Re: ATA 4 KiB sector issues.

[Nikanth Karthikesan <knikanth@suse.de>]

On Thursday 11 March 2010 18:34:56 Theodore Tso wrote:
> On Mar 10, 2010, at 11:19 AM, Damian Lukowski wrote:
> > I have practically no knowledge of Linux' block device drivers,
> > but is this really a partitioning issue? I think the problem is
> > with the filesystems when clustering multiple blocks without
> > knowledge of the sector alignment and sector size of the underlying
> > block device. Maybe it is a better solution to adapt the filesystem
> > buffer routine which reads/writes data from/to the block device?
> 
> No, it's really a partitioning issue.   If the paging subsystem wants a 4k
>  block to fill a particular page, we need to read that 4k block into
>  memory.  If we need to swap out that 4k block, we need to write that 4k
>  block to swap space, or to the memory segment's backing store.   If the
>  partition is misaligned by 512 bytes, this is simply not possible.   The
>  file system has to do what is requested of it by its users, and the
>  reality is that we need to do 4k aligned reads and writes with respect to
>  the beginning of the partition, far more often than not.
> 
> Hence, if we want the best performance on 4k sector drives, the partition
>  needs to be aligned with respect to what is most desirable for the device
>  in question.
> 

I guess, what he meant was, to keep filesystem blocks aligned, even if the 
partition is not. Say if the partition is mis-aligned by 512-bytes, let the 
filesystem waste 4k-512bytes and keep it's blocks aligned. But it might be a 
case of over-engineering, possibly requiring disk format change.

Thanks
Nikanth