[Qemu-devel] Bug: FC6 x86_64 guest doesn't work in QEMU 0.8.2 on 32-bit P4 host

[Qemu-devel] Bug: FC6 x86_64 guest doesn't work in QEMU 0.8.2 on 32-bit P4 host

[Kevin Kofler]

I have encountered an issue which I think is a bug in QEMU. I'm running QEMU 
0.8.2 (from the Fedora Extras RPM: qemu-0.8.2-3.fc6.i386.rpm) on a 32-bit 
Pentium IV running Fedora Core 6 (as host OS). (And yes, that RPM is built 
with compat-gcc-32 (GCC 3.2), not GCC 4.x, so that's not the problem.) Using 
qemu-system-x86_64, I can install (using the x86_64 boot.iso and a HTTP 
installation) and run CentOS 4.4 x86_64 (as the guest) with no problems. 
(Even the speed is acceptable when keeping in mind that this is an emulated 
instruction set.)

Unfortunately, trying to do the same thing with Fedora Core 6 as the guest 
doesn't work:
* If I try to boot the FC6 x86_64 boot.iso, it only goes as far as "Booting 
kernel." and then the emulated machine locks up. Trying to boot the vmlinuz 
directly (bypassing the syslinux bootloader) doesn't change anything. Looking 
at the debugging logs, I see the installer hits an "illegal" instruction (an 
instruction unknown to QEMU actually, as the boot.iso is known to work on 
real x86_64 hardware) early in the kernel.
* So what I tried next is setting up an FC6 x86_64 chroot in the installed 
CentOS 4.4 x86_64 guest using the "mock" tool. This works as long as it is 
only setting up the chroot from the host system, but as soon as a binary from 
the FC6 chroot is run, it hits an illegal instruction again. (This time it 
just kills the FC6 executable and returns to CentOS 4.4 bash with the error.) 
So it's not just the kernel which doesn't work.

Is this enough information to reproduce and fix the problem? (The images I 
used are all publically available.) Or do you want me to provide some logs?

        Kevin Kofler

[Qemu-devel] Bug: FC6 x86_64 guest doesn't work in QEMU 0.8.2 on 32-bit P4 host

[Kevin Kofler]

I have encountered an issue which I think is a bug in QEMU. I'm running QEMU 
0.8.2 (from the Fedora Extras RPM: qemu-0.8.2-3.fc6.i386.rpm) on a 32-bit 
Pentium IV running Fedora Core 6 (as host OS). (And yes, that RPM is built 
with compat-gcc-32 (GCC 3.2), not GCC 4.x, so that's not the problem.) Using 
qemu-system-x86_64, I can install (using the x86_64 boot.iso and a HTTP 
installation) and run CentOS 4.4 x86_64 (as the guest) with no problems. 
(Even the speed is acceptable when keeping in mind that this is an emulated 
instruction set.)

Unfortunately, trying to do the same thing with Fedora Core 6 as the guest 
doesn't work:
* If I try to boot the FC6 x86_64 boot.iso, it only goes as far as "Booting 
kernel." and then the emulated machine locks up. Trying to boot the vmlinuz 
directly (bypassing the syslinux bootloader) doesn't change anything. Looking 
at the debugging logs, I see the installer hits an "illegal" instruction (an 
instruction unknown to QEMU actually, as the boot.iso is known to work on 
real x86_64 hardware) early in the kernel.
* So what I tried next is setting up an FC6 x86_64 chroot in the installed 
CentOS 4.4 x86_64 guest using the "mock" tool. This works as long as it is 
only setting up the chroot from the host system, but as soon as a binary from 
the FC6 chroot is run, it hits an illegal instruction again. (This time it 
just kills the FC6 executable and returns to CentOS 4.4 bash with the error.) 
So it's not just the kernel which doesn't work.

Is this enough information to reproduce and fix the problem? (The images I 
used are all publically available.) Or do you want me to provide some logs?

        Kevin Kofler

[Qemu-devel] Bug: FC6 x86_64 guest doesn't work in QEMU 0.8.2 on 32-bit P4 host

[Kevin Kofler]

I have encountered an issue which I think is a bug in QEMU. I'm running QEMU
0.8.2 (from the Fedora Extras RPM: qemu-0.8.2-3.fc6.i386.rpm) on a 32-bit
Pentium IV running Fedora Core 6 (as host OS). (And yes, that RPM is built
with compat-gcc-32 (GCC 3.2), not GCC 4.x, so that's not the problem.) Using
qemu-system-x86_64, I can install (using the x86_64 boot.iso and a HTTP
installation) and run CentOS 4.4 x86_64 (as the guest) with no problems.
(Even the speed is acceptable when keeping in mind that this is an emulated
instruction set.)

Unfortunately, trying to do the same thing with Fedora Core 6 as the guest
doesn't work:
* If I try to boot the FC6 x86_64 boot.iso, it only goes as far as "Booting
kernel." and then the emulated machine locks up. Trying to boot the vmlinuz
directly (bypassing the syslinux bootloader) doesn't change anything. Looking
at the debugging logs, I see the installer hits an "illegal" instruction (an
instruction unknown to QEMU actually, as the boot.iso is known to work on
real x86_64 hardware) early in the kernel.
* So what I tried next is setting up an FC6 x86_64 chroot in the installed
CentOS 4.4 x86_64 guest using the "mock" tool. This works as long as it is
only setting up the chroot from the host system, but as soon as a binary from
the FC6 chroot is run, it hits an illegal instruction again. (This time it
just kills the FC6 executable and returns to CentOS 4.4 bash with the error.)
So it's not just the kernel which doesn't work.

Is this enough information to reproduce and fix the problem? (The images I
used are all publically available.) Or do you want me to provide some logs?

        Kevin Kofler