RE: [PATCH 1/2] x86/random: Retry on RDSEED failure

Reshetova, Elena
2024-02-14T06:54:18Z

> Ultimately, if CPU's can actually have an architectgural RNG ala
> RDRAND/RDSEED that actually can do the right thing in the face of
> entropy draining attacks, that seems to be a **much** simpler
> solution.

I don’t think anyone would object that the rdrand approach we are
discussing here is simpler. My point (and also Peter original idea) was
that if we want to do it correctly and generically (and *not* just about
confidential computing), we ought to provide a way for users to define
what entropy sources for Linux RNG they are willing to trust or not.
This should not be a policy decision that kernel hardcodes (we try hard
to avoid policies in kernel), but left for users to decide/configure based
on their preferences, trust notions, fears of backdooring, whatelse.
This of course has the flip part that some users will get it wrong, but
reasonable secure defaults can be provided also.

Best Regards,
Elena.