[Ocfs2-devel] useless tools - tunefs.ocfs2,fsck.ocfs2

[Ocfs2-devel] useless tools - tunefs.ocfs2,fsck.ocfs2

[Pawel]

  One of ocfs2 filesystem has some errors.
1. fsck.ocfs2  informs me that :    "I/O error on channel while reading 
.. " It was NOT TRUE - I was able to read and write  entire storage over 
the network multiple times.
2. becouse of CRC  errors and suggestion to disable metaecc I run  
tunefs.ocfs2 --fs-features=nometaecc /dev/xxx
funefs allocate 9,89 GB of virtual memory and 95% of phisical memory 
(4GB). After 4 hours process has been killed - because of out of memory.

I have to recreate new filesystem and restore data from backup.

I try to use tools in version 1.4  and 1.6 (newest)
Filesystem is quite small 250GB and less than 10 000 files, exported by aoe.
Additionally  on the new clean FS -  running tunefs.ocfs2  
--fs-features=nosparse behave in the same way

It seems that the tools are not "perfect"
Could   anyone confirm?

Pawel

[Ocfs2-devel] useless tools - tunefs.ocfs2,fsck.ocfs2

[Tao Ma]

On 01/20/2011 09:42 PM, Pawel wrote:
>    One of ocfs2 filesystem has some errors.
> 1. fsck.ocfs2  informs me that :    "I/O error on channel while reading
> .. " It was NOT TRUE - I was able to read and write  entire storage over
> the network multiple times.
It means it meet I/O error in some ocfs2 disk structure, not the disk.
> 2. becouse of CRC  errors and suggestion to disable metaecc I run
> tunefs.ocfs2 --fs-features=nometaecc /dev/xxx
> funefs allocate 9,89 GB of virtual memory and 95% of phisical memory
> (4GB). After 4 hours process has been killed - because of out of memory.
>
> I have to recreate new filesystem and restore data from backup.
>
> I try to use tools in version 1.4  and 1.6 (newest)
> Filesystem is quite small 250GB and less than 10 000 files, exported by aoe.
> Additionally  on the new clean FS -  running tunefs.ocfs2
> --fs-features=nosparse behave in the same way
I knew a similar bug in fsck.ocfs2, but didn't meet any similar issue in 
tunefs.ocfs2.
The bug in fsck is fixed by b987ee2 "fsck.ocfs2: Only ask available 
pages in o2fsck_init_cache."

A new clean FS will cause so much memory, strange?
would you mind run o2image and give us the image?
Then I can test it locally.
anyway, thanks for the test.

Regards,
Tao

[Ocfs2-devel] useless tools - tunefs.ocfs2,fsck.ocfs2

[Sunil Mushran]

Please file a bugzilla on the nometaecc issue.

On 01/20/2011 05:42 AM, Pawel wrote:
>    One of ocfs2 filesystem has some errors.
> 1. fsck.ocfs2  informs me that :    "I/O error on channel while reading
> .. " It was NOT TRUE - I was able to read and write  entire storage over
> the network multiple times.
> 2. becouse of CRC  errors and suggestion to disable metaecc I run
> tunefs.ocfs2 --fs-features=nometaecc /dev/xxx
> funefs allocate 9,89 GB of virtual memory and 95% of phisical memory
> (4GB). After 4 hours process has been killed - because of out of memory.
>
> I have to recreate new filesystem and restore data from backup.
>
> I try to use tools in version 1.4  and 1.6 (newest)
> Filesystem is quite small 250GB and less than 10 000 files, exported by aoe.
> Additionally  on the new clean FS -  running tunefs.ocfs2
> --fs-features=nosparse behave in the same way
>
> It seems that the tools are not "perfect"
> Could   anyone confirm?
>
> Pawel
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> Ocfs2-devel mailing list
> Ocfs2-devel at oss.oracle.com
> http://oss.oracle.com/mailman/listinfo/ocfs2-devel