Re: Credentials test patch

[David Howells <dhowells@redhat.com>]

Ulrich Drepper <drepper@gmail.com> wrote:

> In sys_faccessat you temporarily allocate a cred object which is
> discarded in the end.  With a few more macro definitions you could
> create a dup_cred variant which initialized an automatic variable of
> type struct cred.  This way the kmalloc/kfree pair would fall away.

No, you can't.  The filesystems sys_faccessat() then invokes are entitled to
take a reference to it - the SunRPC authentication stuff, for example - so you
can't just preemptively unallocate it as would occur with an automatic variable.

> access is actually used frequently.  For instance, ld.so uses it on
> every startup as a quicker possibility to check for a file which
> usually doesn't exist.  So, speeding up access has some small effect
> on performance.  The resulting code might actually reduce the kernel
> size a bit due to all the checks and calls which go away.

A better way would be to compare fsuid/fsgid to uid/gid and to just take an
extra ref on the incumbent cred object if they're the same, rather than always
allocating a new one.  That, I suspect, would speed up 99.99% of the cases.

David