Re: [PATCH net] net/smc: Fix lookup of netdev by using ib_device_get_netdev()

[Leon Romanovsky <leon@kernel.org>]

On Tue, Nov 05, 2024 at 10:50:45AM +0100, Wenjia Zhang wrote:
> 
> 
> On 27.10.24 21:18, Leon Romanovsky wrote:
> > On Fri, Oct 25, 2024 at 09:23:55AM +0200, Wenjia Zhang wrote:
> > > Commit c2261dd76b54 ("RDMA/device: Add ib_device_set_netdev() as an
> > > alternative to get_netdev") introduced an API ib_device_get_netdev.
> > > The SMC-R variant of the SMC protocol continued to use the old API
> > > ib_device_ops.get_netdev() to lookup netdev.
> > 
> > I would say that calls to ibdev ops from ULPs was never been right
> > thing to do. The ib_device_set_netdev() was introduced for the drivers.
> > 
> > So the whole commit message is not accurate and better to be rewritten.
> > 
> > > As this commit 8d159eb2117b
> > > ("RDMA/mlx5: Use IB set_netdev and get_netdev functions") removed the
> > > get_netdev callback from mlx5_ib_dev_common_roce_ops, calling
> > > ib_device_ops.get_netdev didn't work any more at least by using a mlx5
> > > device driver.
> > 
> > It is not a correct statement too. All modern drivers (for last 5 years)
> > don't have that .get_netdev() ops, so it is not mlx5 specific, but another
> > justification to say that SMC-R was doing it wrong.
> > 
> > > Thus, using ib_device_set_netdev() now became mandatory.
> > 
> > ib_device_set_netdev() is mandatory for the drivers, it is nothing to do
> > with ULPs.
> > 
> > > 
> > > Replace ib_device_ops.get_netdev() with ib_device_get_netdev().
> > 
> > It is too late for me to do proper review for today, but I would say
> > that it is worth to pay attention to multiple dev_put() calls in the
> > functions around the ib_device_get_netdev().
> > 
> > > 
> > > Fixes: 54903572c23c ("net/smc: allow pnetid-less configuration")
> > > Fixes: 8d159eb2117b ("RDMA/mlx5: Use IB set_netdev and get_netdev functions")
> > 
> > It is not related to this change Fixes line.
> > 
> 
> Hi Leon,
> 
> Thank you for the review! I agree that SMC could do better. However, we
> should fix it and give enough information and reference on the changes,
> since the code has already existed and didn't work with the old way. 

The code which you change worked by chance and was wrong from day one.

> I can rewrite the commit message.
> 
> What about:
> "
> The SMC-R variant of the SMC protocol still called
> ib_device_ops.get_netdev() to lookup netdev. As we used mlx5 device driver
> to run SMC-R, it failed to find a device, because in mlx5_ib the internal
> net device management for retrieving net devices was replaced by a common
> interface ib_device_get_netdev() in commit 8d159eb2117b ("RDMA/mlx5: Use IB
> set_netdev and get_netdev functions"). Thus, replace
> ib_device_ops.get_netdev() with ib_device_get_netdev() in SMC.
> "

 The SMC-R variant of the SMC protocol used direct call to ib_device_ops.get_netdev()
 function to lookup netdev. Such direct accesses are not correct for any
 usage outside of RDMA core code. 

 RDMA subsystem provides ib_device_get_netdev() function that works on
 all RDMA drivers returns valid netdev with proper locking an reference
 counting. The commit 8d159eb2117b ("RDMA/mlx5: Use IB set_netdev and get_netdev
 functions") exposed that SMC-R didn't use that function.

 So update the SMC-R to use proper API,

Thanks