Re: [PATCH 3/3] net: wireless: bcm43xx: big_buffer_sem semaphore to mutex

[Michael Buesch <mb@bu3sch.de>]

On Friday 14 December 2007 19:45:02 Ray Lee wrote:
> > > One problem related to b43 source code, patch exists, has yet to be
> > > merged upstream.
> >
> > Yeah. A problem preventing a LED from blinking.
> > That's a real regression.... Come on. Stop that bullshit.
> 
> I'm going to say this one last time. If rfkill and rfkill-input aren't
> manually loaded before sb and b43, not one damn thing comes out in
> dmesg. Nothing. Nada. Zilch. Zero. Bupkis. Zot. Null. The only way to
> find out that those modules had to be loaded by hand was to go read
> the bcm43xx-dev archives. Once those were loaded, messages came out in
> dmesg pointing me to the URL for updated firmware.

I'm sorry. The patch that _you_ quoted fixes a blinking LED
and nothing else. It does _not_ fix loading of rfkill or b43 in any way.
It does, however, fix loading of rfkill-input. But the b43 module
operation does _not_ depend in any way on the rfkill-input module, except
the tiny LED that doesn't blink if it's not loaded.
I hope you understood now that the thread on bcm43xx-dev was NOT about
your requirement to load rfkill before b43.

> I have complete current userspace as of yesterday's Ubuntu Hardy Heron
> development archives.

Ok. I will install a copy of Ubuntu Hardy Heron and check if I can
reproduce this.
However the fact that this does not happen on older Ubuntu platforms
and does not happen on Fedora leads to the conclusion that it
is a bug in Hardy Heron that I am not responsible for.

And you also do realise that Hardy Heron is the current development
version of Ubuntu? Development versions have bugs.

> One last thing. I've been nice to you. Please be nice to me.

If you simply stop blaming bugs on me that I am not responsible for
at all, that is a deal. What about filing a bug at the ubuntu bugzilla?

PS:
Note that Ubuntu is known to break the broadcom driver every now and then.
But I can not change that.

-- 
Greetings Michael.