Re: [RFC/PATCH] "strict" ipv4 reassembly

[Nivedita Singhvi <niv@us.ibm.com>]

Rick Jones wrote:

> 
>> This is a fast LAN problem - real internet latencies
>> don't allow for the wrapping of the id field that fast.
> 
> 
> What is a "fast" LAN these days?  We were seeing IP ID wrap with NFS 
> traffic back in the time of HP-UX 8.07 (early 1990's) over 10 Mbit/s 
> Ethernet.  Since I'm waxing historic, part of the problem at that time 
> was giving the IP fragments to the driver one at a time rather than all 
> at once.  When the system was as fast or faster than the network, and 
> the driver queue filled, the first couple fragments of a datagram would 
> get into the queue, and the rest would be dropped, setting the stage for 
> those wonderful Frankengrams.  Part of the fix was to require a driver 
> to take an entire IP datagram's worth of fragments or none of them.

Yes, a different manifestation of the problem ;). I was talking
in the context of current Linux code and the common ethernet drivers
and typical current Internet/Intranet latencies.

> And there was at least one CKO NIC from that era (the HP-PB FDDI NIC) 
> where the first IP datagram fragment was sent last :)
> 
> If the WAN connected system is (still?) using a global IP ID rather than 
> per-route, it could quite easily be wrapping.  And we have WAN links 
> with bandwidths of 10's of Megabits, so it also comes-down to how much 
> other traffic is going and the quantity of request parallelism in NFS 
> right?

Actually, the problem is much worse now - we have virtual
partitions in the Xen environment for instance where some
packets are headed for local consumption (virtual network,
no actual network latency to speak of) and some going
out to the network. Having a global IP id generator just
won't be able to keep up - we could wrap in submilliseconds...

> The larger NFS UDP mount sizes mean more fragments, but intriguingly, 
> they also mean slower wrap of the IP ID space :)

True, but in a 32 NIC environment, see how they wrap ;)...

thanks,
Nivedita