Re: [patch] sched: fix single-depth wchan output

[Ingo Molnar <mingo@elte.hu>]

* Ken Chen <kenchen@google.com> wrote:

> To get a meaningful /proc/<pid>/wchan, one is required to turn on 
> full frame pointer when compile kernel/sched.c on x86 arch.  The 
> enabling of frame pointer applies to entire kernel/sched.c and 
> affects lots of other core scheduler functions that aren't related 
> to wchan's call stack unwind.  This causes unnecessary expansion of 
> stack pointer push and pop on the stack for scheduler functions.  To 
> cut down the cost of frame pointer push/pop, one can use compile 
> time config option 'single-depth wchan'.  However, the 
> 'single-depth' option is broken on x86 due to lack of stack frame 
> marker and simple stack unwind doesn't work, i.e., wchan always 
> produces '0'.
> 
> This patch adds call site location explicitly in thread_struct for 
> schedule() function so that get_wchan() can reliably get the data 
> and at the same time not to overly burden the entire kernel/sched.c 
> with frame pointer generation.  The remove of frame pointer 
> dependency allows compiler to generate better and faster core 
> scheduler code on x86_64.

hm, this adds overhead - and the thing is that WCHAN is rather 
uninformative to begin with (because it's a single dimension), so we 
should phase it out, not expand it.

How about adding a /proc/<PID>/stacktrace file that gives us the stack 
trace of any task in the system? That would be useful for a number of 
other purposes as well, and about 100 times more useful than wchan. 
(often it would be more useful than sysrq-t dumps)

Hm?

	Ingo