Re: Review: xfs_repair fixes for dir2 corruption

[Madan Valluri <mvalluri@sgi.com>]

Nathan Scott wrote:
> On Fri, Jul 28, 2006 at 11:58:52AM +1000, Barry Naujok wrote:
>   
>> This patch addresses the following xfs_repair issues:
>>     
>
> The libxfs cache stuff looks good to me.  Maybe Madan can cast
> an eye over the repair changes for ya?
>
> cheers.
>
>   
>>  
1) Since dir_hash_add can be called for both V1 and V2 directories its 
second parameter type xfs_dir2_dataptr_t should be neutral.
2) In dir_hash_add when dup is set, do you still need to add to the 
nextbyhash by list?
3) The following statement in   longform_dir2_rebuild looks odd. 
Besides, FWIW, you can match "/."

                if (p->name[0] == '/' || (p->name[0] == '.' && 
(p->namelen == 1
                                || (p->namelen == 2 && p->name[1] == '.'))))
                        continue;

Consider:

               if (((p->name[0] == '/' || p->name[0] == '.') && 
p->namelen == 1) ||
                        (p->name[0] == '.' && p->name[1] == '.' && 
p->namelen == 2))
                        continue;

4) Related to items 2&3, shouldn't the code be skipping duplicate entries?
5) Can we do anything to minimize the do_error calls in 
longform_dir2_rebuild? Seems like on a full file system, while 
rebuilding say the root directory, matters can get wacky - The directory 
is being rebuilt and we have no further room. Sounds like that this how 
it has been....

Thanks.

/Madan