Re: [ANNOUNCE] System Inactivity Monitor v1.0

[Pavel Machek <pavel@ucw.cz>]

Hi!
> >
> >>    But I still believe it can be out.
> >>
> >> Do you believe it could be a user-space daemon or 
> >what?
> >
> >Yes, what prevents userspace daemon watching 
> >/dev/input/event* to
> >provide this functionality?
> >                                                                        Pavel
> ---
> 
> One possible argument is to allow integrating 
> "input-like" user events
> with other kinds of system-level events that you might 
> want to have
> treated like user activity. For instance, our definition 
> of user
> activity includes: button presses, opening-closing the 
> cover (on a
> phone), and plugging in or removing memory cards, 
> accessories, or
> cables. We actually use a mix of kernel and user-space 
> monitoring,

Well... input already has 'pseudokey' for lid, and yes, you
probably can monitor cover, memory cards and cables from userspace,
already... as you do. Cover, and maybe even cards/cables could be
integrated with input infrastructure, too.

(Still waiting for you to start selling those cool phones in czech
republic :-).

> A user-space monitor also has more opportunity for races 
> - for
> instance, deciding that the inactivity timeout has 
> occurred between
> the time that the user does something and the time that 
> the kernel
> gets a notification up to user space.

Same races are inside kernel, too.

> My own hot button is making sure that the definition of 
> what
> constitutes user activity is managed in exactly one 
> place, whether in
> the kernel or not. My naive model would be to put the 
> response at user
> level, but to provide a single point of definition in 
> the kernel (say,
> /dev/useractivity or the equivalent) that the user-level 
> daemon could
> listen to.

Actually, I believe right solution is to provide one, unified,
monitoring daemon, using whatever interfaces are available. (+ add
missing functionality to the kernel, if neccessary).

							Pavel
-- 
(english) http://www.livejournal.com/~pavelmachek
(cesky, pictures) http://atrey.karlin.mff.cuni.cz/~pavel/picture/horses/blog.html