Re: Slow DOWN, please!!!

david
2008-05-01T19:06:40Z

On Thu, 1 May 2008, Willy Tarreau wrote:

> I also proposed to group merges by reduced overlapping areas, and to
> shorten the merge window and make it (at least) twice as often. Rafael
> also proposed to merge core first, then archs, which is a refined variation
> on the same principle. I'm not sure I've seen your opinion on this.

the problem with trying to make the cycle twice as fast is that it takes
time to hunt down the hard bugs, even when you have some idea where they
are.

go back through the last few kernels and look at the bugs that were fixed
in the last couple of -rc releases (and in final), would they have really
been fixed faster if other changes hadn't taken place?

I suspect that they would not have, and if I'm right the result of merging
half as much wouldn't be twice as many releases, but rather approximatly
the same release schedule with more piling up for the next release.

even individual git trees that do get a fair bit of testing (like
networking for example) run into odd and hard to debug problems when
exposed to a wider set of hardware and loads. having the networking
changes go in every 4 months (with 4 months worth of changes) instead of
every 2 months (with 2 months worth of changes) will just mean that there
will be more problems in this area, and since they will be more
concentrated in that area it will be harder to fix them all fast as the
same group of people are needed for all of them.

if several maintainers think that you are correct that doing a merge with
far fewer changes will be a lot faster, they can test this in the real
world by skipping one release. just send Linus a 'no changes this time'
instead of a pull request. If you are right the stable release will happen
significantly faster and they can say 'I told you so' and in the next
release have a fair chance of convincing other maintainers to skip a
release.

it does worry me a bit that the release cycle seems to be slipping
slightly each release, but I don't see a good way to fix this.

David Lang