Problem: 2.4.26/27 & 2.6.9 Audio CD Burning

Problem: 2.4.26/27 & 2.6.9 Audio CD Burning

[Steven E. Woolard]

I've reproduced this problem on my system with 2.4.26, 2.4.27, and 
2.6.9. When trying to burn an audio CD with cdrecord, the system load 
average will skyrocket (relitively speaking) up to 4 or 5 sometimes 
reaching 10 or higher. This does not happen with data CD's or at all 
with 2.6.7 kernel. I used scsi emulation (of course) on 2.4.26 and 
2.4.27--not 2.6.9.

Side Notes:
	DMA is enabled, I have tried downgrading cdrtools, and if I 			remember 
correctly it has the same problem in 2.6.8(.1).

Hardware:
	AMD Athlon XP 2400+
	1024MB RAM
	VIA VT82C686 Southbridge (IDE Controller)
	LITE-ON LTR48246S CDRW Drive

Re: Problem: 2.4.26/27 & 2.6.9 Audio CD Burning

[Steven E. Woolard]

Ed Sweetman wrote:
> 2.6.9-ck2 works just fine burning audio cds.  I've had similar trouble 
> with the vanilla kernel burning audio cds.  I think some people even 
> mentioned ripping audio cds now doesn't use dma in vanilla.  I dont 
> really remember, just that whenever the vanilla kernel has had trouble 
> with audio and dma in 2.6, ck kernels have worked.

Well, I tried the ck3 patch ... no improvement. System load still goes 
crazy.

Re: Problem: 2.4.26/27 & 2.6.9 Audio CD Burning

[Bill Davidsen]

Steven E. Woolard wrote:
> I've reproduced this problem on my system with 2.4.26, 2.4.27, and 
> 2.6.9. When trying to burn an audio CD with cdrecord, the system load 
> average will skyrocket (relitively speaking) up to 4 or 5 sometimes 
> reaching 10 or higher. This does not happen with data CD's or at all 
> with 2.6.7 kernel. I used scsi emulation (of course) on 2.4.26 and 
> 2.4.27--not 2.6.9.
> 
> Side Notes:
>     DMA is enabled, I have tried downgrading cdrtools, and if 
> I             remember correctly it has the same problem in 2.6.8(.1).
> 
> Hardware:
>     AMD Athlon XP 2400+
>     1024MB RAM
>     VIA VT82C686 Southbridge (IDE Controller)
>     LITE-ON LTR48246S CDRW Drive

My understanding based on experience is that with a 2.4 kernel you will 
get a high load average burning audio, and the quickest fix is to use 
speed= to slow the burn.

With 2.6 you should get DMA using the ATAPI:/dev/hdX interface, and in 
fact I do see only a few percent CPU burning at 40x (max) and a lowly 
2.0GHz Celeron.

If none of this helps, do run "vmstat 1" to a file while running, and 
post your command line used to start the burn. You might try "ATA:" as 
well for comparison. I don't know if "-dummy" will allow you to test 
without actually burning or not.

-- 
    -bill davidsen (davidsen@tmr.com)
"The secret to procrastination is to put things off until the
  last possible moment - but no longer"  -me