av7110 error reporting

av7110 error reporting

[Johan]

I need some guidance on error messages..

The machine receives these messages in the systemlog (dmesg)

[ 7673.168026] dvb-ttpci: StartHWFilter error  buf 0b07 0010 07e9 b96a  
ret 0  handle ffff
[ 7674.192025] dvb-ttpci: StartHWFilter error  buf 0b07 0010 07ee b96a  
ret 0  handle ffff
[ 7675.224025] dvb-ttpci: StartHWFilter error  buf 0b07 0010 07f3 b96a  
ret 0  handle ffff
[ 7676.248128] dvb-ttpci: StartHWFilter error  buf 0b07 0010 07f9 b96a  
ret 0  handle ffff
[ 7677.280026] dvb-ttpci: StartHWFilter error  buf 0b07 0010 07fd b96a  
ret 0  handle ffff
[ 7678.312025] dvb-ttpci: StartHWFilter error  buf 0b07 0010 0803 b96a  
ret 0  handle ffff

These start as soon as I view or record a channel, and obviously fills 
up the log quickly.

I believe the code that generates these messages is at the bottom of 
this message (part of av7110.c). This code was introduced in 2005 to 
improve error reporting.

Currently I run today's v4l-dvb (using a hg update), and kernel 
2.6.31-16. (Ubuntu), however the issue occurred in older combinations as 
well (over a year ago), so it is not introduced by the last kernels or 
DVB driverset.

The message seems to be triggered by the variable "handle" being larger 
then 32. On my system it always reports ffff.

Am I looking at faulty hardware, or can I resolve this issue more 
elegant than just disabling the fault report?
(keep in mind that I do not have a programming/coding background)



Johan



start of code--->
static int StartHWFilter(struct dvb_demux_filter *dvbdmxfilter)
{
    struct dvb_demux_feed *dvbdmxfeed = dvbdmxfilter->feed;
    struct av7110 *av7110 = dvbdmxfeed->demux->priv;
    u16 buf[20];
    int ret, i;
    u16 handle;
//    u16 mode = 0x0320;
    u16 mode = 0xb96a;

    dprintk(4, "%p\n", av7110);

    if (av7110->full_ts)
        return 0;

    if (dvbdmxfilter->type == DMX_TYPE_SEC) {
        if (hw_sections) {
            buf[4] = (dvbdmxfilter->filter.filter_value[0] << 8) |
                dvbdmxfilter->maskandmode[0];
            for (i = 3; i < 18; i++)
                buf[i + 4 - 2] =
                    (dvbdmxfilter->filter.filter_value[i] << 8) |
                    dvbdmxfilter->maskandmode[i];
            mode = 4;
        }
    } else if ((dvbdmxfeed->ts_type & TS_PACKET) &&
           !(dvbdmxfeed->ts_type & TS_PAYLOAD_ONLY)) {
        av7110_p2t_init(&av7110->p2t_filter[dvbdmxfilter->index], 
dvbdmxfeed);
    }

    buf[0] = (COMTYPE_PID_FILTER << 8) + AddPIDFilter;
    buf[1] = 16;
    buf[2] = dvbdmxfeed->pid;
    buf[3] = mode;

    ret = av7110_fw_request(av7110, buf, 20, &handle, 1);
    if (ret != 0 || handle >= 32) {
        printk("dvb-ttpci: %s error  buf %04x %04x %04x %04x  "
                "ret %d  handle %04x\n",
                __func__, buf[0], buf[1], buf[2], buf[3],
                ret, handle);
        dvbdmxfilter->hw_handle = 0xffff;
        if (!ret)
            ret = -1;
        return ret;
    }

    av7110->handle2filter[handle] = dvbdmxfilter;
    dvbdmxfilter->hw_handle = handle;

    return ret;
}

<------end of code

Re: av7110 error reporting

[Oliver Endriss]

Hi,

Johan wrote:
> I need some guidance on error messages..
> 
> The machine receives these messages in the systemlog (dmesg)
> 
> [ 7673.168026] dvb-ttpci: StartHWFilter error  buf 0b07 0010 07e9 b96a  
> ret 0  handle ffff
> [ 7674.192025] dvb-ttpci: StartHWFilter error  buf 0b07 0010 07ee b96a  
> ret 0  handle ffff
> [ 7675.224025] dvb-ttpci: StartHWFilter error  buf 0b07 0010 07f3 b96a  
> ret 0  handle ffff
> [ 7676.248128] dvb-ttpci: StartHWFilter error  buf 0b07 0010 07f9 b96a  
> ret 0  handle ffff
> [ 7677.280026] dvb-ttpci: StartHWFilter error  buf 0b07 0010 07fd b96a  
> ret 0  handle ffff
> [ 7678.312025] dvb-ttpci: StartHWFilter error  buf 0b07 0010 0803 b96a  
> ret 0  handle ffff
> 
> These start as soon as I view or record a channel, and obviously fills 
> up the log quickly.
> 
> I believe the code that generates these messages is at the bottom of 
> this message (part of av7110.c). This code was introduced in 2005 to 
> improve error reporting.

True.

> Currently I run today's v4l-dvb (using a hg update), and kernel 
> 2.6.31-16. (Ubuntu), however the issue occurred in older combinations as 
> well (over a year ago), so it is not introduced by the last kernels or 
> DVB driverset.
>
> The message seems to be triggered by the variable "handle" being larger 
> then 32. On my system it always reports ffff.

Handle == ffff means that the av7110 was not able to create a new filter
entry. This will happen if there are already 32 active filters.

Does it happen for all channels, or only for a specific one?
If the latter is true: Which channel is causing the problem?
Does it have a large number of audio pids?

> Am I looking at faulty hardware, or can I resolve this issue more 
> elegant than just disabling the fault report?
> (keep in mind that I do not have a programming/coding background)

You may disable the warning, but be warned that some parts of the data
will not be recorded due to missing filter entries...

Oliver

-- 
----------------------------------------------------------------
VDR Remote Plugin 0.4.0: http://www.escape-edv.de/endriss/vdr/
4 MByte Mod: http://www.escape-edv.de/endriss/dvb-mem-mod/
Full-TS Mod: http://www.escape-edv.de/endriss/dvb-full-ts-mod/
----------------------------------------------------------------

Re: av7110 error reporting

[Johan]

Oliver Endriss wrote:
> Hi,
>
> Johan wrote:
>   
>> I need some guidance on error messages..
>>
>> T
>> [ 7678.312025] dvb-ttpci: StartHWFilter error  buf 0b07 0010 0803 b96a  
>> ret 0  handle ffff
>>
>> These start as soon as I view or record a channel, and obviously fills 
>> up the log quickly.
>>
>> I believe the code that generates these messages is at the bottom of 
>> this message (part of av7110.c). This code was introduced in 2005 to 
>> improve error reporting.
>>     
>
> True.
>
>   
>> Currently I run today's v4l-dvb (using a hg update), and kernel 
>> 2.6.31-16. (Ubuntu), however the issue occurred in older combinations as 
>> well (over a year ago), so it is not introduced by the last kernels or 
>> DVB driverset.
>>
>> The message seems to be triggered by the variable "handle" being larger 
>> then 32. On my system it always reports ffff.
>>     
>
> Handle == ffff means that the av7110 was not able to create a new filter
> entry. This will happen if there are already 32 active filters.
>
> Does it happen for all channels, or only for a specific one?
> If the latter is true: Which channel is causing the problem?
> Does it have a large number of audio pids?
>
>   
>> Am I looking at faulty hardware, or can I resolve this issue more 
>> elegant than just disabling the fault report?
>> (keep in mind that I do not have a programming/coding background)
>>     
>
> You may disable the warning, but be warned that some parts of the data
> will not be recorded due to missing filter entries...
>
> Oliver
>
>   
Think I know why this is happening. Using Mplayer I see that dvb-ttpci 
is used by about 4-5 processes. No errors.
Using mythtv 0.22 lsmod reports dvb-ttpci being used by 31 processes. 
Errors.

My idea is that mythtv's multirec feature is causing this, even though I 
have not enabled any virtual tuner.
My card, an unmodified Nexus-s (from 1998) may not support multirec due 
to its hardware design. (took me quite a bit of googling to make this 
assumption).

So, if my assumption is correct, the error is with Mythtv, where it is 
assumed that my card is multirec capable. (and how would Mythtv know, 
since the driver is the same ?)

I have now bought an HVR4000, so I have time to mod the Nexus. (and dig 
out my reading glasses to find the pins)

Johan