Re: [RFC PATCH v2 01/12] Add sys_hotplug.h for system device hotplug framework

[Greg KH <gregkh@linuxfoundation.org>]

On Thu, Jan 10, 2013 at 04:40:19PM -0700, Toshi Kani wrote:
> +/*
> + * Hot-plug device information
> + */

Again, stop it with the "generic" hotplug term here, and everywhere
else.  You are doing a very _specific_ type of hotplug devices, so spell
it out.  We've worked hard to hotplug _everything_ in Linux, you are
going to confuse a lot of people with this type of terms.

> +union shp_dev_info {
> +	struct shp_cpu {
> +		u32		cpu_id;
> +	} cpu;

What is this?  Why not point to the system device for the cpu?

> +	struct shp_memory {
> +		int		node;
> +		u64		start_addr;
> +		u64		length;
> +	} mem;

Same here, why not point to the system device?

> +	struct shp_hostbridge {
> +	} hb;
> +
> +	struct shp_node {
> +	} node;

What happened here with these?  Empty structures?  Huh?

> +};
> +
> +struct shp_device {
> +	struct list_head	list;
> +	struct device		*device;

No, make it a "real" device, embed the device into it.

But, again, I'm going to ask why you aren't using the existing cpu /
memory / bridge / node devices that we have in the kernel.  Please use
them, or give me a _really_ good reason why they will not work.

> +	enum shp_class		class;
> +	union shp_dev_info	info;
> +};
> +
> +/*
> + * Hot-plug request
> + */
> +struct shp_request {
> +	/* common info */
> +	enum shp_operation	operation;	/* operation */
> +
> +	/* hot-plug event info: only valid for hot-plug operations */
> +	void			*handle;	/* FW handle */
> +	u32			event;		/* FW event */

What is this?

greg k-h