Re: Linux 3.19-rc3

Kirill A. Shutemov
2015-01-10T00:38:19Z

On Fri, Jan 09, 2015 at 11:27:07PM +0000, Catalin Marinas wrote:
> On Thu, Jan 08, 2015 at 07:21:02PM +0000, Linus Torvalds wrote:
> > The only excuse for 64kB pages is "my hardware TLB is complete crap,
> > and I have very specialized server-only loads".
>
> I would make a slight correction: s/and/or/.
>
> I agree that for a general purpose system (and even systems like web
> hosting servers), 64KB is overkill; 16KB may be a better compromise.
>
> There are however some specialised loads that benefit from this. The
> main example here is virtualisation where if both guest and host use 4
> levels of page tables each (that's what you may get with 4KB pages on
> arm64), a full TLB miss in both stages of translation (the ARM
> terminology for nested page tables) needs up to _24_ memory accesses
> (though cached). Of course, once the TLB warms up, there will be much
> less but for new mmaps you always get some misses.
>
> With 64KB pages (in the host usually), you can reduce the page table
> levels to three or two (the latter for 42-bit VA) or you could even
> couple this with some insanely huge pages (512MB, the next up from 64KB)
> to decrease the number of levels further.
>
> I see three main advantages: the usual reduced TLB pressure (which
> arguably can be solved with bigger TLBs), less TLB misses and, pretty
> important with virtualisation, the cost of the TLB miss due to a reduced
> number of levels. But that's for the user to balance the advantages and
> disadvantages you already mentioned based on the planned workload (e.g.
> host configured with 64KB pages while guests use 4KB).
>
> Another aspect on ARM is the TLB flushing on (large) MP systems. With a
> larger page size, we reduce the number of TLB operation (in-hardware)
> broadcasting between CPUs (we could use non-broadcasting ops and IPIs,
> not sure they are any faster though).

With bigger page size there's also reduction in number of entities to
handle by kernel: less memory occupied by struct pages, fewer pages on
lru, etc.

Managing a lot of memory (TiB scale) with 4k chunks is just insane.
We will need to find a way to cluster memory together to manage it
reasonably. Whether it bigger base page size or some other mechanism.
Maybe THP? ;)

--
Kirill A. Shutemov