[linux-lvm] Missing 1 of 3 PVs and all partition tables are good

[Cory Zerwas <gannas@gmail.com>]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 1826 bytes --]

Hi all,

I'm in a pinch. I've got about 500Gb of data trapped in a non-functioning
VG... Here's the deal:

I upgraded from FC3 to FC4, or tried to. The whole update bombed out but
during this time the LVM disks were unplugged from the system. When I got
the new system up on the old FS my LVM conf still appears to be in place. I
powered up the 3 drives and reset the system and I found the VG won't
activate.
I did not export the volume first. I realize now that this was a mistake.

I have 3 whole disks for this VG, each with 1 partition, type 8e, occupying
the entire disk. These are hdb1, hdc1, hdd1.

I'm noticing that an "fdisk -l" lists hdb, hdc, and hdd as all having
partitions of type 8e from beginning to end of disk. However, when I go into
LVM and run "pvscan" I only see two PVs belonging to my VG "bloaty" and it
shows:

PV /dev/hdc1 VG bloaty lvm2 [111.78 GB / 0 free]
PV /dev/hdd1 VG bloaty lvm2 [115.03 GB / 64.00 MB free]
Total: 2 [266.81 GB] / in use: 2 [226.81 GB] / in no VG: 0 [0 ]

LVM doesn't seem to notice /dev/hdb1? It's a 232.88 Gb PV, how can this be?
And why isn't PVSCAN complaining about a missing PV? It should be, shouldn't
it?

When I perform a "lvmdiskscan" I get (the parenthesis outline my input):

/dev/hda1 [ 101.94 MB]
(^^this is the /boot partition)
/dev/hdc1 [ 111.79 GB] LVM physical volume
/dev/hda2 [ 17.54 GB]
(^^this is the / partition)
/dev/hda3 [ 1.00 GB]
(^^this is the swap partition)
/dev/hdb1 [ 232.88 GB]
(^^THIS SHOULD BE A PV)
/dev/hdd1 [ 115.04 GB] LVM physical volume

Is there some trick here I don't know about? Do I have to restore the LVM
conf?

I am stumped. I'm pretty sure I'm not a newb, but I am definately not a
wizard. I've got my LPIC Level 1 cert if that means anything.

Heh, thanks for any help,
Cory

[-- Attachment #2: Type: text/html, Size: 2368 bytes --]