Re: scp stalls mysteriously

[Arnd Hannemann <hannemann@nets.rwth-aachen.de>]

Ilpo Järvinen wrote:

[snipped]

> Also, we have the another mystery to be solved, the fast retransmission is 
> not triggered for some reason (or alternatively not captured in to a 
> log), even in the working .9. case. It would be easy to see whether it 
> works at all from TCP point of view by looking into mibs once you have 
> have some transfers in a working configuration:
> 
> grep -A1 TCP /proc/net/netstat
> 
> ...luckily this fast retransmit issue is less crucial as almost all people 
> are pretty happy already if their RTO-based recovery works even if the 
> fast recovery would not. So figuring it out can be postponed (if one has 
> to prioritize) until the silent death issue is out of the way.
> 
> 

I looked at the working .9 case stream from 192.168.1.15 to 192.168.1.19.
I don't think it is a mystery that fast retransmit does not trigger.
The condition SACKED_DATA > 3* SMSS is simply not fulfilled.
Neither are there 3 non-continuous SACK sequences.
The segments sent are too small :-(
Interesting though, seems to me in this case non-SACK would be better than SACK.
Or did I miss something?

Hey we could cook up a draft for this problem ;-)

Anyway, real problem is, RTO does not trigger...

Best regards,
Arnd