Re: [PATCH] Add STMicroelectronics LPS001WP pressure sensor device driver into misc

[Jean Delvare <khali@linux-fr.org>]

On Mon, 14 Mar 2011 21:36:43 +0100, Arnd Bergmann wrote:
> On Monday 14 March 2011 21:18:09 Jean Delvare wrote:
> > Jonathan is correct. Pressure sensors are not hardware monitoring
> > devices, their drivers have nothing to do in drivers/hwmon. This is
> > something for drivers/misc or staging/iio.
> 
> I generally try to prevent people from adding more ad-hoc interfaces
> to drivers/misc. Anything that is called a drivers/misc driver to me
> must qualify as "there can't possibly be a second driver with the
> same semantics", otherwise it should be part of another subsystem
> with clear rules, or be put into its own file system.

I see drivers/misc differently. I see it as "not enough drivers of the
same type to justify a new subsystem". So I encourage people to put
things there in the absence of any suitable subsystem, until someone
gets enough motivation to start such a subsystem. This is more
pragmatic than requesting subsystems to be created upfront.

That being said, staging is another option nowadays.

> While it seems that right now everyone is just trying to keep move
> the driver to some other subsystem, I think it's worth noting that
> it is indeed a useful thing to have the driver, I'm optimistic
> that we can find some place for it. ;-)
> 
> Now how about the IIO stuff? This is the first time I've even
> heard about it. Does it have any major disadvantages besides
> being staging-quality?

This is indeed the major disadvantage. IIO seems to take a lot of time
to move out of staging, although I don't know what the current ETA is.

-- 
Jean Delvare