[RFC] Best method to control a "transmit-only" mode on fiber NICs (specifically sky2)

[RFC] Best method to control a "transmit-only" mode on fiber NICs (specifically sky2)

[Kyle Moffett]

Hi,

The company I'm working for has an unusual fiber NIC configuration
that we use for one of our network appliances.  We connect only a
single fiber from the TX port on one NIC to the RX port on another
NIC, providing a physically-one-way path for enhanced security.
Unfortunately this doesn't work with most NIC drivers, as even with
auto-negotiation off they look for link probe pulses before they
consider the link "up" and are willing to send packets.  We have been
able to use Myricom 10GigE NICs with a custom firmware image.  More
recently we have patched the sky2 driver to turn on the FIB_FORCE_LNK
flag in the PHY control register; this seems to work on the
Marvell-chipset boards we have here.

What would be the preferred way to control this "force link" flag?
Right now we are accessing it using ethtool; we have added an
additional "duplex" mode: "DUPLEX_TXONLY", with a value of 2.  When
you specify a speed and turn off autonegotiation ("./patched-ethtool
-s eth2 speed 1000 autoneg off duplex txonly"), it will turn on the
specified bit in the PHY control register and the link will
automatically come up.  We also have one related bug-fix^Wdirty hack
for sky2 to reset the PHY a second time during netif-up after enabling
interrupts; otherwise the immediate "link up" interrupt gets lost.
Once I get approval from the company I will patch the post itself for
review.

I look forward to your comments and suggestions

Cheers,
Kyle Moffett

Re: [RFC] Best method to control a "transmit-only" mode on fiber NICs (specifically sky2)

[Stephen Hemminger]

Kyle Moffett wrote:
> Hi,
>
> The company I'm working for has an unusual fiber NIC configuration
> that we use for one of our network appliances.  We connect only a
> single fiber from the TX port on one NIC to the RX port on another
> NIC, providing a physically-one-way path for enhanced security.
> Unfortunately this doesn't work with most NIC drivers, as even with
> auto-negotiation off they look for link probe pulses before they
> consider the link "up" and are willing to send packets.  We have been
> able to use Myricom 10GigE NICs with a custom firmware image.  More
> recently we have patched the sky2 driver to turn on the FIB_FORCE_LNK
> flag in the PHY control register; this seems to work on the
> Marvell-chipset boards we have here.
>
> What would be the preferred way to control this "force link" flag?
> Right now we are accessing it using ethtool; we have added an
> additional "duplex" mode: "DUPLEX_TXONLY", with a value of 2.  When
> you specify a speed and turn off autonegotiation ("./patched-ethtool
> -s eth2 speed 1000 autoneg off duplex txonly"), it will turn on the
> specified bit in the PHY control register and the link will
> automatically come up.  We also have one related bug-fix^Wdirty hack
> for sky2 to reset the PHY a second time during netif-up after enabling
> interrupts; otherwise the immediate "link up" interrupt gets lost.
> Once I get approval from the company I will patch the post itself for
> review.
>
> I look forward to your comments and suggestions
>
> Cheers,
> Kyle Moffett
>   
For the second problem, you could just change the code to check the 
status immediately,
by calling the same code the irq does. It might need some refactoring 
but should only be minor surgery.
I was thinking about doing that anyway for the forced link (no 
negotiation case).