Re: [RFD] voltage/current regulator consumer interface

[Mike Rapoport <mike@compulab.co.il>]

James Kosin wrote:
> Mike Rapoport wrote:
>> James Kosin wrote:
>>> Mike Rapoport wrote:
>>>> Hi,
>>>>
>>>> Recently there was a brief discussion on linux-arm-kernel list [1] about
>>>> controlling voltage regulator state in cases when there is no consumer device
>>>> for a particular regulator.
>>>>
>>>> I have some thoughts but I'd like to know people opinion before I start
>>>> implementation.
>>>>
>>>> Problem
>>>> -------
>>>> The regulator framework API provides ability to control the state of
>>>> voltage/current regulators from within the kernel. Usually the regulator
>>>> supplies power to a device and device driver or some hooks to the platform code
>>>> from the device driver manipulate the regulator state. However, the regulator
>>>> framework does not have userspace ABI that allows regulator state modifications.
>>>> Lack of this ABI prevents fine-grained control for power consumption of devices
>>>> such as GPS trancievers and GSM modems. Moreover, in SoC based systems it is
>>>> possible to switch on/off power to entire subsystem when it is not used.
>>>>
>>> I'd also ask the question, Why?
>>> If exposing to user space it leaves the possibility of damaging hardware
>>> or completely frying a board.
>> Suppose you have a handheld device with GPS transceiver. You would like to give
>> user the ability to switch the transceiver on and off.
>>
> 
> Then the GPS drivers should be made aware and let the drivers handle the
> on/off interface.  If a user is allowed to turn interfaces on/off at
> will with this then drivers could suffer from (shock)...  ie: you could
> turn off your hard-drive in a middle of a write by the driver corrupting
> data, if handled in the driver it could finish the write before turning
> off the drive.  I know this is a far stretch from a GPS were the device
> is only READ only.

The point is there's no GPS driver... GPS transceivers are usually connected to
a serial line and the applications access the GPS data through ttySX. The case
when there is a kernel driver for device connected to a regulator is completely
different. It is then the driver responsibility to decide when to power on/off
the device.

> I do agree it could be useful, but we need to be careful on how much
> control the user has over the drivers and system.  To an extreme, a user
> could be able to turn off CPU cores outside of the drivers control
> causing serious pipeline hazards that would need to be handled at the
> driver level.  This would not be an issue for GPS were the data is read
> only and the missing data is really not that important to the system
> operation and continued use.
> 
> James
> 

-- 
Sincerely yours,
Mike.