[RFC] new jbd locking

[RFC] new jbd locking

[Alex Tomas]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 1911 bytes --]


hi!

here is new version of the patch. following problems have been fixed
since last one:
- bug in log_do_checkpoint(): some buffer were locked,
  but I/O didn't get started (thanks to Dave Hansen for testing)
- minor memory leak has been fixed
- now b_committed_data is protected from to be freed 
  by journal_commit_transaction()

some benchmarks:

1) dbench
   I have a lot of troubles with dbench because results are very
   unstable and unpredictable. so, I collected results of several
   runs and calculated average thoughput. unfortunately, even average
   numbers are unstable

   dbench 1:    before         after
                73.63975       70.20113
                71.55381       72.89969
                69.54363       70.46640
                72.24077       69.91244

   dbench 2:    before         after
                95.92940       100.22570
                86.85545       90.09191
                90.98304       105.07921
                84.86959       85.68771

   dbench 4:    before         after
                45.64170       53.43416
                48.66928       57.15186
                49.71130       56.51542

   dbench 16:   before         after
                41.13922       52.74798
                50.43494       51.12468
                42.23480       54.16548
                44.76376       53.92670

2) synthetic test

    N (1/2/4) processes write 32 blocks into own file, then truncate file to zero
    and repeat this sequence for 100000 times:

             4/32/100000  2/32/100000  1/32/100000
    before:  11m13.389s   4m48.604s    1m51.323s
    after:   5m38.025s    2m47.733s    1m56.503s


all tests were performed on dual p3-1GHz/512MB/old scsi hdd

you should apply two patches (against 2.5.69-mm6):
1) new locking schema for jbd
2) patch that makes ext3 allocation safe with new locking schema

I'll be happy to see any comments

with best regards, Alex


[-- Attachment #2: jbd-no-bkl-2.5.69-mm6.patch.bz2 --]
[-- Type: application/octet-stream, Size: 20789 bytes --]

[-- Attachment #3: ext3-jbd-nobkl-2.5.69-mm6.patch.bz2 --]
[-- Type: application/octet-stream, Size: 1164 bytes --]