Re: [PATCH V3 07/12] ata/sata_mv: Remove conditional compilation of clk code

[Andrew Lunn <andrew@lunn.ch>]

On Tue, Apr 24, 2012 at 07:12:10PM +0530, viresh kumar wrote:
> On 4/24/12, Andrew Lunn <andrew@lunn.ch> wrote:
> > Sorry, but still wrong.
> >
> > The clock is optional. If we can find a clock, turn it on. If not,
> > keep going....
> >
> > You patch causes the missing clock to become a fatal error.
> >
> > This sata_mv exists in multiple forms. It can be part of a SoC. It can
> > also be on a PCI bus. In the PCI form, it is unlikely to have a clk
> > which can be controlled. When built into a SoC, namely one of the
> > Orion family, dove, orion5x, mv78xx0 do not have a clock which can be
> > controlled. However kirkwood does have a clock.
> >
> > So, kirkwood will provide a clock and expects that sata_mv will turn
> > it on. All the other ways of using sata_mv will not provide a clock,
> > but still expect the driver to be happy.
> 
> Hmm. What this code does now is:
> If HAVE_CLK is selected, then there must be a clock for the device. Otherwise
> it will always pass.
> 

-#if defined(CONFIG_HAVE_CLK)
    hpriv->clk = clk_get(&pdev->dev, NULL);
-   if (IS_ERR(hpriv->clk))
-           dev_notice(&pdev->dev, "cannot get clkdev\n");
-   else
-           clk_enable(hpriv->clk);
-#endif
+   if (IS_ERR(hpriv->clk)) {
+           dev_err(&pdev->dev, "cannot get clkdev\n");
+           return PTR_ERR(hpriv->clk);
+   }
+
+   clk_enable(hpriv->clk);

There are three use cases....

1) The platform does not implement HAVE_CLK. So we are using your NOP
   operations.

   clk_get() returns NULL.

   IS_ERR(NULL) is false. So it keeps going, calls clk_enable() which is
   also NOP and the driver is happy.

2) The platform does have HAVE_CLK. So we are using driver/clk/
   code. There is no clk defined for the device, since there is no
   controllable clk. Its using the PCI clock, or some hard wired
   internal SoC clock.

   clk_get() returns ERR_PTR(-ENOENT)

   IS_ERR(hpriv->clk) is true, you output a dev_err() and the device
   probe fails.

   This is wrong. Not having the clk is not fatal. The old code would
   carefully not call clk_enable(), since it has an error pointer, not
   have a valid clk, and would also not call clk_disable during
   removal.

3) The platform does have HAVE_CLK. So we are using driver/clk/ code.
   There is however a gateable clock driving this lump of silicon.

   clk_get() returns a valid pointer to a clk.
   IS_ERR(hpriv->clk) is false, so it keeps going.
   clk_enable() is called and the driver is happy.

   Well, actually, his brings up a new issues 

static int __clk_enable(struct clk *clk)
{
        int ret = 0;

        if (!clk)
                return 0;

        if (WARN_ON(clk->prepare_count == 0))
                return -ESHUTDOWN;

   this should actually be clk_prepare_enable(). Did you see my
   patches adding generic clk framework support for Orion. I fixed
   this as part of that patch set.

Anyway.... You asked:

> You want not to return error if a platform does have HAVE_CLK, but
> doesn't have a clock for sata? That would be simple to fix, but want
> to confirm if this is actually required.

Correct.

	Andrew