Re: [PATCH] Open Firmware device tree virtual filesystem

Segher Boessenkool
2007-01-03T15:31:26Z

>> Kill OF? sparc does not want that IMO, how else should I return to
>> the 'ok' prompt?
>
> PowerPC kills OF because it really has to,

No it doesn't. It has to on some (very common, heh) subarchs.

> that's one of numerous
> reasons that it started sucking the device tree into a kernel copy
> early in the bootup and using that for device discovery etc.
>
> To be honest, the 'ok' prompt is of limited value when you have
> things like Alt-SysRq and PPC's XMON debugger in the kernel already.

When I ported the PowerPC kernel to a new platform years ago,
the big problems happened *before* any of those methods worked,
at really early boot time (the PowerPC port has become a lot
better since then fwiw, it might be easier now). Running (and
debugging) other client programs was a lot easier, since you
could always drop back to OF on panic conditions so you could
investigate what was going on without using hardware probes.

> In fact, the 'ok' prompt is an ENORMOUS pain in the ass to support
> on machines with USB keyboards, because sharing the USB host
> controller is beyond non-trivial. I've never implemented support
> for that on sparc64 and I frankly have no desire to do the work
> necessary to support that. It simply is not worth it.

Oh yes, USB keyboards, lovely. Use a serial port, or a dedicated
network controller, or similar, for the OF console instead ;-)

Segher