Re: [GIT PATCH] block: unify request processing model and implement peek/fetch

[Jens Axboe <jens.axboe@oracle.com>]

On Fri, May 08 2009, Tejun Heo wrote:
> Hello,
> 
> Upon ack, please pull from the following git tree.
> 
>   git://git.kernel.org/pub/scm/linux/kernel/git/tj/misc.git block-peek-fetch
> 
> Block layer has allowed two different models of request processing.
> elv_next_request() is used to peek at the top of the queue, after
> peeking, a LLD could start processing it immediately or dequeue and
> then start processing.
> 
> The non-dequeuing behavior is mostly useful for simpler device drivers
> (usually PIO based) which process requests on segment basis.  By using
> the block layer queue tip as the current request pointer, they don't
> have to care about request boundaries and just process things
> segment-by-segment.
> 
> However, this dual mode of operations complicates and ambiguates block
> layer API.  Block layer can't tell whether a request has begun
> processing or not in deterministic manner.  This makes accounting
> inaccurate and implementing high level features in block layer
> difficult.  For example, it isn't clear when a block layer timeout
> timer should be started or how queue queiscing for EH should be
> implemented.  Even when problems can be worked aroudn, it makes the
> implementation fragile.
> 
> Although allowing llds ignore request boundaries makes things simpler
> for certain drivers, the number of drivers benefit form it aren't too
> many and driver stacks which are even mildly complex have to deal with
> request boundaries anyway.  Also, the benefit itself isn't that
> significant.  In most cases, it is just another way of doing things
> rather than the definitively better way.  IOW, if there were no such
> alternative, nobody would have missed it.
> 
> This patchset converts all block layer llds to dequeuing model and
> then clean up API to simplify a bit and enforce dequeueing model.
> This patchset contains the following patches.

Glad this finally got completed, thanks a lot Tejun! Applied.

-- 
Jens Axboe