Re: IPsec PMTUD problem

[Patrick McHardy <kaber@trash.net>]

Herbert Xu wrote:
> On Mon, Apr 02, 2007 at 04:10:25PM +0200, Patrick McHardy wrote:
> 
>>I noticed a problem with PMTUD between two IPsec tunnel endpoints.
>>When sending a packet larger than the PMTU with IP_DF from one
>>tunnel endpoint to the other, xfrm4_output sends an ICMP frag.
>>required with the IPsec MTU. Since the addresses match the tunnel
>>endpoints, this updates the MTU for the XFRM route with the value
>>that was calculated for the entire bundle, which in turn causes
>>a decrease for the bundle, resulting in further ICMP frag. required
>>messages until the minimum is reached.
> 
> 
> I presume you're using the same pair of addresses inside and
> outside the tunnel? If so the problem is that the kernel doesn't
> distinguish between internal ICMP errors and external ones.
> So when an MTU update occurs for the internal pair the external
> pair is also affected.

Exactly.

> We'd need some field in the routing cache to distinguish the
> two pairs.

I'm not sure I understand how this would work, the ICMP message
looks the same in both cases. Or are you suggesting to
differentiate based on the source of the ICMP message?

> Of course the easy work-around is to use distinct addresses
> within IPsec tunnels.

Yes, that would work as a workaround, but it still seems like
something worth fixing.