Re: flash read performance

Trent Piepho
2008-11-08T05:29:34Z

On Fri, 7 Nov 2008, Andre Puschmann wrote:
> Trent Piepho wrote:
>> I've found that writes do not work with caching enabled. When the CPU writes
>> to the flash and then reads it back, it gets returned what it wrote. That's
>> not what is supposed to happen.
>
> Sure, writes should be uncached and unbuffered. But I thought the mtd
> layer handles this correctly as there are two different ioremap's in the
> driver:
>
> map.virt = ioremap(..);
> map.cached = ioremap_cached(..);
> map.inval_cache = inval_cache_fct();

It depends on what mapping driver you're using. It looks like only the
pxa2xx driver uses map.cached. The physmap or of_physmap drivers that I'm
using don't use it.

> So, calling inval_cache_fct() just before any write operation and then
> using the uncached mapping should do the trick, no? On the other hand, I
> am not sure if the mtd-layer really behaves like that. Can somebody
> confirm this?

>From looking at the code I'd say you're right.

> I am not familiar with GPCM and eLBC, but it sounds about the same here.
> Same timings for writes and reads. But I use burst mode (4 words), but
> this only applies to reads.

I've switched from GPCM to UPM, which lets me use different timings for
read and write as well as use burst mode.

In non-cached and guarded mode, I now get 13.61 vs 12.30 MB/s. That's just
from slightly better timings because I could make them different for read
vs write. The big difference is cached and non-guarded reads, which went
to 44.79 MB/s from 14.24 MB/s. That boost is from using burst mode.

So the answer is yes, turning on cache can boost cold-cache performance, if
doing so lets you use page burst mode. It makes a huge difference in fact!

>> The biggest bootup delay I have now is waiting for the ethernet phy to get
>> online, which takes almost 3 seconds.
>
> Same here, ethernet phy takes sooo long. Here is what I do: I am using a
> parallel init. On script is just for loading the ethernet-module which
> is done next to the other scripts. So 2sec is cheated, cause ethernet
> isn't really available at this point of time.

It might be the case that the ethernet module resets the PHY when it loads
and/or when the ethernet device is opened. That was a problem I was
having. The PHY would almost be done when the dhcp client would run and
open eth0, which would start the phy all over again.