Re: [Qemu-devel] [RFC] Disk integrity in QEMU

[Jamie Lokier <jamie@shareable.org>]

Mark McLoughlin wrote:
> > So O_SYNC on/off is pretty much equivalent to disk write caching being
> > on/off, right?  So we could make that guest-controlled, i.e. toggeling
> > write caching in the guest (using hdparm) toggles O_SYNC in qemu?
> 
> I don't think it's correct to equate disk write caching to completing
> guest writes when the data has been copied to the host's page cache. The
> host's page cache will cache much more data for much longer than a
> typical disk, right?
> 
> If so, then this form of write caching is much more likely to result in
> fs corruption if the host crashes. In that case, all qemu users would
> really need to disable write caching in the guest using hdparm, which
> they don't need to do on bare-metal.

However, should the effect of the guest turning off the IDE disk write
cache perhaps be identical to the guest issuing IDE cache flush commands
following every IDE write?

This could mean the host calling fdatasync, or fsync, or using
O_DSYNC, or O_DIRECT - whatever the host does for IDE flush cache.

What this means _exactly_ for data integrity is outside of qemu's
control and is a user & host configuration issue.  But qemu could
provide consistency at least.

-- Jamie