Re: [PATCH] rfkill: create useful userspace interface

[Marcel Holtmann <marcel@holtmann.org>]

Hi Henrique,

> > 3G cards have two ways of being killed:
> > 
> > 1) Put them to sleep; Sierra for example has code that does this
> > already, it will take the modem out of D3 sleep on startup.  No reason
> > why rfkill couldn't just stick it back there.  Drivers that implement
> > this method would be easy to integrate with rfkill if the BIOS/platform
> > module doesn't do it for them (hp-wmi will drop the 3G card off the bus
> > on the 2530p when you rfkill it, just like bluetooth, so nothing else is
> > needed there).
> 
> thinkpads will power down the card (and obviously kick it off-bus), as
> well.  This is how they disable bluetooth and 3G.
> 
> I have code in thinkpad-acpi that tells the fw to power these radios
> down during sleep, and resume with them powered off.  Needs to be
> unbroken to not do that on wake devices one of these days (_if_ the
> thinkpad supports bluetooth or wwan as wake devices, something I also
> have to find out).
> 
> BTW: please do send me a note of how you guys will want to do sleep/
> resume with the new core, I probably will have to adjust thinkpad-acpi
> to play well with it.
> 
> > 2) CFUN=0; that is supposed to shut down all radios, but of course that
> > requires the serial port of the card and the firmware to be loaded and
> > whatever.  And that should only be done by the daemon (if any, like
> > ModemManager or Wader or whatever) that is arbitrating the serial port.
> > That's not something that rfkilld should do.
> 
> And, to make matters worse, you are likely to find that lots of devices
> screw that up (probably by just ignoring it silently) :-(  The people
> writing the firmware for these modems do an even worse job than the
> people writing ACPI BIOSes...

I was talking about the external 3G cards. So besides the Option HSO,
that has a RFKILL switch, we have no control right now.

For all the built-in ones, I just expect that we have a platform RFKILL
switch that does the right thing. Naive, but good enough for now :(

Regards

Marcel