Re: [PATCH] [request for inclusion] Realtime LSM

Nick Piggin
2005-01-14T03:14:43Z

On Thu, 2005-01-13 at 21:40 -0500, Paul Davis wrote:
> >SCHED_FIFO and SCHED_RR are definitely privileged operations and you
>
> this is the crux of what this whole debate is about. for all of you
> people who think about linux on multi-user systems with network
> connectivity, running servers and so forth, this is clearly a given.
>
> but there is large and growing body of machines that run linux where
> the sole human user of the machine has a strong and overwhelming
> desire to have tasks run with the characteristics offered by
> SCHED_FIFO and/or SCHED_RR. are they still "privileged" operations on
> this class of linux system? what about linux installed on an embedded
> system, with a small LCD screen and the sole purpose of running audio
> apps live? are they still privileged then?
>

I think yes, because their misuse can trivially take down the
machine by definition. So it is still privileged in the context
of that system.

> i think there is room for debate, but its clear that in general,
> SCHED_FIFO/SCHED_RR's "definite" status as privileged operations is
> not clear. we are trying to find ways to provide access to it in ways
> that don't conflict with the other categories of linux systems where
> it clearly needs to be off-limits to unprivileged users.
>

In such a system, sure you could make allowances by elevating
privileges or what have you.

I guess the tricky part is exactly how to make these allowances. I've
joined the thread too late (and don't have the knowledge) to really get
into that... but I just wanted to be clear that watering down SCHED_RR
and SCHED_FIFO basically just makes them no good to anyone.

I personally can't see how a scheduling policy can allow deterministic
access to the CPU without being a privileged operation. If you don't
need deterministic access to the scheduler, then let's talk about why
SCHED_OTHER isn't good enough. If you do, then we're talking about
security access I think.

Nick

http://mobile.yahoo.com.au - Yahoo! Mobile
- Check & compose your email via SMS on your Telstra or Vodafone mobile.