Re: Bad sequential performance of RAID5 with a lot of disk seeks

[XiaoNi <xni@redhat.com>]

On 10/07/2014 12:44 PM, P. Gautschi wrote:
> I've created a RAID5 on 5 identical SATA disks. Doing some performance 
> measurements
> with dd I get a disappointing performance.
> A dd with bs=1M on a btrfs created on md0 transfers about 110 MB/s. 
> (both read and write)
> A dd on md0 has the same write speed but only about 20 MB/s on read.
> In all of the tests I hear the disk constantly seeking. This was also 
> the case
> during creation of the array.
> I also created a RAID4 to make sure that I doesn't get fooled by the 
> stripe layout of RAID5.
> Now I get about 110 MB/s for write and 230 MB/s for read on md0. But 
> the constant
> seeking is still present for both read and write and during creation 
> of the array.
>
> Why are the disk perform so many seek operations? I think a sequential 
> access on md0 should
> cause a sequential access on the individual disk.
Hi P. Gautschi

     How can you find the seek operations? Do you use blktrace or other 
commands? Can you give the
detail commands and informations?

     BTW, I think ever if you use larger chunksize when create raid, 
there is few RMW. There is a period to wait for full write.
>
> I have to add that I did something unusual: I created the RAID4/5 with 
> a chunk size of 4KiB.
> The idea of this was that when I'm going to use btrfs with the default 
> nodesize of 16KiB
> all node write will fill a full stripe and there won't be any RMW at 
> all. (both fortunate
> for performance and integrity in a power loss situation.)
> Nevertheless I think a sequential access on the array should cause a 
> sequential access on the
> disks for any chunk size if the read/write block size is a exact 
> multiple of
> the (numdisks-1)*chunk size.
>
> Is there any explanation for the seeks and how do I get rid of them?
>
> Patrick
> -- 
> To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-raid" in
> the body of a message to majordomo@vger.kernel.org
> More majordomo info at  http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html