Re: MTD NAND BCH support for 24 bits/1K of ECC correction?

[Ivan Djelic <ivan.djelic@parrot.com>]

On Thu, Mar 28, 2013 at 10:23:01PM +0000, Aaron Williams wrote:
> Hi all,
> 
> I am trying to clean up our OCTEON NAND flash driver in the Linux kernel 
> and enable support for multi-bit ECC using BCH and am having some 
> issues. I am able to successfully work with NAND flash that requires 4 
> bits ECC per 512 bytes but I am having issues with one of our boards 
> that has a NAND device that requires 24 bits of ECC per 1024 bytes.
> 
> I was wondering if ECC of this magnitude has been successfully tested in 
> the past. By my calculations I should have 42 bytes of ECC per 1K block 
> (m=14, t=24 for 336 bits of ECC data). My problem is that when decoding 
> an encoded block I am seeing that nroots != err in decode_bch() after 
> find_poly_roots(). I am seeing this for all of the blocks I attempt to 
> read. As far as I can tell the data being sent to BCH is good, though it 
> might have a few bad bits but nowhere near 24.
> 
> I am also seeing this same behavior in my U-Boot code which uses the 
> identical bch and nand_bch code.
> 

Hi Aaron,

CC-ing your message to linux-mtd which is the place to go for such questions :-)

Your configuration (m=14 t=24 with 1024 bytes of data) has been tested, and should work
with the BCH library. Could you give some details about your ECC setup:

1. Are you trying to locate and correct errors from hardware-computed syndromes ?

2. If yes, did you provide the BCH lib with the specific primitive polynomial used by
   your hardware ? What is this polynomial ?

3. Could you provide the ECC bytes generated for the following block patterns:
  - a 0xff-filled 1024 bytes block
  - a 0xff-filled 1024 bytes block, except for the first byte set to 0xfe
  This would help me find out how to setup the library to match your hardware.

Regards,
-- 
Ivan