From mboxrd@z Thu Jan 1 00:00:00 1970 Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; arc=none smtp.remote-ip=209.85.221.51 ARC-Seal: i=1; d=subspace.kernel.org; s=arc20261015; a=rsa-sha256; cv=none; t=1795010641; b=V1Nx0Pce/LHjd/KeisartLntadb+6iILJ2iGCc4hwspqJ8fGN/QeRtCK/vJtsqANZGVs tqElph4ngDjLEXU1D3qJidBXeGqk3a/xw3pesbsbXnpbbNzWufGa7Qpi1Z/N51GCi/l7a mQzMi34tkqPLjLByhHjWLMo8GaZVNN6aWjiCua2yH39bKDLhUus0Yk4vHtWJ6eMJ4nwYv YnpAt+C1yC9vZG7mueygYNkZdMMH4jY2rLe0I6UwLcdD0LT7E6lIpL2hs3HugUWEijSc+ oEU7NTXBA8rPe8Zzy/e5LO+vbEoFKNBk5ULUPAfArri5+luapH6APIejfnp5VRzZn4w== ARC-Message-Signature: i=1; d=subspace.kernel.org; s=arc20261015; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; t=1795010641; h=DMARC-Filter:Received:DKIM-Signature:X-Google-DKIM-Signature: X-Forwarded-Encrypted:X-Gm-Message-State:X-Gm-Gg:X-Received:Received: Mime-Version:Content-Type:Date:Message-Id:To:Cc:Subject:From:X-Mailer: References:In-Reply-To; bh=+uwi0okOO21nN8029G5kKeS0+aK14PL+obDOFNYM53E=; b=mpFkfiNWJquETwsgIF4e80SKUWeP+JhnVCCeYL6Em621GHzAWS3BTwPO9FehuGF7BEti KsbVVrFYPVu9e/g62kwonqaU8fPHhsLANp2BCHdBGfEydavUhxL8ZwWGPdeTsycT43P3g IetDC5CtMgvVkv6JHSJmGWMlB9aO1aec6Sg4EQHzzNJvvlfgdU/MM4pSakfqvdpNAS521 z5tdvssJkqHPvmrKEuBeaNqWCOnR8yMIeptRbwSajU6DvchCJ+0gcMdqSzu/HTLhSAiQa ZIpKoI/5kyuDg9e3is7ASOpKf48IQ3FY6P6DLpC5UtQwT13NWAuzhPJfMwK6mqR2zwQ== ARC-Authentication-Results: i=1; smtp.subspace.kernel.org; dmarc=pass header.from=gmail.com; spf=pass smtp.mailfrom=gmail.com; dkim=pass header.d=gmail.com header.i=@gmail.com header.a=rsa-sha256 header.s=20260707 header.b=SDfu4jMf; arc=none smtp.remote-ip=209.85.221.51 Received: from mail-wr1-f51.google.com (mail-wr1-f51.google.com [209.85.221.51]) (using TLSv1.3 with cipher TLS_AES_128_GCM_SHA256 (128/128 bits) key-exchange X25519 server-signature ECDSA (prime256v1) server-digest SHA256) (No client certificate requested) by smtp.subspace.kernel.org (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 7DF6560A260B for ; Wed, 18 Nov 2026 14:04:00 +0000 (UTC) DMARC-Filter: OpenDMARC Filter v1.4.2 smtp.subspace.kernel.org 7DF6560A260B Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; dmarc=pass (p=none dis=none) header.from=gmail.com Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; spf=pass smtp.mailfrom=gmail.com Authentication-Results: smtp.subspace.kernel.org; dkim=pass (2048-bit key) header.d=gmail.com header.i=@gmail.com header.a=rsa-sha256 header.s=20260707 header.b=SDfu4jMf Received: by mail-wr1-f51.google.com with SMTP id ffacd0b85a97d-490c3ae81d3so663153f8f.2 for ; Wed, 18 Nov 2026 06:04:00 -0800 (PST) DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=gmail.com; s=20260707; t=1795010639; x=1795615439; darn=lists.linux.dev; h=in-reply-to:references:from:subject:cc:to:message-id:date :content-type:mime-version:from:to:cc:subject:date:message-id :reply-to:content-type; bh=+uwi0okOO21nN8029G5kKeS0+aK14PL+obDOFNYM53E=; b=SDfu4jMfx+KOwAJ0+Ai4IKvXX4cbuokqAXc1kvWuKb9SeQjKVF6Nq2NP8A8TWgr2WW Z8eWL6KRsLWDFriVRWLOX8CygsJpehUPhRyiqvGdsxneNpY+i2qXyODcwTRStL7PxE7l g4GTkKfiWpixQkNQxDVxMC1Leu7RGByPA8ky8Ei5ZiGXTUziGod6aUJ8+HKQrkOEuPan /iKpOBxfNYImAfXnMFJgrohaArBwI1a9dyiDAyGWHxQouGUSlqHnhAvhRYkw95Fd9vmH leXsA+2yw7ZQye5hiElzbDWQiBsLNvDuXQbSc4b5uFqiXvjV79KoXK5Ds1ZUTIUcgtEC TyBg== X-Google-DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=1e100.net; s=20260707; t=1795010639; x=1795615439; h=in-reply-to:references:from:subject:cc:to:message-id:date :content-type:mime-version:x-gm-gg:x-gm-message-state:from:to:cc :subject:date:message-id:reply-to:content-type; bh=+uwi0okOO21nN8029G5kKeS0+aK14PL+obDOFNYM53E=; b=Bl4GytKDR/TJmx3wJElfGeme3d+vLzMJm4e35jRtSNNezPRE24ZROXkR/x6TOMpv0b 7hywcuX26392mJDy8nK/J0PcMf6u86ETEyRSNToc/PG15LVlaHFjyUFofYughVVpXLJZ XtTWoEQ+j+olPvmtrfeEsMq0dP83SyPlrDfaw7/ImP7Ub6G3Kbkp889ALP3jv0k7TV4I rCcoML5VfdU1h/+NdskWF792fWbksc0vBKj5GtUik7LYSlxS6Z/ugYDhIdPe+AU3dF6P q/uk32V/kzpJ46ewbnUGGDacf00TtQd5roUfQ+PSItHXrKsBIePQdqD5Ep77H5QNWGLL QdxA== X-Forwarded-Encrypted: i=1; AL+hErF1jR8URV6AJO945WaT6b9xnS9hW12yPOp18HVuZPnqmHYr2e2IJeWiPUQKF6NZZc4QtlBSZg==@lists.linux.dev X-Gm-Message-State: APuU4Z+du2z1D/xdFhKKm8d2wFJwiAxaWw9DLiqSMuLA+35gGJ72Wu/x RYlJDF5TZSMY7MTB+mNKDB9LugTzL76k5nMvD5vX6Utkny3Fg3Kjef7D X-Gm-Gg: AZFdTZeSrbkggjh8J77ljqJKQBs3FOt3mh9r5wfpKEdmH7JwgUmGK6Y2l+yHwbN/dSz 00KBO5GDBO8F87V/26oHcPG9JwbtMemE1bo1+PqPWm0ybfPPZY9p03xr8KSrr5tCBYk0tK+TdWE ca9mNC9u8UX2rTLjP+ByWA/PzCY2DhIqfI3UEeVDM1EooA7+SwqlKbbaFaHCEgguZ5/mgHr9uo4 MHAOWfeKBJCB53yBIW9J4RT1FUbARDQSQ4oH05G9oDFMPO8WfMVAKfftmuusTlFVMRsHW8vXIAf AH5AekbOoeyZ0LoXUS9Mt5xIJcd4Kc3/mBLqLrRfz8pil09xsRMOP2qgkGxr8tO1jZB1xe1IuAN brt4Oia7JAvQEEYCueFuLhAsbmQWB7qy4kGsINm+V9zKyjmH3MM/Yp6VRLtFGlpanIOX9Y+vB8w UBfOGN0iFzkHWwlvZdOTtzAQ/3u7NGRYqreMYAzcPzJgNhrz8RwFbA286Jhuhe1W5jyTiNy4BrM daY8tV2LgiB21nqFlBtxDbP5SOpM3eDDfWNhS1+U3LKpB9Is3QWYjJMLOg260YbOWkSDD5VSnjG f8mZbr3oaaRNKMhu+QIASQGVQ2LOc4HEm04jjIhNLlvc1tvBXkrhHwwRAmBI0s2epZ0= X-Received: by 2002:a05:6000:41c3:b0:48e:20ed:d5e7 with SMTP id ffacd0b85a97d-4a63de5249fmr5373556f8f.34.1795010638556; Wed, 18 Nov 2026 06:03:58 -0800 (PST) Received: from localhost (mob-176-246-251-118.net.vodafone.it. [176.246.251.118]) by smtp.gmail.com with ESMTPSA id ffacd0b85a97d-4a65560b2a1sm4737224f8f.32.2026.11.18.06.03.52 (version=TLS1_3 cipher=TLS_AES_128_GCM_SHA256 bits=128/128); Wed, 18 Nov 2026 06:03:57 -0800 (PST) X-Mailing-List: ntfs3@lists.linux.dev List-Id: List-Post: List-Help: List-Subscribe: List-Unsubscribe: List-Owner: Precedence: list Mime-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: multipart/signed; boundary=4827e7d7bbe23dd35858a8366dc75e2a45dd46e9129f07e8a6f88ac53c0e; micalg=pgp-sha512; protocol="application/pgp-signature" Date: Wed, 18 Nov 2026 15:03:50 +0100 Message-Id: To: "Jeff Layton" , "Amir Goldstein" , "koraynilay" Cc: "David Sterba" , "Namjae Jeon" , "Sungjong Seo" , "Alexander Viro" , "Christian Brauner" , "Trond Myklebust" , "Anna Schumaker" , "Chuck Lever" , "Konstantin Komarov" , "Paulo Alcantara" , "Chris Mason" , "Yuezhang Mo" , "Jan Kara" , "NeilBrown" , "Olga Kornievskaia" , "Dai Ngo" , "Tom Talpey" , "Ronnie Sahlberg" , "Shyam Prasad N" , "Bharath SM" , "Sergey Senozhatsky" , "ChenXiaoSong" , "Darrick J . Wong" , "Sean Smith" , "Andrey Albershteyn" , "Pedro Falcato" , =?utf-8?q?Pali_Roh=C3=A1r?= , , , , , , , , Subject: Re: [RFC PATCH v4 00/10] add provenance time (ptime) From: "koraynilay" X-Mailer: aerc 0.22.0-0-gc2f86b7abde3 References: <20261115180343.576773-1-koray.fra@gmail.com> In-Reply-To: --4827e7d7bbe23dd35858a8366dc75e2a45dd46e9129f07e8a6f88ac53c0e Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 On Wed Nov 18, 2026 at 2:45 PM CET, Jeff Layton wrote: > On Wed, 2026-11-18 at 09:14 +0100, Amir Goldstein wrote: >> On Wed, Nov 18, 2026 at 2:09=E2=80=AFAM koraynilay = wrote: >> >=20 >> > Hello and thanks for replying, >> >=20 >> > On Wed Nov 18, 2026 at 12:53 AM CET, Jeff Layton wrote: >> > > On Sun, 2026-11-15 at 19:03 +0100, koraynilay wrote: >> > > > This is an initial implementation of a new timestamp to indicate t= he >> > > > time when a file/directory was initially created. >> > > >=20 >> > > > This patch series takes inspiration from the one by Sean Smith >> > > > [1], but using >> > > > file_setattr()/file_getattr() as suggested by Darrick J. Wong >> > > > in [2]. >> > > >=20 >> > > > The semantics of this new timestamp should be at least these: >> > > > - it should be the same as btime on a newly created file >> > > > - it's user-settable, so it can be preserved for backups, filesyst= em >> > > > conversions, archives and any similar operation >> > > > - it should be preserved every time mtime gets preserved >> > > >=20 >> > > > and the correspondence with the other timestamps is as follows: >> > > >=20 >> > > > ctime <-> btime >> > > > mtime <-> ptime >> > > >=20 >> > >=20 >> > > I'm not sure how to interpret the correspondence above. >> >=20 >> > |-----\_-----------------|-----------| >> > | \_ change/ | birth/ | >> > | \_ modification| creation | >> > | \------------|-----------| >> > | inode time | ctime | btime | >> > |------------|-----------|-----------| >> > | file time | mtime | ptime | >> > |------------|-----------|-----------| >> >=20 >> > ("file" as in "the concept of this file", I'd say "file content" but >> > that would be incorrect for symlinks) >> >=20 >> > so ctime is "inode change time", btime is "inode birth/creation time", >> > while mtime is "file content change/modification time" and ptime would >> > be "file content creation time" (same as Window's or MacOS's creation >> > time). >> >=20 >> > Does this make more sense? >> >=20 >> > >=20 >> > > > Examples: >> > > > 1) a .zsh_history file created in 2019, then after a few years the= user >> > > > decides to switch to another filesystem, copying the .zsh_histo= ry to >> > > > the new home, in that case btime would have the timestamp of th= e copy >> > > > and ptime would have the 2019 timestamp (just like mtime would = have >> > > > been preserved) >> > > > 2) a symlink created in 2020 from the home directory to a /path go= ing >> > > > through the same process as the .zsh_history, in this case it w= ould >> > > > also make sense to sync the ptime to the 2020 timestamp instead= of >> > > > keeping only the btime (so the inode creation time). >> > > >=20 >> > > > The proof-of-concept code (for testing) for stat(1) and cp(1) is >> > > > available at https://github.com/koraynilay/coreutils (master branc= h) >> > > > (Note: these coreutils code changes are a prototype and won't be >> > > > submitted upstream as-is, but they work as expected in simple stat= and >> > > > cp -a/--preserve=3Dptime tests) >> > > >=20 >> > > > Lastly, the name "provenance" and "ptime" are not final, I persona= lly >> > > > don't have a strong opinion on any name, but while testing with st= at(1) >> > > > I noticed that "Provenance" is definitely too long for the normal >> > > > output, so another option which would fit well is "Origin time", >> > > > abbreviated as "ntime" (OrigiN time) and not as "otime", as that w= ould >> > > > conflict with btrfs' internal naming and create confusion. >> > > >=20 >> > > > v2 changes: >> > > > - fix permission bypass leading to ptime update on immutable and >> > > > append-only files (found by sashiko[3]) >> > > > - normalize ptime timestamp as done in fs/attr.c:notify_change() (= found >> > > > by sashiko[3]) >> > > > - fix wording in vfs patch to be like the cover-letter >> > > >=20 >> > > > v3 changes: >> > > > - vfs: reject setting ptime with -EOPNOTSUPP on filesystems that d= o not >> > > > support it instead of silently ignoring it (found by sashiko[4]) >> > > > - vfs: fix not being able to clear immutable and append-only on fi= les >> > > > with ptime, and allow updating immutable/append-only atomically = along >> > > > with ptime (found by sashiko[4]) >> > > > - btrfs: validate on-disk ptime nanoseconds and reset to otime if >> > > > invalid (found by sashiko[4]) >> > > > - btrfs: avoid re-assigning ptime on unrelated chattr calls (found= by >> > > > sashiko[4]) >> > > > - add ntfs3 and exfat support as suggested by Amir Goldstein[5], b= ut no >> > > > vfat, smb, or nfs4 yet as they are a bit more complex >> > > > - move the introduction of fileattr_has_fsx_mask() from the btrfs = patch >> > > > to a standalone patch in the series >> > > > - btrfs: add fileattr_[gs]et to symlink and special file operation= s >> > > >=20 >> > > > v4 changes: >> > > > - vfs: implement fsx_xflags_mask as suggested by Amir Goldstein[6]= ; >> > > > - add SMB (ksmbd/cifs) and nfs (nfsd/nfs) support as requested in >> > > > previous threads; >> > > >=20 >> > > > Note: >> > > > to apply this patch 2 previous patches[7][8] from the ksmbd/cifs >> > > > subsystem are needed. >> > > >=20 >> > > > New Question: >> > > > should I rename fileattr_has_fsx_mask() to something like >> > > > fileattr_has_unsupported_fsx() and keep its code as-is, or should = I add >> > > > the fsx_xflags_mask & ~allowed check in it and keep the name as-is= ? (or >> > > > both?) >> > > >=20 >> > > > Thanks. >> > > >=20 >> > > > [1]: https://lore.kernel.org/20260405195007.1306-2-DefendTheDisabl= ed@gmail.com >> > > > [2]: https://lore.kernel.org/20260407014129.GC6192@frogsfrogsfrogs >> > > > [3]: https://sashiko.dev/#/patchset/20261027220532.736352-1-koray.= fra%40gmail.com >> > > > [4]: https://sashiko.dev/#/patchset/20261028134728.294127-1-koray.= fra%40gmail.com >> > > > [5]: https://lore.kernel.org/CAOQ4uxiuy0VwZj+3M-zRqQ49WTpHZpiaQ+6M= Z8z8WdLjyQM_zA@mail.gmail.com/ >> > > > [6]: https://lore.kernel.org/CAOQ4uxjtuTDT63vJdYaq+RHQEQFLTksp66e4= 6OMN99WhJz3SbA@mail.gmail.com/ >> > > > [7]: https://lore.kernel.org/linux-cifs/20261112111637.184045-2-ko= ray.fra@gmail.com/ >> > > > [8]: https://lore.kernel.org/linux-cifs/20261115155308.415734-1-ko= ray.fra@gmail.com/ >> > > >=20 >> > > >=20 >> > > > koraynilay (10): >> > > > vfs: add provenance time (ptime) >> > > > vfs: add fileattr_has_fsx_mask() >> > > > ntfs3: make crtime user-settable using ptime >> > > > exfat: make crtime user-settable using ptime >> > > > btrfs: add provenance time (ptime) >> > > > vfs: add __vfs_fileattr_set_locked() for inode_lock()'d callers >> > > > nfsd: add provenance time (ptime) via FATTR4_TIME_CREATE >> > > > nfs: add provenance time (ptime) via FATTR4_TIME_CREATE >> > > > ksmbd: add provenance time (ptime) and map it to CreationTime >> > > > cifs: add provenance time (ptime) and map it to SMB's CreationTi= me >> > > >=20 >> > > > fs/btrfs/btrfs_inode.h | 4 + >> > > > fs/btrfs/delayed-inode.c | 6 ++ >> > > > fs/btrfs/inode.c | 29 +++++- >> > > > fs/btrfs/ioctl.c | 24 ++++- >> > > > fs/btrfs/print-tree.c | 1 + >> > > > fs/btrfs/tree-log.c | 3 + >> > > > fs/exfat/exfat_fs.h | 2 + >> > > > fs/exfat/file.c | 42 ++++++++- >> > > > fs/exfat/namei.c | 1 + >> > > > fs/file_attr.c | 156 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++-= ----- >> > > > fs/nfs/inode.c | 27 +++++- >> > > > fs/nfs/internal.h | 2 + >> > > > fs/nfs/nfs4proc.c | 56 +++++++++++- >> > > > fs/nfs/nfs4xdr.c | 19 ++-- >> > > > fs/nfs/symlink.c | 1 + >> > > > fs/nfsd/nfs4proc.c | 9 ++ >> > > > fs/nfsd/nfs4xdr.c | 40 +++++--- >> > > > fs/nfsd/vfs.c | 17 ++++ >> > > > fs/nfsd/vfs.h | 4 +- >> > > > fs/nfsd/xdr4.h | 3 + >> > > > fs/ntfs3/file.c | 20 +++- >> > > > fs/ntfs3/frecord.c | 8 +- >> > > > fs/smb/client/cifsfs.c | 8 ++ >> > > > fs/smb/client/inode.c | 7 +- >> > > > fs/smb/client/ioctl.c | 109 ++++++++++++++++------ >> > > > fs/smb/server/smb2pdu.c | 37 +++++--- >> > > > fs/smb/server/vfs.c | 43 ++++++++- >> > > > fs/smb/server/vfs.h | 1 + >> > > > fs/stat.c | 2 + >> > > > include/linux/fileattr.h | 29 +++++- >> > > > include/linux/nfs_xdr.h | 3 + >> > > > include/linux/stat.h | 1 + >> > > > include/uapi/linux/btrfs_tree.h | 3 +- >> > > > include/uapi/linux/fs.h | 9 +- >> > > > include/uapi/linux/stat.h | 7 +- >> > > > 35 files changed, 614 insertions(+), 119 deletions(-) >> > > >=20 >> > > >=20 >> > > > base-commit: 3bc1fb9c3b20cd478c83496ab16addecb401770d >> > > > prerequisite-patch-id: 049ae0eba275b5be35a238833107e0b251a55aa2 >> > > > prerequisite-patch-id: 614f0bc9411391403d4e9702bafeb31b0ec04ec1 >> > > > prerequisite-patch-id: ddf636b9d33d82ea206ce265d817371350bf8858 >> > >=20 >> > > I think this is going to be very hard to do properly, because the >> > > kernel can't really manage this on its own. Something in userland is >> > > going to have to set this value if you want to update it to somethin= g >> > > other than the original inode instantiation time (aka btime). >> > >=20 >> > > It really sounds like what you want is the ability to make the btime >> > > settable. Personally I think the decision to forbid that was wrong- >> > > headed and that it should have been settable from userland from the >> > > beginning. Maybe we should just revisit that decision. >> >=20 >>=20 >> Frankly, I don't think this decision was made at all. >>=20 >> There are only 2 types of filesystems in Linux today: >> 1. btime is constant (xfs, etx4, btrfs,...) >> 2. crtime is settable in principle but not via a standardized Linux >> API (ntfs, cifs, ...) >>=20 > > CephFS is in this category too. I explicitly made it settable so we > could set it when restoring backups. Ah ok, should I try adding support for it using this API in the next version? (either by making btime settable like with SMB/NFS or adding ptime as new?) > >> AFAIK, btrfs in this series is the only filesystem which is going to >> have two deviated copies of btime and ptime. >> For all the rest, the deviation is artificial in statx. >>=20 >> So the questions to ask are: >> 1. Do btrfs developers prefer to store a new settable ptime or >> making otime/btime settable with this new API? >> 2. Will any other fs in the future want to store settable ptime along >> side the legacy immutable btime? >>=20 >> My take on these question is: >> - Personally I would love to see ptime support in xfs in the future and = would >> willing to contribute to this work, because I have hard evidence from = the >> performance benefits that it brings to smb server workloads >> - Judging by past experience with i_version bump interpretation on xfs, >> I find it hard to believe that xfs developer would agree to making the >> legacy btime settable >>=20 > > Maybe? The main reason for that was that XFS uses i_version as > internally as a change counter for any inode change. I doubt that it > uses btime internally like that. > > The only reason I can see to _not_ make btime settable is for > forensics: maybe having the inode btime be immutable would make it > harder to disguise when an inode was instantiated, but I imagine that > would be defeatable with offline tools anyway. > > If people are using the btime in this way, then it would be nice for > them to speak up and give us some details about this usage. How does > keeping it immutable help you? I agree, I do understand the possible reasons for keeping it, but personally I don't have any use for immutable btime (tho, it is nice to have also that information available). >> Hence the distinction in statx API is needed, but for most filesystems >> it is a pure semantic way of saying "I do/don't have settable birth time= ". >>=20 >> > Originally I just wanted to have btime settable, yes, and if btime was >> > settable I wouldn't have made this RFC PATCH either, but after reading >> > the already existing discussions about it, I can understand having an >> > "immutable inode creation time", like ctime exists, so even after maki= ng >> > btime settable, a new timestamp would be necessary anyway (e.g. for th= e >> > people who want btime to exist as a forensics timestamp). >> >=20 >>=20 >> Right, but every filesystem (e.g. btrfs) can still make an independent >> choice whether storing one or two copies is desired. >> The API does not limit those choices. >>=20 >> > > Failing that, why not just track this in an xattr of some sort, sinc= e >> > > this is really just an opaque blob once you allow it to be settable.= If >> > > the xattr isn't present, then you can just use the value of the btim= e >> > > as-is. FWIW, I think samba does this today, so you could try to sync >> > > with its behavior here. >> >=20 >> > (This is copied and adapted from [2]) >> >=20 >> > I actually have been using fully userspace xattrs[1] for a few months, >> > mostly for backups, and it "works"; but last month I wanted to merge 2 >> > FSs (and have another merge I have to do), so I ran [1] on all files a= nd >> > then compared all metadata/data between source and destination and >> > noticed there were quite a lot of files that didn't have the xattr set= . >> > So I looked online and learned that xattrs only work on regular >> > files/directories, not on symlinks or anything else (and the missing >> > ones were of symlinks). >> > This is what prompted me to search more if anyone had already proposed= a >> > new timestamp (instead of making btime settable) and found the email >> > thread from april linked in the cover letter, which gave me the excuse >> > to finally work on a proper patch. >> >=20 >>=20 >> I am tired of repeating my arguments (and finding my own quotes) >> about why using xattrs is a poor replacement for in-inode ptime. >> AI agents can easily find those quotes for those who are interested >> so I won't bother, I just say that smbd already uses xattr to store >> the creation time - it's just bad for performance and disk usage in >> metadata intensive workloads. >>=20 >> > > That seems a lot simpler than adding an entirely new inode timestamp >> > > that is always going to be a copy of the btime, except in rare cases= . >> > > Having to patch all of the on-disk filesystems with a new per-inode >> > > field is a lot more work. >> >=20 >> > > This patch is quite simple, but changing btrfs, then ext4, xfs, etc = is a >> > > mess, and inevitably you can't get these timestamps until you upgrad= e your >> > > filesystems. >> >=20 > > Weird. I didn't write the above sentence. Yes, I copy-pasted from the linked email and since it was raising the same issue I kept it along yours (I should've probably used >>). >>=20 >> Jeff, this is standard "how to make progress". >> I completely don't agree with this argument. >> We cannot use this argument to block progress. >> Is it already a long standing practice for userspace file servers (samba= ) >> to probe the host filesystem for specific features and fall back to >> alternative implementation if they are not supported. >>=20 >> There will be nothing new in this case, that's the only way to >> make forward progress - define the API, make support queryable, >> implement the feature in some filesystems, implement consumers, repeat. >>=20 >> Also for nfsd, that's the only way to ever implement settable >> FATTR4_TIME_CREATE which is the protocol allows. >> This is never going to be possible with custom xattrs. >> So I must say that I don't understand the objection from you and Chuck >>=20 > > I'm not saying that to try and block progress. I'm just pointing out > that it is a rather heavy lift to add a new inode field. This will > require revving the on-disk format for most local filesystems, and it > will take years to roll out. If we can get away with just making the > btime settable, that seems like a much simpler way to do this. > > FWIW, Omar Sandoval apparently tried to add AT_UTIME_BTIME to > utimensat() back in 2019, but it never made it in. It might be good to > look over the objections to it then to see if they can be overcome. That would also be fine for me, tho adding ptime as a new timestamp does increase completeness, which would be better IMO. Thanks, koraynilay --4827e7d7bbe23dd35858a8366dc75e2a45dd46e9129f07e8a6f88ac53c0e Content-Type: application/pgp-signature; name="signature.asc" -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- iHUEABYKAB0WIQRJ2XvJtXGwULYEerQ0bnTtJTDoOAUCav2wRgAKCRA0bnTtJTDo OLi8AP9On9SVdP2pKaY1bWdUmRmtD+y7ePm2dX8InXgjigrpogEA8jJF9kAz0j67 U81poULRLeUHl4UqJ/jCdHtr6gV6YQM= =E9c9 -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- --4827e7d7bbe23dd35858a8366dc75e2a45dd46e9129f07e8a6f88ac53c0e--