BK: scsi-misc cs inconsistencies?

BK: scsi-misc cs inconsistencies?

[Guennadi Liakhovetski]

Hello

I've searched scsi-misc cs-entries on bk, and they don't seem to be quite 
consistent:

Linux kernel tree Search results for "tmscsim" in ChangeSet comments

Filename  Rev		Match

ChangeSet 1.1861	[PATCH] tmscsim: kernel bugzilla bug #2139 
ChangeSet 1.1760.31.6	[PATCH] kill obsolete typedefs and wrappers from tmscsim 
ChangeSet 1.1760.31.5	[PATCH] some tmscsim consolidation 
(6)
ChangeSet 1.1760.31.5	> I've looked through my old tmscsim patch queue and found this one: 
(7)
ChangeSet 1.1739.2.17	[PATCH] tmscsim: host_lock use in LLD 
(1)
ChangeSet 1.1739.2.17	While reviewing tmscsim, I noticed something, I didn't quite like / 
(2)
ChangeSet 1.1739.2.16	[PATCH] tmscsim: init / exit cleanup 
ChangeSet 1.1722.73.26	[PATCH] tmscsim: 64-bit cleanup 
(3)
ChangeSet 1.1722.73.26	tmscsim.c. 
(4)
ChangeSet 1.1722.73.5	[PATCH] tmscsim: Store pDCB in device->hostdata 
ChangeSet 1.1722.45.17	[PATCH] tmscsim: convert to slave_... 
ChangeSet 1.1722.45.15	[PATCH] tmscsim: remove DeviceCnt 
ChangeSet 1.1722.45.14	[PATCH] tmscsim: Update version after "new API" 
ChangeSet 1.1612.6.20	[PATCH] tmscsim: trivial updates 
ChangeSet 1.1612.6.14	[PATCH] tmscsim: remove legacy and void code 
ChangeSet 1.1612.6.13	tmscsim: remove procfs write support from tmscsim 
ChangeSet 1.1612.6.11	[PATCH] tmscsim: no internal queue 
ChangeSet 1.1612.6.9	[PATCH] tmscsim: 64-bit cleanup 
(5)
ChangeSet 1.1371.1.378	[PATCH] Fix tmscsim on amd64 
ChangeSet 1.1371.94.3	SCSI: Fix tmscsim driver 
ChangeSet 1.1046.250.59	PCI: remove pci_present() from drivers/scsi/tmscsim.c

Here, (6), (7); (1), (2); and (3), (4) have the same cs-number, (3) and 
(5) have the same description. Is it a problem with the BK itself, or with 
the way these entries have been committed? In the former case I can 
forward this to Larry / BitMover support / whatever. Or is just my 
understanding wrong and all those fields do not have to be unique?...

Thanks
Guennadi
---
Guennadi Liakhovetski

Re: BK: scsi-misc cs inconsistencies?

[James Bottomley]

On Wed, 2004-07-14 at 05:24, Guennadi Liakhovetski wrote:
> Hello
> 
> I've searched scsi-misc cs-entries on bk, and they don't seem to be quite 
> consistent:
> 
> Linux kernel tree Search results for "tmscsim" in ChangeSet comments

If you mean you searched through the bk commits list, then yes, this is
what you see since change sets can renumber as trees are combined.

James

Re: BK: scsi-misc cs inconsistencies?

[Guennadi Liakhovetski]

On Wed, 14 Jul 2004, James Bottomley wrote:

> On Wed, 2004-07-14 at 05:24, Guennadi Liakhovetski wrote:
>> Hello
>>
>> I've searched scsi-misc cs-entries on bk, and they don't seem to be quite
>> consistent:
>>
>> Linux kernel tree Search results for "tmscsim" in ChangeSet comments
>
> If you mean you searched through the bk commits list, then yes, this is
> what you see since change sets can renumber as trees are combined.

Well, I just went to http://linux-scsi.bkbits.net:8080/scsi-misc-2.6 
entered a search term and pressed SEARCH, thus searching in changeset 
comments. If you mean, that 2 different changesets can appear in the 
resulting list with the same number, then this is useless, as only one of 
them can be viewed - links point to the same address. If on the other 
hand, this is the same patch, just occurring twice, well, that's just a 
bit confusing, but at least no information gets lost.

Thanks and sorry for OT.
Guennadi
---
Guennadi Liakhovetski