From mboxrd@z Thu Jan 1 00:00:00 1970 From: Kevin E Subject: Re: Marvell 88E8056 gigabit ethernet controller Date: Sat, 18 Aug 2007 04:45:26 -0700 (PDT) Message-ID: <244053.17817.qm@web38913.mail.mud.yahoo.com> References: <20070818053812.GP6002@1wt.eu> Mime-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: multipart/mixed; boundary="0-115891262-1187437526=:17817" Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Cc: linux-kernel@vger.kernel.org, netdev@vger.kernel.org To: Willy Tarreau , Stephen Hemminger Return-path: In-Reply-To: <20070818053812.GP6002@1wt.eu> Sender: linux-kernel-owner@vger.kernel.org List-Id: netdev.vger.kernel.org --0-115891262-1187437526=:17817 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=iso-8859-1 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Content-Id: Content-Disposition: inline --- Willy Tarreau wrote: > No Stephen, look again, he says that moving the > video card into the broken > system does not change anything. Correct, I've used three different video cards in the broken machine. I've used an old PCI vid card, the PCI-X vid card from the working machine, and now PCI-X card I just bought yesterday (nvidia based). None have affected whether the Marvell chipset works or not. Also, the broken machine is a server so I don't start X on it. It just sits in console mode all the time. The CPU (Core2 E4400) used to be in the working machine, then upgraded it to the Q6600 and put the old E4400 in the new MB that became the broken machine. Memory was brand new out of the package. So I've used the E4400 in a MB that worked fine. > I don't understand why the working one is on PCI bus > 3 while the other > is on PCI bus 4. It's just as if the chip embedded a > PCI bridge. Maybe > those chips are just cheaper dual-channel > controllers with one faulty > controller disabled. It would also explain why the > PCI ID is different. I've attached the "lspci -vvv" output for the two machines, if it doesn't come through just let me know how I can get it to you. Thanks, Kevin ____________________________________________________________________________________Ready for the edge of your seat? Check out tonight's top picks on Yahoo! TV. http://tv.yahoo.com/ --0-115891262-1187437526=:17817 Content-Type: application/gzip; name="working-MB.gz" Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64 Content-Description: 2173274505-working-MB.gz Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="working-MB.gz" H4sICEDbxkYAA3dvcmtpbmctTUIA7VtZc6pIFH6Ov6Kr5iUpJGkQEFM3U+WW Za4mjiaZh5QPCK2hLoKDTW6cXz+nWRQREjQkuZMxVXHB3jjL951zusH4FONj jC6dOUUj1zQm5BRd2ZRYqOm4M8fVqOnYSBV7NUU+uYAX1CVTx13AzzZ1Hcsi Lrr0RujQJU8Ii0elg4E3mi/mlExP0YU50fjRghJ0S/RH27GcyQLd2T9s56eN DPJk6gTJGOPSQTgazH1yw7MpONTw5l0NxnE5NJgRvbnQLeL/9NfV9T2P7i/q A9txZjzqaW7bdXk0oGQ2M+0JfGr3+zw6h94NscHDkqhGvfkpamozDilK9/If Ht21zpdNuOUYrfb9oN05G8N19PttfeS4lEfflh+6/gcO/R7M8K3H3koHHY0S W1+cInYn2kwbmZZJTQIzPhA8RPfENhzXvwtzbOog37HjTn3JlkoYNCCABnrN q5wKYC3bzzOXzOeo7zgU9WBNSwWgw5nrTHhzjDBGD9dsIgtkrTsGGR6tC5r7 cEHz2wmazxZ0GebQHwnqmDZBA/MfkFpFRMzW5qWDBlvDzDWnmrs4w9B2Dvdv G/43Ab55MLhh2jBY8J3ovBWMfAYaBMmgEXk0bWOpELBRPIZ/HvufxuPSQegG iYZjyW+B+bEy9v9KBz2XjAnVH7WRRdA0tRcO/0j4zi8vjKNRBtEdoHko41C8 u0mWQ9/WJdvwl9KkYBkwkEkXkXKvnatB3bcCMJdIK30yJzSu+ITVq+oQ7YYD iXHAe3rOT8CYrmZrEzIlNkVPxJ0zn6iUDg7OLW0CDXvddtP6Afc+uIIXAf5F HtW956bnutDlDE/rrM1hC3Nl+LkMP5dblUeHwteK7lgGB66xtN4WZo35ts1U xgYl1hmGN12zwGD83zZWWoOVdsEjYZFgjhNbA2Q0fEd2XW9GoQn4GKxQkUYm SO5Pj3gw1glG4Swwfd0wmE+vzAGhlka14PvGhBpMmIICAwtu6ghd9f9kYHTQ 8oV7CsqYAZZQYrB1PPe0heVoBhJENXCZMuo9ajY992yduVb7md5qEz7WP3Q8 1MFz9E2RbOjREdA3wZvHGoH5OS7zfgekrtNAeteOzZ/DbVjMXPy3O3serSY+ Rd96Nm5cg49mXy3JV2Xvp8sGC6Ao1i39duBqn2hGn/y9ugqdAC1+xITB8A5e xWP5YnQCvf4yDfqIngWljOqDXpfdbTmQq7jsvCYJUVYiUSiSt5rB790y50wE Buo3G6D3YBEgnOkUbJVjtzlY2Pojv1pXxmqYaYJaYVhqN6gNkvnpNqkLouz2 Ozy7emUb/lX//dKhPctj6Oy5M3Pu21bQ/9qbjsCXKmI58KqOOTUpqsrHgb0t 2wU2acTnO7doOB3g2bzFvL85NZozdvmyd+X+zcdW6S8I3YzH5XBR6MYOp2TN mLm+aiW+lzF2FDRgx7tBIxZxpDOkioVLdHjVvFRhjKlpLY78bneXwJesbxCs /CZlUCVrN9wpfpFSaJV/J1rlc8UvU2KY3nQnYgX+i0ALONS0UR25jsechTo+ rDB77JMJk7nk3y9izjRHGkU6A62HObDxWUUcRtoTCtFeGGv+Ju/Vt5X6Ggn1 iUK2+qQ09VXfoD4RtZP6E1P0J8K07Z31p/xy6UOR+msm3U9d6g+fRskYKG9c EzALPtFhReQhxigjGzB1Fgs+j0LdCt+HG9GE/FKgJe4SaPHrgRYfBlr8toGW b4UjoIC6Z5hOqPbcNnjZCvvFTHDnVFXDWPxsW/ugDOoVDhDFbCP0I9dDRXrF CJV3tEJZfvd4X9km3ufyxfu54v5qLO6P7JMuZuSLh/xcsSG/F0huGWTjMOJf Xvejfpwe9SeFkRbzh2E+nxnmb6wgQDo9RykoBefiNSF/6cK+IJSzICQmCkJi 3oKQGlVq1JcKQuPxsqSzfUEo3jt27R0KQvx2BSGOWQGfvyAkfVq1wrMtluUS w/fY5bevWLbYqFoI6fgFqBXA13Yli2wsS64E71ax4KKKBZesWLCKTKxiIeD3 qVjcLdE/qFqsvm9fukgrZX5ogZBVJLdPpoTUQmOxqUFRMVlImJVCCDOrLLQn zCRhVhKEWclLmLWIybSXCLMW7aDU9oS5J8yPJUzp1TL/u1X5C6fM2p4y95SZ QZlSIZSZVYrfU2aSMqUEZUp5KXMUcdnoJcqsRpSp7nDoQA3f+diFPWXuKTMn ZcpfhzJFvKfMPWWmUqZR0BmEaBc0qzy738XOdwhBrGTvYqubu9hGwYcQ0jax 9+rLfwhBqGWrT09Tn1io+ip79RV1BiGpPgOnqa/gMyRp6Lk/Q7ITem5s37Nz uF/yDAnJt7PqtwkSk8DKxmsoIaAHsC7qajo1n8gXzHFfTmTlRCIrryeyFTEz k61GKWb1V9wt3dr9tjxAv20uK+8UVodnCMZg6TDnq/WdxsllP8Dbk/4R6vSa QaIw1mC0Is5LhYF+4Y7BvcUx3oSrOzzcA9oQ0aB+W0d6DvprBPo4QpJPqUHH eoL/UoIXgCW/lXCMdyDAEcbyxyMY90vEnzgZwKwOwarDZSsh2WqVZEirVmKy lZ42ViXRiuC0sZKBFVk/nBs1k5P8reTibzGFv3esHUg71w6qhT/dw6fn/FsH DBvVCXUIUaeIHgDR8DDy6woadH2yzBnM+q0/CFn5/0DG8YaTztV8Vi4r2Q7F It21TEUIHoUFGQFUT2egSBZyxFHbvjcNU1tT9EUVrOKCnDsuqKVagSE77WGg WE1IpJcwcgKc64O7wS35zmqfM7h1FyxJP04qWxVYBPN14sv8z5esqz18tDJH cqJ015B7NUb0gOXqfHKG2XTX4Dq2CDk5wMuLeHgyXepplr8zodk+svVvuv5Q SjjUgxHWw4dRV1FNgWfll02vNlaqftbZaHW1A9S2jZljgoje9Vz0xjZH1Cra IkhsQhS9JcQVfXRaFsQ3PC0Jgnj56HTubaHl6nZ6YLKEKwGYbwTef3RN3QWH WXKryQTgw270k4grCj5hr5UPCb3x1wH3tzxTEovJE0FtXtxPRU31nVGzsBhT jm1fd8hEA5dZwzDho5/t+CAIK3xXewcIy3lyOnufv/gz1EIEYgK6arWRGVVm 3gHCVBk9BFiDBkS/QT3XvNlD2RZQtlFeUDLLCzWcp7xQk/KUF2pqnvJCTc9T XtBW6xKUT4DRN9T2pYDq2/SRuDaha3Tf1dwnYllxq70AXc1QhxrHSFXbKpYV VvLn276NA7+sBko6jSBt7xTkf+sUufM6NX9K9T3bGUYrAw7S/hdSr+jIW97U S3rJ+rMLVRxYP5d9OAX+RW7XwylCdhBxbwLrAog7hqdTP13abKZ/UoZGXgly Pu+E3v8y2tkiX8sT7WwkbVuFO/8CQZzyHYxOAAA= --0-115891262-1187437526=:17817 Content-Type: application/gzip; name="broken-MB.gz" Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64 Content-Description: 2522529575-broken-MB.gz Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="broken-MB.gz" H4sICGPbxkYAA2Jyb2tlbi1NQgDtXFlT4lgbvtZfcarmRitGT0ISgtVOFZvL 19Ay0DpTZXERkoOmOiRMFlvm13/vyQIhJHiIoD0OVikQzpZ3e94tYnyO8SlG 147no5FrGo/kHN3YPrFQ03Gnjqv5pmMjVezVFPnsCv6gLpk47gy+tn3XsSzi outghI5c8oyweHx4MAhG3szzyeQcXZmPGj+a+QR9J/qT7VjO4wzd2T9s56eN DPJs6gTJGOPDg3g12PvslqdbcKgReF0N1nE5NJgSvTnTLRJ+9efNt3se3V/V B7bjTHnU09y26/Jo4JPp1LQf4V273+fRJcxuiA0ejuRrfuCdo6Y25ZCidK// 4dFd63I+hJuv0WrfD9qdizFcR79/r48c1+fRl/mbbviGQ79HO3zp0ZfDg47m E1ufnSN6J9pUG5mW6ZsEdnwgeIjuiW04bngX5tjUgb5jx52ElD08xMABATjQ a94wMoCObL9MXeJ5qO84PurBmeYMQEdT13nkzTHCGD18oxtZQGvdMcjweJnQ 3LsTmt+M0HwxoU9gD/2JoI5pEzQw/wGqVUREZc07PGjQM0xdc6K5swsMYz24 f9sIPwnwKYDFDdOGxaLPROetaOUL4CBQBo3Ik2kbc4aAjOIx/PI4fDceHx7E apAZOJbCEZgfK+Pw5/Cg55Ix8fUnbWQRNMmdheMfEr/y8wvjZJVBcgfIi2kc k7ccZTn0ZZmyjfAoTR8kAxYy/VnC3G/OzaAeSgGIS8KVPvGIn2Z8RupVdYjK 2YHMOqA9Pecn2JiuZmuPZEJsHz0T16M6UTk8OLi0tEcY2Ou2m9YPuPfBDfwR 4FfkUT14aQauC1Mu8KROxxy1MHcCX5/A1yetypPjw8eK7lgGB6oxl94WpoP5 tk1ZRhcl1gWGF12zQGDC71ZOWoOTdkEj4ZAgjo+2BpbRCBXZdYOpD0NAx+CE ijQygXJ/BCSAtc4wineB7euGQXV6IQ4ItTRfiz6vbKjBhjlWYGDBTR2jm/4f 1BgdtELingMzpmBLfGLQc7z0tJnlaAYSRDVSmRPUe9Js/zKwdapa7Rf/u/bI p+bHioc62ENfFMmGGR0BfRECLzUIxM9xqfY7QHXdj6j3zbH5S7gNi4pL+HJn e8lp0lv0rRfj1jX4ZPfFkUJW9n66dLHIFKWm5d8OXO0TzeiTvxdXYRJYix8p YlB7B3/FU/lqdAaz/jQN/wm9CMoJqg96XXq3JxFdxfnkJUqIspKQQpGCxQ7h 7JbpURIYqN9sAN+jQwBxJhOQVY7e5mBm60/84lwFp6GiCWyFZX274dtAmZ9u 03eBlN1+h6dXb2wjvBq+Xjt+zwqodQ7cqemFshXN/xZMRqBLFfEk0qqOOTF9 VJVPI3mbj4tk0kjvd2n58XZgz7wW1f7mxGhO6eXr3o37N586ZXggdDsen8SH Qrd2vCUdRsX1VSnJ1TIBUzg1XT8AUGuCfNjEWh0kwaDEuhzJxyHGChpg7N2g kfJb8nFWxcI1OrppXqtwkolpzY7DaXfXgLp0buTy/CYVAC4dNyzlBUk54Mzv CJx5Ji9oQgwzmJSCZ0DRxPQBEps2qiPXCajK+U5onKhU98kjpbkU3i+iKukh zUcGNX0PHmD6RUUcJtwTtsK92GP9Td6zbyP2NTLsE4VC9um57Ku+gX0iamf5 J+bwT4Rt26X5p/xyQcg2+dfMqp865x8+T0I6YN54JGDqiaGjisiDp3KCbLDM 05QLexzzVvg6XLG88jp3TSzjrvHL7hofu2v8pu5aKIUjgIB6YJhOzHZmGbxu xfNSIlg64NUwFj9a1t4pDnsFA0SxWAhD//dIkV4RQmWHUijLO48alE2iBo4t amCKHqqp6CGRT382JZ88cOC2GzgEEeXmrjqO44b59TB2wPmxQ5YYeZFDHCzw hcHCyglKusyVPJdZZ0hL5VjLdH4qJICwT04xJqfETHJKZE1OyUnWSF6XnBqP 5+mlzZNT6dmpaztITvGbJac4KgU8e3JK+rDMSWBbNOImRqj380+fMYWykkER 8q0g2L7ICG6WPim2iNmT4HLZEy7JnnDZ7AnNDqWyJwLeTfbkbo4hUQZl8fnt aRT1vZOVNDu6eUgm5CY9txtg7MqzY4NdNR92K1uB3aIU1R52s7BbycBuhRV2 lQQPq+tgd5TUhEZ72N3D7vvCrvRq4WJndYutA29tD7x74N0p8EpbAd6i4sIe eLPAK2WAV2IFXjVBRHUd8FYT4FVLNGOo8SufurAH3j3wMgKv/HmAV8R74N0D 7w6B19hSb0ZSHS5KOO+r+2zNGSIuru5Lq9V9Y8vNGXnF/T372JszhGox+9Q8 9olbZV9lz75t9WassE/PY9+We2vyrOe+t6aU9Vxpa6Dt4Z+yt4aw1YrDMVF4 E0nZeMlKCOgBpMt3Nd03n8knjJTXh8NyJhyWl8PhilgYD9eSQHW0Lh6uJfGw VioeFrLxsMgYD2+sfhs+nrBpRCyXcs5xJOljkHTY89UsUePsuh/Z27P+Mer0 mlG4MdZgtW30kcXhwtYVg3uLYrzJrpZ4dAq4IaJB/Xsd6Qzw14j4cYykEFKj ifUM/uU4L2CWwlHCKS4BgCOM5fe3YNwv4X/ibG/3InxQh/NRQnbUwkuVFqPE 7Cg9b61KZhR9pmp1raxjRZbDmmSYnMVvhQm/xRz8LpmBkEpnIKpbf3aKz88c bOwwrOQ41CF4nSJ6AIuGh4leV9CgG4IlozMbjn4ny8r/CyKO16KMNc23VTYp l5VihaIdaUuRihA9aAw0AlM9mQIjqcuRttr2vWmY2hKjr6ogFVfk0nGBLdUK LNlpDyPGakImvISVP5On+JbGakEu4G38dCpDBKJ0l8zzYo3kGdVFc3aBbHSX bHLqEHJ2gfWHeHiOcophEUOzQ/PVv+2GSynxUg9GnDofJlNFNccGK79sDLVy UvWjGsPVRbGobRtTxwQS7bQpfKUikoxKqgmZesW2q0fctvvGZUF8wwOnQIj1 fePMFaT56co9c1oqvS+qiYY1AoiOfDCiYPsrke1f8dP/1zV1F1RvDsUmJeWN rZ/OvxJxRcFn9G/lXTx1vEeQjAuf8YFZESTX/qo7tr9bc0nlVM28Qx41UL4l ayi89yMy72QMt15KL2EMGVvHi5sLtt9ELiRGTEA3rTYyk0TODkyYKqOHyNag AdFvUc81b/embANTtpKNUAqzEQpmyUYoEks2QlFZshGKzpKNqC7OJSgfYEbf UAqQIqhv+0/EtYm/BPddzX0mlpWW2ivg1RR1fOMUqWpbxbJCKwR8O5RxwJfF QlmlEUoE9uQ/qxRr/v3CcoSosgdnX4uVQV0IcJQlWBPEJX12rEGctE76i/Na HEg/V9wRA78iV7YjRih2Iu5NQF0w4o4R6H4YeK0O0z8o1iOvODkf1xb4n/R2 Noj8WLydlfBvE3cnN/qrG8+arcP4kPioT+idRRGeHJl9EFQPeb7jUllOm35Q gInppW1z7CSJWFRquW7QsnkvXODO8l1NqFS+/yV+dJFlxbR7lvOzjGkHM35E i622hyamfYIkOXqvvRy/yejXCj2hGpMnVGPyhGpMnlCNyRPSMp5QbkyqMfdV hJi1FovEIizK+08Ta/OJQi4UcTEU7dwRk6N/K7m5RvZaTaqUKjqKVAuoAbp1 /HYdxXivo5skXrI6qjHVTjWm2qnGVDsdMdVORxKbjrJWHhh0VPo0OioWBUt5 VU9Zrp6pZ7XFBNA4RBU00k11WR1XVwjnzR9V6t+ewVwuTZe6oU1BPD86Rtpi t4IioSMxpaaChLejp0X/QAsEXWUSdOlrsRKPFkqsLGtxeifmYt4rZbSksytH o7qrCmXoG2cfuB3HX2KsUP8HKE5dms5aAAA= --0-115891262-1187437526=:17817--