Re: Stelian Pop <stelian.pop@fr.alcove.com>

[ebiederm@xmission.com (Eric W. Biederman)]

jdthood@home.dhs.org (Thomas Hood) writes:

> Stelian Pop wrote:
> >> Well, the funny thing is, the same kernel doesn't boot on a Dell Inspiron 
> >> laptop either, if PNP is enabled -- and the oops is the same. So it's not 
> >> just Sony...
> >
> >Maybe we'll need to test against something like 'pnp_broken' 
> >variable instead of is_sony_vaio_laptop in PnP drivers, and
> >add the callbacks in dmi_scan to initialize pnp_broken...
> 
> Yes, the "pnp_bios_dont_use_current_config" flag in the driver
> can be set based on additional criteria.
> 
> I notice that both the Vaio and the Inspiron have Phoenix BIOSes.
> So perhaps there is a class of Phoenix BIOSes we should be testing
> for.  For the time being, we will need to add Ion Badulescu's Inspiron
> to the dmi_blacklist.  Ion, can you give us the exact product name,
> exact BIOS vendor name, exact BIOS version and exact BIOS date?
> Also, let us know all the results of your tests of various kernels.
> 
> It's interesting to note that my IBM ThinkPad BIOS has a bug that
> is similar to the bug in your BIOS.  After Linux is run, on the
> subsequent boot the "current" config is not initialized from the
> "boot" config; instead, all devices are left disabled.  This does
> not happen if Windows was the previous OS run, or if the BIOS
> is initialized before the boot.  My sneaking suspicion is that this
> behavior is a "feature" of the BIOS: when certain of its functions
> are accessed it deduces that it is being used by a Plug-n-Play
> operating system (tm) and so refrains from configuring devices other
> than the vital ones.  

Hmm. If you are using an AC kernel I seriously suspect the bootflag code,
because that is what the code is telling the BIOS to do explicitly.

> My workaround for now is to use "setpnp" to
> switch on all the configurable devices.  The "right" solution may
> be to use the ESCD functions of the BIOS.  Or it may be to stop
> doing whatever it is that suggests to the BIOS that Linux is a
> PnP OS.

Suggests.  With the bootflag stuff we are saying treat as a pnpos we
know what we are doing.

Eric