From mboxrd@z Thu Jan 1 00:00:00 1970 Received: from mout.gmx.net (mout.gmx.net [212.227.17.20]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES256-GCM-SHA384 (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by smtp.subspace.kernel.org (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 4EF2B2C1598 for ; Fri, 6 Feb 2026 11:11:47 +0000 (UTC) Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; arc=none smtp.client-ip=212.227.17.20 ARC-Seal:i=1; a=rsa-sha256; d=subspace.kernel.org; s=arc-20240116; t=1770376308; cv=none; b=cnQFHgBmWE91KeNAo/vSYlUPuG7YqqaGPwzRL+B/DNqX+M09wmRsllI14gMvJoZylly10eqatJeOOq8hO+7/scfW6+yWt+hGxtt9Xc/KavP94J0HRTsbR+jDpL7QKh3+7fQaAgbiFMnCbS+mZ35Sydy1jhoI2nZCXfF/L4w1Bc8= ARC-Message-Signature:i=1; a=rsa-sha256; d=subspace.kernel.org; s=arc-20240116; t=1770376308; c=relaxed/simple; bh=JH+GVFbrZzRNhKJ5kHBFhwcKvUHF7iExiI1ivhHTe+A=; h=From:To:Subject:Date:Message-ID:MIME-Version:Content-Type; b=qHMsNrv1RTfUVQbrRCF/9LmMyMaFL9wuhrjet/TkXgmuHZX696pZ16qjo8gK+k5NBNEihUw7Q5jhQ5W/1f+2XXCXzC5q21m42oVMnbEhTSCCcu5KKC1SsWWLfhp08KXdL71KkuRouDRwdA781laF7OP585fiBOPneDVjdHMxa68= ARC-Authentication-Results:i=1; smtp.subspace.kernel.org; dmarc=pass (p=quarantine dis=none) header.from=gmx.de; spf=pass smtp.mailfrom=gmx.de; dkim=pass (2048-bit key) header.d=gmx.de header.i=markus.stockhausen@gmx.de header.b=JG1bh50R; arc=none smtp.client-ip=212.227.17.20 Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; dmarc=pass (p=quarantine dis=none) header.from=gmx.de Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; spf=pass smtp.mailfrom=gmx.de Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; dkim=pass (2048-bit key) header.d=gmx.de header.i=markus.stockhausen@gmx.de header.b="JG1bh50R" DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=gmx.de; s=s31663417; t=1770376281; x=1770981081; i=markus.stockhausen@gmx.de; bh=6pbjVftfuhX7sjlpGyIlWfyKRezA3LDKNaBQxAv1RMM=; h=X-UI-Sender-Class:From:To:Subject:Date:Message-ID:MIME-Version: Content-Type:Content-Transfer-Encoding:cc: content-transfer-encoding:content-type:date:from:message-id: mime-version:reply-to:subject:to; b=JG1bh50R10z904S4OfXr0aaOwraoNej/WLxEEkyUPq4BieB6PL/OAri63ybip08Y FlzXbtt5+qUT+GwPzreb9X0fzsmYMz2iitciaQcBpkUyI/jwoQqaj270ymo15de4/ ZkRx4smCzKcp/n5KJCR//vmdMrA+dgv28W9skgEZ/Ost/Go1kLwrdJWlLO9fh5N79 ryuHZvSsnDwetssjBG9ly9lCvfEwktXW7m08U0tLVgKIUdFcBcEL1KZNuGaPLGH3M dFJ/ejk1niqrauZUHsEQxidwaqZrGVJkDstQyGpDScZ8OG8wOWvZuq4t/+EhCyz/p xxB02C4wmK9X7cKynw== X-UI-Sender-Class: 724b4f7f-cbec-4199-ad4e-598c01a50d3a Received: from colnote55 ([94.31.93.28]) by mail.gmx.net (mrgmx105 [212.227.17.168]) with ESMTPSA (Nemesis) id 1MbzuB-1vGLdW12Eh-00q72d; Fri, 06 Feb 2026 12:11:21 +0100 From: To: "'Ahmed Naseef'" , , , , , Subject: RE: [PATCH] mtd: nand: realtek-ecc: relax OOB size check to minimum Date: Fri, 6 Feb 2026 12:11:20 +0100 Message-ID: <028201dc9759$52e364f0$f8aa2ed0$@gmx.de> Precedence: bulk X-Mailing-List: linux-kernel@vger.kernel.org List-Id: List-Subscribe: List-Unsubscribe: MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset="UTF-8" Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable X-Mailer: Microsoft Outlook 16.0 Thread-Index: AdyXWVHokLSp1g2rTue+wHksGiEs7Q== Content-Language: de X-Provags-ID: V03:K1:J0FXwJ9nuVJ4z0ywD2PZm8cOdRnPbkAKQ5DA0S260kWGjCxSyMO oIjuYPhJVnhG4X+//ibCTk0k2E7jqqbz17dTvwxaqD0suPOfmYf2OncmheIB850K9oeqiYS cItH8fx18W98Dwaw1nGsqrJJjtCnuQs7mah/WuEDvSACIEnUmzlWzPlUAVG2OOC4pxWz0QN dPEqk5mPn4E5Nnb/eNsVg== X-Spam-Flag: NO UI-OutboundReport: notjunk:1;M01:P0:U0I/WQ2Gngs=;FbauZGhjC6kP344pyp+HFbMmAIo tCIPsx4lqVVJ8/A5tuQxOIKrmibNIRA6b+H12CegIanB74CtNuG71MOuzw4nMzRcCfEGYRfaF ecdethQ0iYq6jYG8qIpyFt4mWECnpk1XNLb/vSiHTkcFX2cSaPyB2PHUXB8B3iOnvujCcZ9aK WlKAZ7otfoNuvU2/f/UXKKEiRbpmbtYs1Ek60m5dzRIlsgPus6gCeiaSwicS4UKV2l4yj64Qr 6Gyo2lf9Jmmn1fmLzx/0zp3e5j4y4/qHSMp0lVu6Q53vik9II5wLwxYAi9iMjgPDa46Py/Fm6 MEnosdCUAUWWXAnoC+faXYMrC2Ilw0A81hiSC1Ph6BSaaGI23KP9PKFhKRKnsYnrE3kfGBQkc bi9yf9wIGTAOcifyUgzHnbr8Uow9AkBE5VVFwB9Cm14F124cw0GS9lVlJkf1mPJ4LQoe4xSMQ daQ7ma97oOO7x1Vk1UCEcCHREGFjUwSgM0bDVnLqGrsdoI4QF60+yV/yPA4DR/n4Z3ZSHD7qI DJt2qjfhGnyTAcx2APkBaAkObevmoaypmEsrxgqtk+RV7fnoJqBArPQjAc47vmGgGTefsQp9E NtZPb6cagrzqV1Np6TAtL6kzUNj3T/3SpR4AxxwjebfVwPYuQgtsUx53yK90rHw70aNErhc47 o8onqo5ChO5YjimAFXwOIO9J4P1faARt1yf1HPmAiQibVEO/Dt3DftgLlSGa1yp9Y7cqoQrVr CDwUuiKC3Ce+YoyCGNNECcUIN0Y3qrpGZUwvZrkCw9chAUubaBtKIeSERR+W0edssPufDP74z VweImTjAf7GNQACST5X8HDFn+KyWYEGMhqW1JXheni5o8v00IdRHRsWIXXeDJuVaGBQ7gB1sz 8wZ18nGtZfj2b9Gq56xlLQB/w+n7veLlOaWlYJgUW1afUFkb95CcvOT5mhAROGH789pYrkaF+ 0R9gU/pj27+Uk9vNugjZ97eQxUMMVP1AvorKFGWuKzvdV6769hcf9EqQ6q/iib1oADSqwHnmI z+5CYEwP+eS72dOlSWiszm4pBzWk6UnCfCviLw4UxFHEglzkOr4Lk2s5VqXg3IUkZFwFCq9Np ekNGBZRBgZPrIbNRYuzzWoz8CWnHGbUnh+Lv15oRzqI8LrJ/u8z9gV6KGMqGPweDkaufNNW3F xs1wnDq+UmYfn2/+J3wVGkMwfHYLSaLsNtYe3XodDjhHS6VfH6Vyo3AtPO3vDcT2+TR2LSuC3 +gnLGfUS07shZaEchTakT31LIvVZJtdlZmy3rHFspHA0QtP3PxuPxpxC5cpSalBieX/Q1ZT/u rxcgDKU98CK+yYq+SyRkzcDaoMtmCALLDVo+gKpnmWLCR1guV84iLHt0MSkr0fkDp43V+w+00 d2paFf/PGKiFqgU23RIcEvglpLW8TkkAe2ehN92tsdUn3kyYMxJeK2/r7hRLq9X8eC1zd/bv+ 5Mm8kcbL7iswb6sym4BjIf93tSyLLXzL4GeKFGIu9M630iJAqmfKHZDUnUMJtOJu9QKTTT6iU zt0HhTrHH0kBzoM6XRhiugHa79kIIVc8eTd3c9b86avLthl781Koz8Q16pwMZcJapgsmK0STl 4/qI9Z2hFS1JSRcl7j15B79ASvxU+5QIvk4QyKV/AZFANVXz+jo5+ZD+kZAOg6Q9Bjj3p8SUY 4MD/oLQhLU+n2jfS1ocdaa2fiSrv76bFuxj6402QXRONujjisy3K/BHRUlhTNk0reL/Cie6gv krouiaHSxCBzs78+pP/YVl03CHPMhlCsal4f76W/9nzgSaFZEnS0BM6oQtG+0oJ0FqC2x7jYK Olqs6Sg5dFhBoMnG9hnRL3qnK1ydIsvHMj/jInNBlsKjgHTxSI/rtLVbxniwlLBg3TLYJ3fGw owrJXGT23Atxj94EvFeSaYDsl7Ed1k/ypvUg5mIipYbwf1uRrldX1A7jUWdJfSK2H/41ddHvd 1P0ZyOtlEEWl8IhKxNS21kt+F/RPwPexO1fJ0YYx1hoGhHPU5UmwhvWSu6vGshKq2u+oHbFtn nXj8F/k40Li/199sk7zUhhKEG+aXjl5p+lXhGp0PL3QXbAh+TwDIPgoFhtonCOGxrzovCkkMd X8yb6C1YueI1DSHYU4dQObGcpLsh86I9l1vpSNiw3qfwGwopndbS7Bdp0EheCgrXtxDtIJpML 368moa9osRKkDJvLMsL9A8HEhQVgHktxC81u0Cwlt8Qhnk6NZcfCzF/LINm95x+thqnGCFSgo QNsOryXkR91n62r9UXNBKUhICwKX8FUY6XK5v3hzeTdcisfMrlmAOUhS1braxpsyI/tgBMI67 JUfWxaMIe44C650snA/ijU8pjptz2RuYazlSHntV6RqjhW9fBpcXmmrWNSO6+9cAiz9CzJyeX bGkjii1BdEUj7dVyW9MUSaCw0XC9SBerJCD2MMVHjN2+0z/TxTa6DOdHmMiIZIufvOurQtt9G a8zqAKAp+e+JJBaP4TB2Eh3ESeRExQiCGoD7Ie15+hAcmWuVMqO+W/ZXcAX0v1ch8hBh5WXQw s0oO59bdEl1+wUH/cdpVw4fkFWdM2t45QkIX5ZHPVwOzC5Ck+kHSZOR20DWODepDPThyXP10g 6wCXn4Jbf0GylqC424kFtscBJJknGPyJqeTBS4u7ZsTuUGfKPLpykzb/REpREoOD4Nf44XUUU 4d9xwPk+rTp5Dv5a1NRyLSYQWH0rXf3rfzoINej2vgvKZQdEQXwq8As0u9dD+/vzxdpdyje53 0Z6h7/aLrC2Bm6XJpIHc+gVZxeFbHCwbxvXY95QtGYnORLgmtzGUkTQNRZGeTBVi7CPOU9Ouv CO8dYvNK38uiumiAnyLuAeRORZsCnFKiJWcvdiO12yaei0cNN1/FWZBbdN9np3fnudzbkszLW ghMT5iBwZHsX3oYJ7Rlv8aPkDLmiBn42nXwB/UsPkwlCUBoLEMx6FRc7ucI68fQQReln34Kwa 84rYbzAmjAqIv8bogbrGRysI8H9hqVD2NxsZ632tEOy3zSBZnRHDF01YMVAsb1YpWc4epWQYv DjumWPHlLyU423MiS4TU3oRnO23/o++SdO1RjFq5pvYvm+0cs0/L/mxpXAf6cYlmn7hzUzqAY xP7mUTscvMRQadqCo0TfaI0+qm3aQPpepRPsFMSFStuetT0Pl6parSHhok6Rjx1h2sinEKBiQ bnmrtvq/HsQ/5u8QOA+H5+ckzI7uSk1MZLI+ZTWpZgUg0fBzY3Z9yFbJ7RkQAZORosj4xNWG9 vyyUM9Qzk24TXKYgaYSrdDQNAVMKUe+U9YllQSEO9p0Wo+9MrEGlYXB91J5Q7vyjymKqQxn7F O/Uij8nRlLlZM8NE7fRCqOOmQ7QGLFljyJaJW8AdVOA2jNPMciiR72/Ix8u0n70s8uZ9wmsrj 6/RDucf5NpeAM0SMWFYnba6YTe3i40g+jbn/Az/GVi5wbPVMyGx/inlUwLO7nLQepSgYuppQC x/PzYHLPpjClwl4lr9N4OgUQMcRgPflJNugAaDiC6SFLg2OlLlXO0YjojHwtbELMQcA/kPwBW 8TkgtiMV/YNV4bizu7thPAcoP7F8NV4ECkqtuUUIAKjkehs8MsHXD2y2yQsXr2XuLI4JIVP3l cWJdo3HMkMW4lrgNtv+vfs908RyFO9TOarVn+M+ZIY76WElL4Ath+A6K6BDPfz/S6wHIVPxql OjKIn2WUuyN7iOCXycBI6HpDIvAwO+VaIb5nRDwKTPQgCmD1rl/f9zt2nX0dV6i0fNSkjaO/o NuiMP8Iyx9ARuvinR6Jhdm8zSa1e7vEI72oPJ80vHdelzUbOakFynGtR1VVkzbVJ9RukJmoUU nLF7Eb5SJHyVvxQGgY5y6g2Th7xKBhYsUQBKySz9id2g9f3EvNBwGjDwY3H/tMUXlE3j7BZ3H rYw7w1Nhr0JbB6lEmdr1N+oJMY5veCmUPe7lu+SEVToOSfKsWR300Ax2hy7mZFheVqSXSqrli WVCPn133ZPmoQ4m1HlMLVXDd6wgC/MfNM+BKqPTEieIB1niAHmPikTjd5ZUPDmvdqq69rJerq 8JDPvPaOIib+ix6hO6llxVdIOomBBdenmSopoZYwygrpAiW8i8WHCBxWTEtlQ1O6PPBrDpOI+ ceNaIPu6mCePn9B3dxMg7qiwIuzzMWcBtIQ39+KYnSDlSZ0yuXhekuZn5Y+eMW27PlsCgB+JG 5ww/N2hn7p17I8UHZv/gaGW3jNcA4021Drs39ilqQ0C9xOSv2mwCKWBNLW2xTQEctDh6ZgM7H Bg0jWHdiarI7ITw9Ga+vCSS90rsDMQOODYqaai3LuH9rPEb3mZ1Lbgc1X1YD7bUxnqphpp2Uu 1V/DrkuNsqqmqLlNB2xK0MJYmhQjNzPTGBtKRghfqsBJsbiKFSoefOpmJJOeFzsl/4uoqBIKW GHC1nDvOu3v2BxuwPo2x3NPIxqw/+Po0C4r2yrz+HsogaPdF+6jdkvruRsTvQU6RVehV2v9ph 1cGqhWqFMFO7fznAcQ2G1/sbWbNhcHcKhMF7rGUizh0Tok7DjutY/WccTolvbnlFOb52JhB/B lAx8agtP0x67iQ8Z/4PDqOH1Dx+kWkiurRWzkSUgjtu7QmLcGgKIltTaWMo/f0UnBxes9iIab i/IEM0V4I+8ZrSWkoEmL6/2JrfnFEF0AvYWtG2Ty1ZKl6PPGCHPonktb3mws4f2mwbrATNz2q mxCmRKJ7hJnxOz5+b8lO15o6N7UMoS7yTyharw5E1CGRjAdlpyJmIHRuUP++hy6l9e8vw3zzT BMFcxApy8uLwEnLCGbQ3O3ytpGSEkRqXKc+CIuIzJZA5g2jXc/fv35Cu1xvXf21hKop7J+/mO 4vLtK9/j9goa0axoykIJ7S7WRSj0YHl1uan2+tE6IxYlUuKrxvxHlX+gUkDsmlZaOZlFr0KYX BBHhQ2cet5XGUXyWODd9//X0mhh+hrKpJmLJzwesSVGB6D57FqaybhEkn8uf5fg3m1kYscRYk gnRnQKelv9Wg/VLmWpsE7S/rSNRY1x9uxYEDt+WJrMQohtFJdsU89+bOr0QYYx4ilx21ZEXBf 0+irSZoXD6eVmu0FkMO3QsRt+kIGzuCHeTqTs45qSMiZxIDx01QGd2o4wpsh85cu3maI0IRNV K0ERe04Z7RGZF5DLNBI9gu0KUwIOGknhQCkQiVZcCnkO0BYYjj4T3JBntFy+4JnOmcCT1Pl1Z j1odUS3bdvZ3CbXoQpE7l6J9RhiTo Hi Ahmed, thanks for that finding. > Von: Ahmed Naseef =20 > Gesendet: Freitag, 6. Februar 2026 11:58 > Betreff: [PATCH] mtd: nand: realtek-ecc: relax OOB size check to = minimum > > ... > > Signed-off-by: Ahmed Naseef > Suggested-by: Markus Stockhausen IIRC this should be the other way round. > ... > * are only two known devices in the wild that have NAND flash and = make use of this ECC engine > * (Linksys LGS328C & LGS352C). To keep compatibility with vendor = firmware, new modes can only Now it is more than these two devices. Please adapt the whole = description so it gives a consistent explanation. Markus