Re: [PATCH 2/5] usb: xhci: plat: Create both HCDs before adding them

[Roger Quadros <rogerq@ti.com>]

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

On 21/04/15 11:08, Maxime Ripard wrote:
> On Tue, Apr 21, 2015 at 12:49:54PM +0300, Roger Quadros wrote:
>> On 20/04/15 15:35, Mathias Nyman wrote:
>>> Hi
>>>
>>> On 02.04.2015 15:23, Roger Quadros wrote:
>>>> As xhci_hcd is now allocated by usb_create_hcd(), we don't
>>>> need to add the primary HCD before creating the shared HCD.
>>>>
>>>> Creating the shared HCD before adding the primary HCD is particularly
>>>> useful for the OTG use case so that we know at the OTG core if
>>>> the HCD is in single configuration or dual (primary + shared)
>>>> configuration.
>>>>
>>>
>>> This doesn't apply as 
>>>
>>> commit 7b8ef22ea547b80475ac7feab06fb15e0fc143d8
>>>     usb: xhci: plat: Add USB phy support
>>>
>>> changed xhci-plat.c since.
>>>
>>> I rebased it, and the changed version is sitting in the for-usb-next branch in:
>>> git://git.kernel.org/pub/scm/linux/kernel/git/mnyman/xhci.git
>>>
>>> But it appeared to me that usb_add_hcd() and usb_remove_hcd() will also
>>> call phy init and remove functions. As the order how hcds are created and added
>>> would change I'd need some more eyes on this to see if it will cause regression.
>>>
>>> Or maybe in the best case we could get rid of the "Add USB phy support" patch as
>>> we will call xhci_add_hcd() for the first hcd much later, and it could maybe init
>>> the phy for us?
>>
>> I thought usb_phy_*() stuff would be deprecated and we should use
>> phy framework instead i.e. phy_init() and friends.
> 
> Except that all drivers have not been converted yet... So it's not
> really an option until then.
> 
>> In fact usb_add_hcd() is already handling the phy for us.
> 
> If it handles USB phy, then I don't really have an issue with it.

It handles usb_phy as well. It just expects hcd->usb_phy to be set.

cheers,
- -roger
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1
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=OA20
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----