Re: [PATCH] [v2] power/fsl: add MDIO dt binding for FMan

[Emil Medve <Emilian.Medve@Freescale.com>]

Hello Scott,


On 12/22/2014 03:42 AM, Scott Wood wrote:
> On Mon, 2014-12-22 at 03:37 -0600, Emil Medve wrote:
>> Hello Scott,
>>
>>
>> On 12/22/2014 02:32 AM, Scott Wood wrote:
>>> On Mon, 2014-12-22 at 02:20 -0600, Emil Medve wrote:
>>>> For the purpose of an example in the binding document, I suggest we just
>>>> stick with the IEEE standard frequency.
>>>
>>> The whole reason for this property existing in the device tree is
>>> non-standard frequencies.
>>
>> While the standard claims 2.5 MHz, most MDIO controllers and PHY devices
>> support frequencies well beyond the standard. Specifying a lower then
>> the standard frequency for the benefit of some errata is just one side
>> of this property
> 
> The erratum was (until now) the only claimed reason for it.  If there
> are other reasons why one would specify a different frequency (in
> particular, that relate to hardware description), please elaborate.

>From memory, the 1 Gb/s Vitesse PHY(s) we have on some of our DS boards
support 12.5 MHz. I can dig out more specs for specifics on other PHY(s)

2.5 MHz is slow and even more so for high speed interfaces. With both
polling and interrupts (both MDIO and/or PHY) we've noticed (or blamed)
in the past some Ethernet performance issues on this very slowness

As of right now I'm not aware of another way to specify/coordinate the
MDC speed so setting a default (common denominator) in the DT that is
different then the IEEE standard seems ok

>>>> We can continue this conversation about errata handling when we submit
>>>> the code relevant to this binding (and the FMan v3 support)
>>>
>>> It affects the binding, so let's discuss it now please.
>>
>> I think this specific (unpublished yet) errata has less bearing on the
>> binding then you might believe. This is mostly about providing a
>> common/default frequency supported by all the devices on some board
> 
> What reason other than an erratum would there be for the standard
> frequency not being supported?

This is not about not supporting the standard frequency. This is about
the default frequency being different then the standard


Cheers,