Re: [ACPI] Re: Call for help: list of machines with working S3

[Lorenzo Colitti <lorenzo@colitti.com>]

Matthew Garrett wrote:
>>                Vendor: Hewlett-Packard
>>-               Version: 68BDD Ver. F.0F
>>-               Release Date: 07/23/2004
>>+               Version: 68BDD Ver. F.11
>>+               Release Date: 11/22/2004
> 
> 
> Ok, so you both have different BIOS versions and different CPUs.

S3 works for me with both BIOS F.0F, which I was using before, and F.11, 
which I flashed today after learning it existed.

> Everything else looks pretty identical. Could you both
> stick /proc/acpi/dsdt up somewhere so I can check if there are any
> relevant looking differences?

I would advise trying to compile a custom kernel from scratch with my 
.config first.

I got S3 working first with a very basic kernel config, but I couldn't 
get it to work with my usual kernel. Assuming it was some feature that 
caused the problem, I started disabling features in the hope of getting 
it to work, but I ended up with two different kernels with seemingly 
irrelevant differences, of which one would succesfully resume and one 
wouldn't. So I started added features to the other kernel, and I never 
found out what caused the problem.

I'm not saying that this is not deterministic, but I am saying that, at 
least in my case, it's not obvious what it is that stops S3 from 
working. :-)


Cheers,
Lorenzo