libata support for Adaptec 1205SA?

libata support for Adaptec 1205SA?

[Kevin P. Fleming]

I need to add some SATA ports to a system, not RAID, just plain SATA 
ports. I've found the SIIG SC-SAT212 which is based on the Sil3112A 
chip, but may not fit in my low-profile case. There is also the 
Adaptec 1205SA which already is a low-profile card, but I can't seem 
to find any information on the 'net as to which chip it uses.

Does anyone here know, and more importantly, is libata ready to 
support it? I want to build a 6-drive SATA RAID using software RAID 5 
(can't just the expense of a 3ware card for this application), so I 
need to add four ports to the two already present on an ICH5 on the 
motherboard.

Re: libata support for Adaptec 1205SA?

[Hugo Mills]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 2121 bytes --]

On Fri, Oct 03, 2003 at 08:57:55AM -0700, Kevin P. Fleming wrote:
> I need to add some SATA ports to a system, not RAID, just plain SATA 
> ports. I've found the SIIG SC-SAT212 which is based on the Sil3112A 
> chip, but may not fit in my low-profile case. 

   I just happen to have an SC-SAT212 sitting in front of me, as a
replacement for my Adaptec 1210SA which doesn't work in Linux. :(

   The card is 64mm from the top edge to the bottom of the PCI pins,
and 56mm from the top edge to the edge of the "cutout" on the card
(i.e. the top edge of the PCI slot). Bear in mind though that the SATA
data cable is going to stick up at least 15mm beyond the top of the
card.

> There is also the Adaptec 1205SA which already is a low-profile
> card, but I can't seem to find any information on the 'net as to
> which chip it uses.

   I don't know for certain, *but* the AAR-1210SA definitely uses the
SiI3112 chip (slightly mangled), and I'd be surprised if Adaptec used
a different chip for the 1205SA. There's a picture of the 1210SA card
on Adaptec's site which is just about good enough to see the shape of
the word "SiI" on the chip surface -- there may be an equivalent
picture for the 1205SA.

   Bear in mind, though, that the 1210SA doesn't seem to play exactly
like other SiI3112 cards, and keeps dropping interrupts. This makes it
effectively useless for anything practical. You may want to take this
into account when thinking of Adaptec SATA kit.

> Does anyone here know, and more importantly, is libata ready to 
> support it? I want to build a 6-drive SATA RAID using software RAID 5 
> (can't just the expense of a 3ware card for this application), so I 
> need to add four ports to the two already present on an ICH5 on the 
> motherboard.

   AFAIK, libata doesn't support SiI3112 yet. Jeff has promised it at
some point -- possibly as the next SATA chip to support.

   Hugo.

-- 
=== Hugo Mills: hugo@... carfax.org.uk | darksatanic.net | lug.org.uk ===
  PGP key: 1C335860 from wwwkeys.eu.pgp.net or http://www.carfax.org.uk
           --- There are three mistaiks in this sentance. ---            

[-- Attachment #2: Digital signature --]
[-- Type: application/pgp-signature, Size: 189 bytes --]

Re: libata support for Adaptec 1205SA?

[Jeff Garzik]

Hugo Mills wrote:
>    I don't know for certain, *but* the AAR-1210SA definitely uses the
> SiI3112 chip (slightly mangled), and I'd be surprised if Adaptec used
> a different chip for the 1205SA. There's a picture of the 1210SA card

that's my suspicion too.


>>Does anyone here know, and more importantly, is libata ready to 
>>support it? I want to build a 6-drive SATA RAID using software RAID 5 
>>(can't just the expense of a 3ware card for this application), so I 
>>need to add four ports to the two already present on an ICH5 on the 
>>motherboard.
> 
> 
>    AFAIK, libata doesn't support SiI3112 yet. Jeff has promised it at
> some point -- possibly as the next SATA chip to support.

The driver is posted in the latest snapshot, but it's only for developer 
use right now...  need to acknowledge a few more interrupt events :)

	Jeff