ad6483c244
# bad: [9ac52315d4cf5f561f36dabaf0720c00d3553162] sched: guest CPU accounting: add guest-CPU /proc/<pid>/stat fields
git-bisect bad 9ac52315d4cf5f561f36dabaf0720c00d3553162
# good: [038a5008b2f395c85e6e71d6ddf3c684e7c405b0] Merge branch 'master' of git://git.kernel.org/pub/scm/linux/kernel/git/davem/net-2.6
git-bisect good 038a5008b2f395c85e6e71d6ddf3c684e7c405b0
# good: [782e3b3b3804c38d5130c7f21d7ec7bf6709023f] Fix up more bio fallout
git-bisect good 782e3b3b3804c38d5130c7f21d7ec7bf6709023f
# good: [1b9778dae71dc64d3678d766c0f1fbed79c80f9f] KVM: Keep track of missed timer irq injections
git-bisect good 1b9778dae71dc64d3678d766c0f1fbed79c80f9f
# bad: [bcd11eaa222fce31d0b59cdbfdf9b8c47067f15a] Merge git://git.kernel.org/pub/scm/linux/kernel/git/bart/ide-2.6
git-bisect bad bcd11eaa222fce31d0b59cdbfdf9b8c47067f15a
# good: [c5d6471ff9172e4d8f7a5b484b459c56904ae1f0] fallout from DECLARE_MAC_BUF patches
git-bisect good c5d6471ff9172e4d8f7a5b484b459c56904ae1f0
# good: [59d8235be2ab38ddaffbe9137385095a5e8b0a77] [JFFS2] Fix unpoint length
git-bisect good 59d8235be2ab38ddaffbe9137385095a5e8b0a77
# good: [3749c66c67fb5c257771815c186bc32290cacf44] Merge branch 'for-linus' of git://git.kernel.org/pub/scm/linux/kernel/git/avi/kvm
git-bisect good 3749c66c67fb5c257771815c186bc32290cacf44
# bad: [b9d9e61abb85ecf4e4aa55328b21eac17840a3fb] sgiioc4: add missing ->dma_base check
git-bisect bad b9d9e61abb85ecf4e4aa55328b21eac17840a3fb
# good: [aedea5910ce44fea79e2c517bb22e0006372156f] ide-pmac: remove pmac_ide_do_setfeature() (take 2)
git-bisect good aedea5910ce44fea79e2c517bb22e0006372156f
# good: [249aa4ff1778b318346d8ba4a7fa62c169a29410] cs5535: check ide_config_drive_speed() return value
git-bisect good 249aa4ff1778b318346d8ba4a7fa62c169a29410
# bad: [b140b99c413ce410197cfcd4014e757cd745226a] ide: change master/slave IDENTIFY order
git-bisect bad b140b99c413ce410197cfcd4014e757cd745226a
# good: [88b2b32babd46cd54d2de4d17eb869aea3383e11] ide: move ide_config_drive_speed() calls to upper layers (take 2)
git-bisect good 88b2b32babd46cd54d2de4d17eb869aea3383e11

If you need me to do some more tests, just ask.

regards,

Richard Genoud.

Re: [BUG] PLEXTOR DVDR PX-740A drive not ready for command

[Boris Petkov]

On Thu, Mar 13, 2008 at 10:43 AM, Richard Genoud
<richard.genoud@gmail.com> wrote:
> Hi!
>  On ubuntu bug tracker, there's some bug reports about DVD drives that don't respond anymore.
>
>  The affected drives are:
>  PLEXTOR DVDR PX-740A
>  BENQ DVD DD DW1620
>  PHILIPS DVDR14P
>  SS-SAMSUNG SCR-3232
>  Matsushita SR-8584-B
>  (for now)
>
>  the error message is :
>  hda: status error: error=0x00 { }
>  ide: failed opcode was: unknown
>  hda: drive not ready for command
>  hda: status error: status 0x59 { DriveReady SeekComplete DataRequest Error }
>
>  more details on the ubuntu bug-tracker:
>  https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/179336
>  https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/182996
>  https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/181561
>
>  I bisect to find out where the bug was and I found that this commit is:
>
>  b140b99c413ce410197cfcd4014e757cd745226a is first bad commit
>  commit b140b99c413ce410197cfcd4014e757cd745226a
>  Author: Bartlomiej Zolnierkiewicz <bzolnier@gmail.com>
>  Date:   Sat Oct 13 17:47:51 2007 +0200
>
>     ide: change master/slave IDENTIFY order
>
>     Need to probe slave device first to make it release PDIAG-
>     (this is required for correct device side cable detection).
>
>     Based on libata commit f31f0cc2f0b7527072d94d02da332d9bb8d7d94c.
>
>     Thanks to Craig for testing this patch.
>
>     Cc: Craig Block <chblock3@yahoo.com>
>     Signed-off-by: Bartlomiej Zolnierkiewicz <bzolnier@gmail.com>
>
>  :040000 040000 fa17f9e66a6e551184b1ec00049cea6fb87f7a1c 89a175312afe235fbdb04a3a593a4b981bdd9188 M      drivers
>
>
>
>  The bisect log is:
>
>  git-bisect start
>  # good: [bbf25010f1a6b761914430f5fca081ec8c7accd1] Linux 2.6.23
>  git-bisect good bbf25010f1a6b761914430f5fca081ec8c7accd1
>  # bad: [c9927c2bf4f45bb85e8b502ab3fb79ad6483c244] Linux 2.6.24-rc1

Have you tried a more recent kernel? Your bisection interval is .23 and .24-rc1,
and a lot of code went into ide after that. However, you should try to
avoid 2.6.24
since ide-cd was broken there. I'd go with 2.6.25-rc5, for example.

>  git-bisect bad c9927c2bf4f45bb85e8b502ab3fb79ad6483c244
>  # bad: [9ac52315d4cf5f561f36dabaf0720c00d3553162] sched: guest CPU accounting: add guest-CPU /proc/<pid>/stat fields
>  git-bisect bad 9ac52315d4cf5f561f36dabaf0720c00d3553162
>  # good: [038a5008b2f395c85e6e71d6ddf3c684e7c405b0] Merge branch 'master' of git://git.kernel.org/pub/scm/linux/kernel/git/davem/net-2.6
>  git-bisect good 038a5008b2f395c85e6e71d6ddf3c684e7c405b0
>  # good: [782e3b3b3804c38d5130c7f21d7ec7bf6709023f] Fix up more bio fallout
>  git-bisect good 782e3b3b3804c38d5130c7f21d7ec7bf6709023f
>  # good: [1b9778dae71dc64d3678d766c0f1fbed79c80f9f] KVM: Keep track of missed timer irq injections
>  git-bisect good 1b9778dae71dc64d3678d766c0f1fbed79c80f9f
>  # bad: [bcd11eaa222fce31d0b59cdbfdf9b8c47067f15a] Merge git://git.kernel.org/pub/scm/linux/kernel/git/bart/ide-2.6
>  git-bisect bad bcd11eaa222fce31d0b59cdbfdf9b8c47067f15a
>  # good: [c5d6471ff9172e4d8f7a5b484b459c56904ae1f0] fallout from DECLARE_MAC_BUF patches
>  git-bisect good c5d6471ff9172e4d8f7a5b484b459c56904ae1f0
>  # good: [59d8235be2ab38ddaffbe9137385095a5e8b0a77] [JFFS2] Fix unpoint length
>  git-bisect good 59d8235be2ab38ddaffbe9137385095a5e8b0a77
>  # good: [3749c66c67fb5c257771815c186bc32290cacf44] Merge branch 'for-linus' of git://git.kernel.org/pub/scm/linux/kernel/git/avi/kvm
>  git-bisect good 3749c66c67fb5c257771815c186bc32290cacf44
>  # bad: [b9d9e61abb85ecf4e4aa55328b21eac17840a3fb] sgiioc4: add missing ->dma_base check
>  git-bisect bad b9d9e61abb85ecf4e4aa55328b21eac17840a3fb
>  # good: [aedea5910ce44fea79e2c517bb22e0006372156f] ide-pmac: remove pmac_ide_do_setfeature() (take 2)
>  git-bisect good aedea5910ce44fea79e2c517bb22e0006372156f
>  # good: [249aa4ff1778b318346d8ba4a7fa62c169a29410] cs5535: check ide_config_drive_speed() return value
>  git-bisect good 249aa4ff1778b318346d8ba4a7fa62c169a29410
>  # bad: [b140b99c413ce410197cfcd4014e757cd745226a] ide: change master/slave IDENTIFY order
>  git-bisect bad b140b99c413ce410197cfcd4014e757cd745226a
>  # good: [88b2b32babd46cd54d2de4d17eb869aea3383e11] ide: move ide_config_drive_speed() calls to upper layers (take 2)
>  git-bisect good 88b2b32babd46cd54d2de4d17eb869aea3383e11
>
>  If you need me to do some more tests, just ask.
>
>  regards,
>
>  Richard Genoud.
>
>
>  --
>  To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in
>  the body of a message to majordomo@vger.kernel.org
>  More majordomo info at  http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
>  Please read the FAQ at  http://www.tux.org/lkml/
>



-- 
Regards/Gruß,
Boris

Re: [BUG] PLEXTOR DVDR PX-740A drive not ready for command

[Richard Genoud]

> Have you tried a more recent kernel? Your bisection interval is .23 and .24-rc1,
>  and a lot of code went into ide after that. However, you should try to
>  avoid 2.6.24
>  since ide-cd was broken there. I'd go with 2.6.25-rc5, for example.

I did not tried it personnaly, but at least 2 persons on the ubuntu
bug tracker did.
The bug is still there.

Re: [BUG] PLEXTOR DVDR PX-740A drive not ready for command

[Richard Genoud]

> Could we get full dmesg for this particular system/problem?
>
>  Please also;
>  - test 2.6.25-rc5 on _your_ system
>  - verify that configuration of hda and hdb devices is correct
>   (master/slave settings)
>
> There is far too much information there (different error messages,
>  different host drivers, some systems are using libata...) - please
>  open a new bug entry at http://bugzilla.kernel.org so we can start
>  "clean" and fully concentrate on fixing this bug.
>

Ok, I will test that this evening and open a bug entry.

Richard.

Re: [BUG] PLEXTOR DVDR PX-740A drive not ready for command

[Bartlomiej Zolnierkiewicz]

Hi,

On Thursday 13 March 2008, Richard Genoud wrote:
> Hi!
> On ubuntu bug tracker, there's some bug reports about DVD drives that don't respond anymore.
> 
> The affected drives are:
> PLEXTOR DVDR PX-740A
> BENQ DVD DD DW1620
> PHILIPS DVDR14P
> SS-SAMSUNG SCR-3232
> Matsushita SR-8584-B
> (for now)
> 
> the error message is :
> hda: status error: error=0x00 { }
> ide: failed opcode was: unknown
> hda: drive not ready for command
> hda: status error: status 0x59 { DriveReady SeekComplete DataRequest Error }

Could we get full dmesg for this particular system/problem?

Please also;
- test 2.6.25-rc5 on _your_ system
- verify that configuration of hda and hdb devices is correct
  (master/slave settings)

> more details on the ubuntu bug-tracker:
> https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/179336
> https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/182996
> https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/181561

There is far too much information there (different error messages,
different host drivers, some systems are using libata...) - please
open a new bug entry at http://bugzilla.kernel.org so we can start
"clean" and fully concentrate on fixing this bug.

PS Thanks for bisecting it.

Bart