Re: [PATCH] panic: add TAINT_SOFTLOCKUP

David Rientjes
2014-06-25T00:45:17Z

On Tue, 24 Jun 2014, Josh Hunt wrote:

> Anyone you'd suggest adding to this thread to get other feedback about
> tracking page allocation failures? I could also spin up a patch and cc them.
>

Page allocation failures happen all the time, mostly because of
large-order allocations (more than PAGE_ALLOC_COSTLY_ORDER) or allocations
done with GFP_ATOMIC where it's impossible to reclaim or compact memory to
allocate. Because of this, they are fairly easy to trigger from userspace
without having to do much.

Why would this qualify for a taint? I have never debugged a kernel crash
that I traced back to an earlier page allocation failure and said "oh, if
I had only known about that page allocation failure earlier!". If one of
them is going to cause an issue, it probably is at the point of the crash
and you shouldn't have to "investigate" much.