Re: [PATCH 5/9] Make use of permissions, returned by kobj_lookup

[Pavel Emelyanov <xemul@openvz.org>]

Andrew Morton wrote:
> On Fri, 07 Mar 2008 12:22:01 +0300 Pavel Emelyanov <xemul@openvz.org> wrote:
> 
>>> This doesn't include sufficient headers to be compileable.
>>>
>>> I'm sure there are lots of headers like this.  But we regularly need
>>> to fix them.
>>>
>> Not sure, whether this is still relevant after Greg's comments, but that's
>> the -fix patch for this one. (It will cause a conflict with the 9th patch.)
> 
> Well.  Where do we stand with this?  afaict the state of play is:
> 
> Greg: do it in udev
> Pavel: but people want to run old distros in containers

Actually no.

Greg: Use LSM for this
Pavel: My approach just makes maps per-group, while LSM will
       bring a new level of filtering/lookup on device open path

> Realistically, when is the mainline kernel likely to have sufficient
> container functionality which is sufficiently well-tested for people to
> actually be able to do that?  And how much longer will it take for that
> kernel.org functionality to propagate out into non-bleeding-edge distros?

The fact is that we have users of OpenVZ and even Virtuozzo, that still use 
redhat-9 as in containers. So even if this is ready in 5 years, there will 
always be someone who sets the outdated (by that time) fedora-core-8 and find
out, that his udev refuses to work.

> Altogether we're looking at one to three years, aren't we?  By then,
> perhaps a lot of "old" distros are already udev-based.
> 
> otoh, my experience upgrading old kernels to new udev has not been a
> good one (ie: it didn't work).

Agree, but we're talking about making old udev working with new kernel.

>