next-20230809: kvm unittest fail: emulator

next-20230809: kvm unittest fail: emulator

[Aithal, Srikanth]

Hello,

On linux-next 20230809 build kvm emulator unittest failed.

===================
Recreation steps:
===================

1. git clone https://gitlab.com/kvm-unit-tests/kvm-unit-tests.git
2. export QEMU=<location of QEMU binary> I used v8.0.2
3. cd kvm-unit-tests/;./configure;make standalone;tests/emulator

Debug log:

[stdout] BUILD_HEAD=023002d2
[stdout] timeout -k 1s --foreground 90s 
/home/VT_BUILD/qemu/build/x86_64-softmmu/qemu-system-x86_64 --no-reboot 
-nodefaults -device pc-testdev -device 
isa-debug-exit,iobase=0xf4,iosize=0x4 -vnc none -serial stdio -device 
pci-testdev -machine accel=kvm -kernel /tmp/tmp.AFoESgjELO -smp 1 # 
-initrd /tmp/tmp.CGpwyvgHI4
[stdout] enabling apic
[stdout] smp: waiting for 0 APs
[stdout] SKIP: Skipping tests the require forced emulation, use 
kvm.force_emulation_prefix=1 to enable
[stdout] paging enabled
[stdout] cr0 = 80010011
[stdout] cr3 = 1007000
[stdout] cr4 = 20
[stdout] PASS: mov reg, r/m (1)
[stdout] FAIL: or
[stdout] FAIL: add
[stdout] FAIL: xor
[stdout] FAIL: sub
[stdout] FAIL: adc(0)
[stdout] FAIL: adc(0)
[stdout] FAIL: sbb(0)
[stdout] FAIL: sbb(1)
[stdout] FAIL: and
[stdout] FAIL: test
[stdout] FAIL: repe/cmpsb (1)
[stdout] FAIL: repe cmpsb (1.zf)
[stdout] FAIL: repe cmpsw (1)
[stdout] FAIL: repe cmpll (1)
[stdout] FAIL: repe cmpsq (1)
[stdout] FAIL: repe cmpsb (2)
[stdout] FAIL: repe cmpsw (2)
[stdout] FAIL: repe cmpll (2)
[stdout] FAIL: repe cmpsq (2)
[stdout] FAIL: repe/cmpsb (1)
[stdout] FAIL: repe cmpsb (1.zf)
[stdout] FAIL: repe cmpsw (1)
[stdout] FAIL: repe cmpll (1)
[stdout] FAIL: repe cmpsq (1)
[stdout] FAIL: repe cmpsb (2)
[stdout] FAIL: repe cmpsw (2)
[stdout] FAIL: repe cmpll (2)
[stdout] FAIL: repe cmpsq (2)
[stdout] FAIL: scasb match
[stdout] PASS: scasb mismatch
[stdout] FAIL: scasw match
[stdout] PASS: scasw mismatch
[stdout] FAIL: scasd match
[stdout] PASS: scasd mismatch
[stdout] FAIL: scasq match
[stdout] PASS: scasq mismatch
[stdout] PASS: smsw (1)
[stdout] PASS: smsw (2)
[stdout] PASS: smsw (3)
[stdout] before 80010011 after 80010019
[stdout] PASS: lmsw (1)
[stdout] before 80010011 after 80010011
[stdout] PASS: lmsw (2)
[stdout] PASS: lmsw (3)
[stdout] PASS: outsb up
[stdout] PASS: outsb down
[stdout] FAIL: incl
[stdout] FAIL: decl
[stdout] FAIL: incb
[stdout] FAIL: decb
[stdout] FAIL: lock incl
[stdout] FAIL: lock decl
[stdout] FAIL: lock incb
[stdout] FAIL: lock decb
[stdout] FAIL: lock negl
[stdout] FAIL: lock notl
[stdout] FAIL: lock negb
[stdout] FAIL: lock notb
[stdout] FAIL: btcl imm8, r/m
[stdout] FAIL: btcl reg, r/m
[stdout] FAIL: btcq reg, r/m
[stdout] PASS: bsfw r/m, reg
[stdout] PASS: bsfl r/m, reg
[stdout] PASS: bsfq r/m, reg
[stdout] FAIL: bsfq r/m, reg
[stdout] PASS: bsrw r/m, reg
[stdout] PASS: bsrl r/m, reg
[stdout] PASS: bsrq r/m, reg
[stdout] FAIL: bsrq r/m, reg
[stdout] PASS: imul ax, mem
[stdout] PASS: imul eax, mem
[stdout] PASS: imul ax, mem, imm8
[stdout] PASS: imul eax, mem, imm8
[stdout] PASS: imul ax, mem, imm
[stdout] PASS: imul eax, mem, imm
[stdout] PASS: imul rax, mem
[stdout] PASS: imul rax, mem, imm8
[stdout] PASS: imul rax, mem, imm
[stdout] PASS: movdqu (read)
[stdout] PASS: movdqu (write)
[stdout] PASS: movaps (read)
[stdout] PASS: movaps (write)
[stdout] PASS: movapd (read)
[stdout] PASS: movapd (write)
[stdout] PASS: movups (read)
[stdout] PASS: movups (write)
[stdout] PASS: movupd (read)
[stdout] PASS: movupd (write)
[stdout] PASS: movups unaligned
[stdout] PASS: movupd unaligned
[stdout] PASS: unaligned movaps exception
[stdout] PASS: movups unaligned crosspage
[stdout] PASS: movups crosspage exception
[stdout] FAIL: shld (cl)
[stdout] FAIL: shrd (cl)
[stdout] PASS: ltr
[stdout] PASS: cross-page mmio read
[stdout] PASS: cross-page mmio write
[stdout] PASS: string_io_mmio
[stdout] SKIP: MOVBE unsupported by CPU
[stdout] PASS: no fep: #DB occurred after MOV SS
[stdout] FAIL: push $imm8
[stdout] FAIL: push %reg
[stdout] FAIL: push mem
[stdout] FAIL: push $imm
[stdout] FAIL: pop mem
[stdout] PASS: pop mem (2)
[stdout] PASS: pop reg
[stdout] PASS: ret
[stdout] PASS: leave
[stdout] FAIL: enter
[stdout] FAIL: xchg reg, r/m (1)
[stdout] FAIL: xchg reg, r/m (2)
[stdout] FAIL: xchg reg, r/m (3)
[stdout] FAIL: xchg reg, r/m (4)
[stdout] FAIL: xadd reg, r/m (1)
[stdout] FAIL: xadd reg, r/m (2)
[stdout] FAIL: xadd reg, r/m (3)
[stdout] FAIL: xadd reg, r/m (4)
[stdout] PASS: mov %cr8
[stdout] PASS: ljmp
[stdout] PASS: divq (fault)
[stdout] PASS: divq (1)
[stdout] PASS: mulb mem
[stdout] PASS: mulw mem
[stdout] PASS: mull mem
[stdout] PASS: mulq mem
[stdout] FAIL: movq (mmx, read)
[stdout] PASS: movq (mmx, write)
[stdout] FAIL: movb $imm, 0(%rip)
[stdout] PASS: Test ret/iret with a nullified segment
[stdout] PASS: mov null, %ss
[stdout] PASS: mov null, %ss (with ss.rpl != cpl)
[stdout] FAIL: cmovnel
[stdout] PASS: push16
[stdout] PASS: jump to non-canonical address
[stdout] SUMMARY: 136 tests, 68 unexpected failures, 2 skipped
[stdout] ^[[31mFAIL^[[0m emulator (136 tests, 68 unexpected failures, 2 
skipped)

Re: next-20230809: kvm unittest fail: emulator

[Sean Christopherson]

On Thu, Aug 10, 2023, Srikanth Aithal wrote:
> Hello,
> 
> On linux-next 20230809 build kvm emulator unittest failed.
> 
> ===================
> Recreation steps:
> ===================
> 
> 1. git clone https://gitlab.com/kvm-unit-tests/kvm-unit-tests.git
> 2. export QEMU=<location of QEMU binary> I used v8.0.2
> 3. cd kvm-unit-tests/;./configure;make standalone;tests/emulator

What hardware are you running on?  I've tested on a variety of hardware, Intel
and AMD, and haven't observed any problems.

Re: next-20230809: kvm unittest fail: emulator

[Aithal, Srikanth]

On 8/11/2023 4:15 AM, Sean Christopherson wrote:
> On Thu, Aug 10, 2023, Srikanth Aithal wrote:
>> Hello,
>>
>> On linux-next 20230809 build kvm emulator unittest failed.
>>
>> ===================
>> Recreation steps:
>> ===================
>>
>> 1. git clone https://gitlab.com/kvm-unit-tests/kvm-unit-tests.git
>> 2. export QEMU=<location of QEMU binary> I used v8.0.2
>> 3. cd kvm-unit-tests/;./configure;make standalone;tests/emulator
> 
> What hardware are you running on?  I've tested on a variety of hardware, Intel
> and AMD, and haven't observed any problems.
I am running it on Dell PowerEdge r6515. Same tests were passing till 
next-20230808.

Re: next-20230809: kvm unittest fail: emulator

[Sean Christopherson]

On Fri, Aug 11, 2023, Srikanth Aithal wrote:
> On 8/11/2023 4:15 AM, Sean Christopherson wrote:
> > On Thu, Aug 10, 2023, Srikanth Aithal wrote:
> > > Hello,
> > > 
> > > On linux-next 20230809 build kvm emulator unittest failed.
> > > 
> > > ===================
> > > Recreation steps:
> > > ===================
> > > 
> > > 1. git clone https://gitlab.com/kvm-unit-tests/kvm-unit-tests.git
> > > 2. export QEMU=<location of QEMU binary> I used v8.0.2
> > > 3. cd kvm-unit-tests/;./configure;make standalone;tests/emulator
> > 
> > What hardware are you running on?  I've tested on a variety of hardware, Intel
> > and AMD, and haven't observed any problems.
> I am running it on Dell PowerEdge r6515. Same tests were passing till
> next-20230808.

Ah, let me try an actual linux-next build (once I get the darn thing to compile).
I was assuming I broke something in kvm-x86/next and so was testing that.  But I
haven't pushed to kvm-x86/next since 08/03, so presumably the bug came in from
somewhere else.

Ugh, it's probably one of the recent mitigations.  Those things always break stuff
due to getting thrown in without going through the usual channels.

<time passes>

*sigh*  Yep.  Everything is hunky dory until I turn on CONFIG_CPU_SRSO.  I'll dig
into it today.