From mboxrd@z Thu Jan 1 00:00:00 1970 Received: from mout.gmx.net (mout.gmx.net [212.227.15.19]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES256-GCM-SHA384 (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by smtp.subspace.kernel.org (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 5D23C4418E3; Mon, 29 Jun 2026 17:29:52 +0000 (UTC) Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; arc=none smtp.client-ip=212.227.15.19 ARC-Seal:i=1; a=rsa-sha256; d=subspace.kernel.org; s=arc-20240116; t=1782754194; cv=none; b=DhVzCWrubqODTx84+PtSgUL5ucYG322zBGFU7Rq7LzIFdmkcR3IKFRvlsb66B1SS7Z+VtBLzj3+6s12+oSwPDxrdutFyXhG/N4XtrBLcMIuvZwfH+iF8vDhoM9VqclEPfru4G7YLV7a1wzdkOjNoozdmjVMZBaHpZIiuI8KZgk4= ARC-Message-Signature:i=1; a=rsa-sha256; d=subspace.kernel.org; s=arc-20240116; t=1782754194; c=relaxed/simple; bh=3VAyzXNRFVIW0UFkvirrH4gHGduCRf1oHAuxOzgSmto=; h=From:To:Cc:References:In-Reply-To:Subject:Date:Message-ID: MIME-Version:Content-Type; b=i2/oD8d9dulnejWeqEACrUwegOLT2rE8aAWzz9dE4ITlgxtfjtDpoTRQq4lRto/DZ3EyvGvrlxxeM6gg/UOnp9fskSyc7fNPqDDKJPSqwrJhgeuZ/lb6V+S3OjIfUR614m+h9pGNqdsZ0KNfA1kx60XA4JdECHoBmGd2Vn/UsUg= ARC-Authentication-Results:i=1; smtp.subspace.kernel.org; dmarc=pass (p=quarantine dis=none) header.from=gmx.de; spf=pass smtp.mailfrom=gmx.de; dkim=pass (2048-bit key) header.d=gmx.de header.i=markus.stockhausen@gmx.de header.b=KiN1/xUm; arc=none smtp.client-ip=212.227.15.19 Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; dmarc=pass (p=quarantine dis=none) header.from=gmx.de Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; spf=pass smtp.mailfrom=gmx.de Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; dkim=pass (2048-bit key) header.d=gmx.de header.i=markus.stockhausen@gmx.de header.b="KiN1/xUm" DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=gmx.de; s=s31663417; t=1782754177; x=1783358977; i=markus.stockhausen@gmx.de; bh=3VAyzXNRFVIW0UFkvirrH4gHGduCRf1oHAuxOzgSmto=; h=X-UI-Sender-Class:From:To:Cc:References:In-Reply-To:Subject:Date: Message-ID:MIME-Version:Content-Type:Content-Transfer-Encoding:cc: content-transfer-encoding:content-type:date:from:message-id: mime-version:reply-to:subject:to; b=KiN1/xUm1cjQBkeyb6oi6OX5yVcYuP9CY2dhGsidhFTU7EAdoO1oj4HGfq12ywGV PSEe9wZB9fw43jjuJpFIUEBlwhxFmZUxVyzaTqkjwxY2GQ/N6AAGvBO4e24IUUyd1 5kUEGdUMWO2eyvQZreaR658XOHaUb9U5ZkCZQvcBVWazqEhG5l6gIXUnjYSeCAU5K XToUv38zAwRn+B+C0OCxdE2N6Kb8IpGJuCv2XGF1mVWugxDnC/BiUqugsKoMy9vgH UPNJqv7iYghRRev6EfRcFhqI4a8q1Vh0YHmhGQo4UykF8joV/x3it/Zo1XY0TIyHX /B7n3KYUeFk5FBReyg== X-UI-Sender-Class: 724b4f7f-cbec-4199-ad4e-598c01a50d3a Received: from client.hidden.invalid by mail.gmx.net (mrgmx004 [212.227.17.190]) with ESMTPSA (Nemesis) id 1MzhnH-1x0TU93RhJ-017oN7; Mon, 29 Jun 2026 19:29:36 +0200 From: "Markus Stockhausen" To: "'Andrew Lunn'" Cc: , , , , , , , , , , , , References: <20260629152336.2239826-1-markus.stockhausen@gmx.de> <20260629152336.2239826-6-markus.stockhausen@gmx.de> In-Reply-To: Subject: AW: [PATCH net-next v2 5/8] net: mdio: realtek-rtl9300: Add c45 over c22 mitigation Date: Mon, 29 Jun 2026 19:29:31 +0200 Message-ID: <004401dd07ec$db8f70b0$92ae5210$@gmx.de> Precedence: bulk X-Mailing-List: netdev@vger.kernel.org List-Id: List-Subscribe: List-Unsubscribe: MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii" Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable X-Mailer: Microsoft Outlook 16.0 Thread-Index: AQGLWj2oQThrBp+2CfDhF4qpCxunlgKkR+9CAraA/bC2zk36cA== Content-Language: de X-Provags-ID: V03:K1:L4I2Rl6X0y7r3sM1ZdNTQYM/rJBdZ9eVC0mIGRQiZbg8fqkQYEO q6w8tQ1XLMjBdVh8UOtwO2CY/9MEz56MsMjMqZhSt1254Rr2OtbIdMPmyne3HGyTP0e1bxJ 2Wo0YcB7CGOSpN5xDlzNRH499Hk4lvazlJeobNo8VgAxQzWn07R21epJC57XMALLZEp2EgY JwRUvnFxKIjJNb6geRVMQ== X-Spam-Flag: NO UI-OutboundReport: notjunk:1;M01:P0:SeQCQuYozag=;eELQRvV+xEi7QjcGM2JcOXmRAHo /I6/Wd4ZRo8awbiEnMHtN7qjpPP8q3KqT2pXsOlm36z+cY6Y6nm+a+UwvNDeVaJHJcvq0hxIG Yd/r1QLa+7s23LyJX6PITr+N1PIaytoOzSDRyy6NZffDCZVU05z21LpZ6AhHnIp9gg0dWSvxo iRu+dnQ6Rc1aJMFEVM/DQxXcR6/nsJXLKlxsRuv4zqwfMljfn6y+2gshYRNrm08E72OptvdCB yERGRbxYNCsU3Zqx/lTvrql2yOsmt8Uo/18zhJjPF/Nx5Q90VS3FuKY+p2RzXsMlHKQ+QFCQk z+A3Ky52inbYpumEhCWwe//XTkzJTOc8vZCyvll3BXx6BwWXPOOxapN8dmZbN6IhL6Ng8wJzF 4kJ+IMcPGRvBglTpxoqYN9QpQMtSyJhZZzVO4l4wPCjFOtZKfAUQEALbgcjhznooxtfSOSmll S/QCtAm/B1XWI81XjtmPQ0/T34+mB27S5lTQO1H4wk4Usbw/b9+aq0rbsOGSCiUIWyuUzYatx d70600CExOdNSGOLRcvgVupg4cHza/q/DOGfHj4BzIRGvTxzqBDV/W0Xz/qwsGHLRurKm+9ga RvGNcwKmtj2uUyxE7ML745+fL5xrO8VnS0EtwkBeguUsMZ+53HL3FEz3p2WdIRZcedhRD6h7L hrN/2BvQRzOdwChO/3ZT6E3XPPgcRtKE2G6ETZuAWH3DQRjwCb5A7FYOEztWM7H7v1lAfqfk3 uKyvPgYPJJ9vIpvZEhjVi6NqPGUf8fMYRaG7C1To6sUG+r+CAOPuk7kHPn+YUAp7f3LUQBtET 1jEBG7k46c5HIf1vjI3t46IxkMLrUqXZP+4g9GL0n1/NuGHeEnK2iCGigGQnR8umCatsp/Pg/ QcBqj4vt5Ojiv13PFSJ4IYv+KRbcTDo8Cl2LErQuLskTY0UUdnDSLmYU5eX0LK7Tzpu49KOuG u+FUIzmVSSxSjrQKO7nc+1cxHNJl4Frl0FHIK9pOSB4RYvH3nIBKCzriwDKzKwSRs3DfMoqen 4OFv+hiYg6IrylYLg7ExP/ZfO3vF9rbO+cBu9OmK37WTticOExLhhK2DyAJsQC1xOL5XIP3dC yGgXXQxm5RrQB815sCRkzozw61W0HTGnI22g+h7iCae56q9DheSGKtuzjQZK5EXXlHMolIlGa 7m3h09dtW60aSx02bcal+5UxCkzzJZBaVA7H8b+lmlLfGPHVcUmqzFlEMEAgCVMbcxrSdo9zV hS35TSmk8tSp1h8BJaSJnQkJuWh29YyHsrEqHCpmiKK74f3iuRdRroUC5IHcNMwk5Wgf6Cw90 9AT1KSH87NttnXLCCn32OkuahrZLqtVvJ1+wYBD1fIZ9TzTWAmFn/3ivF/IoKbhJ4VDbDiFVn ZoZVPCbOsM09ICPqZOscXobq3noRj8Misrj4E0nlwYWYaRm8FnsZeg+LIizvGByFXF1EyPf8X vW8vHOGu5vOIvLgMHTSloiJeg0fNg4s3ERAyVdiKJKKrQrFIE4B1ggjAUxSD99Znhlz4vwBJE MDC3uXv8q+v+vuxdC7gnk5acL1HWUPKk5DEkbbMRa1Qlqk+IDadUH9lZetNcxaPZWfF6P1LIG kB2LFdkYUSXMwxSw291iOiL2Cx94FQtHwwr8G5+oTyXgmT3dF2ZzgsgHRRKUJnK6p4lw94wLe IQW78DgWNUwSi8wAsEQXdoXGMjg3YJ75EQpbOkAYmCFTNeMfM/AIngnm/5cu4bhvc+0DAE0M8 H5w2OBg8tDA22d+X3Dmvkc9JUlnV0INUh6r423ZxSxcUFleytvkkvoDprYd/82OmrqXbvGLzM cM4P/aA08+Ghv2rtkDgB/Kb2t8WcgJ7OXhRLUSAKNzCy+CAIv9fB3+zmWGUq+Ll8Rjq2F7s3N A9lFPZmXwThZ/0OOFHeoHbq6bouPc5XW8VIBzkHg5C8QWiSjEaF5LX7OAn3vq19kDvCaOoQIY XW0Tc/5xZHvFY/rAqwHaV9aYeOnF6Ig6Le6NaafLkOPFqBTeRh+1jOIbkT5WQBzlzRC9QtzFv g7BTpXHJORiDqyYSOrXe5/ZryOhB7NYbyaD4tseqA2FhTkOcMDZexjpUZ2+3ow6ZL3ihjKZEd 8X9BzQtFjor/iSPFlKcIB8uKQSURqfWLhBwY96C6oFxFQGHxkYLHxu71TLRHPSVWd7A9Cf7fh cCbmgpG247JTGtrfd4+Nwn8c81lgRtgDMyWneKuDlB5je0Ki799MbVp8n3h9zf/w52v/ls/y7 mGD6Ein1YG9BtO6riCeDnyePl62vRsFPzmck9r0bZz2ujySI7tf8i9GfUjIJabG7/1FQqFQx4 KLdCGS8frI1vIG6TD3hvLkaKK8eao5DW200z6CfMBKwOd0B1QW1P3DQ/d9WyNG8fIyer+SMtr HW1sFS8TRwynAooYZUNTA9B5P1Ug2kiUPuCCtefdRUknsfHIQkX/2fbyjCHZ5vDL0WfjFmIy4 0q1GMnK+OZH2GA5UaPybraiU6fvk12rm2KjM/q0ci9AqCEos/7R0rf+l5n0vNtszV8QcdjKuA m2u1cYh27QNZsk8TQj2tJi7XxsgPmQ0QegEwDlkVBn09bR/rKZYum1CPq6SneGZUZrfwsIewY NnLT715xWLHTzbd9t11jmn2wuFObxtT0or580PBI7aw/Q5dq9zY2xQkODqpPatuqtcTYrSUGe QGaN/3CDq6WGChlF7WrxyjOOUrVwdPX8YRe4/gt1DQd83rqD/KEdPULYLtQ55vuHesMB7My7g RoXrfPPV/XfEKaqFldf/kvlZqrC1rNrGxG/tmf4XkCkJ128891UJvpNHC044iXQ0grSctbZzS PNhmOshJCg0OfqvZkif6ylUXT1b65KMtQuT6Uk5vO1GGFoM+efomC8QQ3XvgCQj+gOwbDurdV YBwmh1pp6tDN1mI3PJapSpeDo8iSOLyVwlxIoipg9vAOrXMFtYwDYNF1v07zowF4bnBE5zDJT ia02SGgBJ4hXSQ/VtQ3AgNqr/XlrEtz8I4MMKP2qD+N6hSoYRCGheZ+/KCW3vqv0SrByoUW1C DWWiUxK5b3ce+Cn3TzmUhkL4MYZup+KHJQm074fDPUP1YjQRYGbPze7ri/iQHBJ+vsVUP94s2 npJlT1f+f90NGP0JteN6+AH21kB2n6C8rlSenm+x8wttPLZi9rCIu6bwIAiM7/2nWNKcLY4G1 CjU8K1y1Z+QkeT813Oo6PFSC6N9W8AgZlMOOuDG965LLUcfhsReF7FyUDDHEQ1NIkRIAW2zKN y5SOz6XClbE2+NQmJdtH8U7hh9HQlLb3wZcDVzpspHOXfEiTXz5uz1ipAYGBdRkF3Zw3dqN0C mipLGMQ3Z4zWYtSivMG2pCEq8389DJo+TVYWTHTtEHTPyTUIQa9uSWkyf9WM0XQ08rICl4kiW mnSUIYf1RXKLmXjTQ5sDMxJ22Bi5SQI6kWTFH2wy8sG5an62aJUM9YQW1TTF73swxQMoBU5Rv qApxYTa3ng3AI5vBN00I/84cOPwC+1qIpGbbMmh9UdJN5nWFrtdMAVwrQSCoTImxA2RnuLQGl Pq6o5wJWRkpZUXXCOitb/mSAxenmw95j9uSJM4CVeZi9oGEmg1kAuC6jBSVKC+OuBUd1MmeVA Fmqd4VQ6/pEBn80kdFHk/3zY3xRXkRjLDnIYdIjcv2zWMKReAN+aw4aY12+hucNUZ0Kkrgnjq 5B8RPp/FEiVXTJhaK97MI0nVL9x6H3fcHKgj36vUoYSUlCE6p1e4lnbYLGwRWtALgklB95X/m EZEuiK2e8KrFfU/+MkNIO4iUaFJSJaoBv5WIYpNq+syODXWy6vjrvFM7PjTNKVC5wr0MUBRWl wFO2dTHxaFieWMCEubgg9gbh1YRUpphWHfjxaRuvxe6GeafN2bIsGL51hCBGzvMWqkSqP8Jtu t9P0ZCGVGdg1IBUu0jaAMBSLOJBZLyWl3a0KczZVYmgwhF+Z6Dtlal+Y9zWPoYg102+BWd0a/ e2pcsWUqvVezqAH4rcTiq06tQhHQJZKCTEN9dTyP+SIxN9QlSl8oP1wz2e0JEatafShcge25m YlYDbJgXK8e1SxtBzfvRWZm4BAEORIjYI+C3grWp9Z2yuzPxF6/QLHPKeIjD0yIQc8WgliUmT muj1CfUx+8ll+yauqqchG3m4rzHIs+2fhuV9K0QNMb9dNqq8ZQ2HRWRh1V3cmICvaqKl2gJ2y ySACLu/B2M4As9DCmkNiliVU3tE94/JuCsgsd/Hpp1JAIkfvVUG2KNRlt6VDnMlcQolLofJBW +FBreMR62bJv0Q0bcg9LKEqEl7kCoghMnjjqWn2PUWsnxFrmBnv6BFWFCCjfuIDEwag8qsuY1 FCsQwlFMcSPi00yyqirysypRNrZ6dLzrb5tgXEw58y/G/bv0ElKc43+eWSFre2DZVQGLF7Jy6 b8r9YhWtUKQYPboedf9OoBkRhmjJIiB0cHOCaeKyvg1OMbAbQuYGrBVFBlQwdJK8dU/YsiLN3 uUtPT70WDStP4Tr3zLUwJgFhEHGGdRIXyVPgpEaP9/m4oSlUO5Ha/7uNpytr6QdXl/o4akpdP xKFhEdupJyYZGs7kczL/Y07S1Vec+otT3E3YbMGb3SQwwl97QNTbBSC6fm5xwAOifmSpP7sWI XpviN0BBya/we3rGlSPXuNUASGb/xtnuZQp/e+jG0h8KreB9jVMI6hvRK8MimUjbuZrU4IaYp azyfFRcqpbmP60Ts6uOC3CLYHgUuUtafXqrYM59KJJ8+qZcj7l8R/Vw2NLVFRaorxgxLqqKr7 /kXxe5WUYZ5fK9Si5Rbu1DQcib9B0Nq2P8+BuVAcGEOUwSpL71FH8gaJoUOnD9AmEVqatiSMn FK70oFaYf3b4eU2wob8SiSY8SQaoLDoGyyfCridA7bytED7Nt53j6SkL6bA49BKLosjWwSfAH 1+2vPYb9VWd+4XfstkyCvDT1OI/GUPdxab8GbHyKvmxqFCX8kH76NIyVXwGS49w+Bt2B/Kog4 0/zIryj833WUgAwoA8pinK/3FPc0XkoDggP54LsvCwEZ8imXUt7jgJnmj87QkSzgW3tFEezkt Z2EtGkNaIlXSuQIBjQabf5RDTSla/peep9ZDp3XYcunzQ8iazuYujQiHsSt3YCB/qkBuo4Etm wY2ABkInM1LaUCBJ7iUrhSzeUtxwA8ZJ9OpSKTVisbUYoQ7oCzlxNV0NgRRM/k5YMGyIuOEB4 LF3M6AHfbmNbHEpKbMmENpoF1PqN5OnaBnCExlVAFHBPA2jFtPHhQhe3VCSyh3SbiQJ67bL4e D5jVecXzEM+fwkN+dnLIinOG8y/PPU0Nck6e24McM29b1ugW9cle7SYbQ+hULpPHMNGZswhb4 eJhAxt600izRNjaI1htGxlbLX+Pon8aBBbeCVbCMpNudOTxSvRaef3n82UEzg20crgvaB4zc7 KJE373e1AmFaCpqcrx5axYHwPL9kPzDZe92o1KlQyQrCT49AUFP2IF1TfSoOiVbcZWe00xk6U lblviAZpt1Bk24xXiFDfO3Zec6Yy60wJ1glyZfwY4eErKhuwN6ntprdKb3oblRZdDVJd512sc PnLcYCH+1cWu8lbrxZKVwK0ZaXRmJB4pJxvNM654E2fWECa94Fe/XdY30fDUmHOu+fHwtOHle Ww99Xenn7f0jfRD3MLllBb9b1EJLunyJGw8vfT1VQ8KBWezdYm//kzq0GmpYg== > Von: Andrew Lunn =20 > Gesendet: Montag, 29. Juni 2026 18:40 > An: Markus Stockhausen > Betreff: Re: [PATCH net-next v2 5/8] net: mdio: realtek-rtl9300: Add c45 over c22 mitigation >=20 > > Enhance the driver to detect this register 13/14/13/14 access sequence= . >=20 > I still think this is the wrong way to do this, and you should look at > MDIO bus lock/unlock. C45 over C22 interception only tried to mitigate a downstream nit that is no show stopper. We already live perfectly without it. I will=20 drop that part. Markus=20