From mboxrd@z Thu Jan 1 00:00:00 1970 Received: from eggs.gnu.org ([140.186.70.92]:52262) by lists.gnu.org with esmtp (Exim 4.71) (envelope-from ) id 1RFqMG-0004Zr-8T for qemu-devel@nongnu.org; Mon, 17 Oct 2011 12:48:17 -0400 Received: from Debian-exim by eggs.gnu.org with spam-scanned (Exim 4.71) (envelope-from ) id 1RFqM7-0008U8-1B for qemu-devel@nongnu.org; Mon, 17 Oct 2011 12:48:12 -0400 Received: from mail-vx0-f173.google.com ([209.85.220.173]:53855) by eggs.gnu.org with esmtp (Exim 4.71) (envelope-from ) id 1RFqM6-0008Tz-OX for qemu-devel@nongnu.org; Mon, 17 Oct 2011 12:48:02 -0400 Received: by vcbfl17 with SMTP id fl17so3127503vcb.4 for ; Mon, 17 Oct 2011 09:48:02 -0700 (PDT) Message-ID: <4E9C5C3E.8030505@codemonkey.ws> Date: Mon, 17 Oct 2011 11:47:58 -0500 From: Anthony Liguori MIME-Version: 1.0 References: <1318213565-3268-1-git-send-email-jcmvbkbc@gmail.com> <1318213565-3268-7-git-send-email-jcmvbkbc@gmail.com> <4E9C0746.3030509@suse.de> <4E9C21C0.5070102@us.ibm.com> <4E9C249D.3080509@redhat.com> <4E9C38F5.2060803@codemonkey.ws> <4E9C5832.908@suse.de> In-Reply-To: <4E9C5832.908@suse.de> Content-Type: text/plain; charset=ISO-8859-1; format=flowed Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Subject: Re: [Qemu-devel] GPLv3 troubles List-Id: List-Unsubscribe: , List-Archive: List-Post: List-Help: List-Subscribe: , To: =?ISO-8859-1?Q?Andreas_F=E4rber?= Cc: Anthony Liguori , qemu-devel@nongnu.org, Blue Swirl , Max Filippov , Avi Kivity , Paolo Bonzini On 10/17/2011 11:30 AM, Andreas Färber wrote: > Am 17.10.2011 16:17, schrieb Anthony Liguori: >> On 10/17/2011 07:50 AM, Paolo Bonzini wrote: >>> On 10/17/2011 02:38 PM, Anthony Liguori wrote: >>>>> Could we please draft some policy on this? This is not a GDB issue, >>>>> it's >>>>> very general. Whether we like it or not, there is GPLv3-licensed code >>>>> and there will probably be a GPLv4 one day. >>>> >>>> I don't see anything wrong with GPLv2 only. While I don't think there's >>>> anything wrong with GPLv3, I think that "or later" is a dangerous clause >>>> to add. >>> >>> License fragmentation with respect to the de facto standard toolchain >>> (binutils) >>> is wrong. >> >> Fragmentation with respect to the de factor standard kernel (Linux) is >> wrong. > > Tell that to the GNU and FSF people. :) > > In my personal opinion, Open Source licenses should preserve our > freedom, not make us unnecessarily duplicate code. > > I'm just asking to not make the situation worse than it is. It's not something that any one person can really change. It would require a very large effort. To give you an idea of the scope, I ran the following command: $ grep GPL *.c hw/*.c | grep -v 'or later' | cut -f1 -d: | sort -u | while read i; do echo $i; git log --format=" %an <%ae>" $i | sort -u; done Here's the results. All of these people would have to explicitly SoB a relicense of that specific file to include a "v2 or later" clause. In some cases, there's code from Thiemo which cannot be relicensed due to his untimely passing. aio.c Alexander Graf aliguori Andrea Arcangeli Anthony Liguori Avi Kivity Blue Swirl Kevin Wolf Nolan blockdev.c Alexander Graf Anthony Liguori Blue Swirl Christoph Hellwig Eduardo Habkost Gerd Hoffmann Jes Sorensen Kevin Wolf Luiz Capitulino Marcelo Tosatti Markus Armbruster Ryan Harper Stefan Hajnoczi block-migration.c Alex Williamson Anthony Liguori Avishay Traeger Blue Swirl Jan Kiszka Jan Kiszka Liran Schour lirans@il.ibm.com malc Marcelo Tosatti Markus Armbruster Pierre Riteau Shahar Havivi Stefan Hajnoczi Yoshiaki Tamura buffered_file.c aliguori Anthony Liguori Avi Kivity blueswir1 Blue Swirl Glauber Costa lirans@il.ibm.com malc Marcelo Tosatti Michael S. Tsirkin Paolo Bonzini Pierre Riteau compatfd.c Alexander Graf aliguori Jan Kiszka Marcelo Tosatti Tristan Gingold error.c Anthony Liguori Luiz Capitulino Stefan Weil hmp.c Anthony Liguori Luiz Capitulino hw/a9mpcore.c Matthew Fernandez Paul Brook hw/ads7846.c Alex Williamson balrog Gerd Hoffmann Juan Quintela Paul Brook pbrook hw/an5206.c Alex Williamson aliguori Anthony Liguori aurel32 Aurelien Jarno Avi Kivity balrog bellard blueswir1 Blue Swirl Jan Kiszka malc Matthew Fernandez Paul Brook pbrook ths hw/arm11mpcore.c Avi Kivity Matthew Fernandez Paul Brook Peter Maydell hw/arm_boot.c Adam Lackorzynski aliguori Anthony Liguori aurel32 Aurelien Jarno balrog Blue Swirl Jan Kiszka Jan Kiszka Lars Munch malc Matthew Fernandez Paul Brook pbrook Peter Maydell Stefan Weil ths hw/arm_gic.c Adam Lackorzynski Alexander Graf Alex Williamson aliguori Anthony Liguori aurel32 Avi Kivity balrog Blue Swirl malc Matthew Fernandez Paul Brook pbrook ths hw/arm_pic.c aliguori Andreas Färber Jan Kiszka Matthew Fernandez Paul Brook pbrook ths hw/arm_sysctl.c Alexander Graf aliguori Anthony Liguori Aurelien Jarno Avi Kivity blueswir1 Blue Swirl Daniel Jacobowitz Gerd Hoffmann malc Markus Armbruster Matthew Fernandez Paolo Bonzini Paul Brook pbrook Peter Maydell ths hw/arm_timer.c Alexander Graf Alex Williamson Anthony Liguori Avi Kivity blueswir1 Blue Swirl Gerd Hoffmann Juan Quintela malc Matthew Fernandez Paul Brook pbrook Rabin Vincent ths hw/armv7m.c Alexander Graf Alex Williamson Anthony Liguori Aurelien Jarno Avi Kivity blueswir1 Blue Swirl Gerd Hoffmann malc Markus Armbruster Matthew Fernandez Paul Brook pbrook hw/armv7m_nvic.c Alex Williamson Avi Kivity blueswir1 Blue Swirl Gerd Hoffmann Juan Quintela Matthew Fernandez Paolo Bonzini Paul Brook pbrook hw/bitbang_i2c.c Andrzej Zaborowski Anthony Liguori Gerd Hoffmann Marcus Comstedt Matthew Fernandez Paul Brook hw/bonito.c Alexander Graf Avi Kivity Huacai Chen Isaku Yamahata Stefan Weil hw/collie.c Anthony Liguori Avi Kivity Dmitry Eremin-Solenikov hw/ds1338.c Matthew Fernandez Paul Brook hw/dummy_m68k.c Alex Williamson aliguori Anthony Liguori aurel32 Aurelien Jarno Avi Kivity balrog blueswir1 Blue Swirl malc Matthew Fernandez Paul Brook pbrook hw/ecc.c balrog Dmitry Eremin-Solenikov Paul Brook pbrook hw/empty_slot.c Alexander Graf Artyom Tarasenko Stefan Weil hw/es1370.c aliguori Anthony Liguori Avi Kivity bellard blueswir1 Gerd Hoffmann Isaku Yamahata Jan Kiszka Jan Kiszka Juan Quintela malc malc Michael S. Tsirkin Paul Brook pbrook hw/event_notifier.c Michael S. Tsirkin hw/fmopl.c aliguori aurel32 bellard Blue Swirl malc malc Stefan Weil hw/framebuffer.c Anthony Liguori Jan Kiszka malc pbrook Vasily Khoruzhick hw/gumstix.c Alex Williamson aliguori Anthony Liguori aurel32 Avi Kivity balrog Blue Swirl Dmitry Eremin-Solenikov Gerd Hoffmann Lars Munch malc Paul Brook pbrook Richard Henderson ths hw/i2c.c Alex Williamson balrog Blue Swirl Gerd Hoffmann Juan Quintela Juha Riihimäki Markus Armbruster Matthew Fernandez Paul Brook pbrook ths hw/integratorcp.c Alexander Graf Alex Williamson aliguori Anthony Liguori aurel32 Avi Kivity balrog bellard blueswir1 Blue Swirl Gerd Hoffmann j_mayer malc Markus Armbruster Matthew Fernandez Paul Brook pbrook Peter Maydell ths hw/ivshmem.c Alexander Graf Anthony Liguori Avi Kivity Cam Macdonell Isaku Yamahata Jes Sorensen hw/kvmclock.c Glauber Costa Jan Kiszka Luiz Capitulino hw/lan9118.c Alexander Graf Atsushi Nemoto Blue Swirl Mark McLoughlin Markus Armbruster Matthew Fernandez Paolo Bonzini Paul Brook Peter Maydell Stefan Weil hw/lsi53c895a.c Alexander Graf aliguori Anthony Liguori aurel32 Aurelien Jarno Avi Kivity balrog Bernhard Kohl blueswir1 Blue Swirl Christophe Fergeau Gerd Hoffmann Hannes Reinecke Isaku Yamahata Jan Kiszka Juan Quintela Laszlo Ast malc Markus Armbruster Matthew Fernandez Michael S. Tsirkin Nolan Paolo Bonzini Paul Brook pbrook Ryan Harper Sebastian Herbszt Stefan Hajnoczi Stefan Weil ths hw/mainstone.c Alex Williamson aliguori Anthony Liguori aurel32 Avi Kivity balrog Blue Swirl Dmitry Eremin-Solenikov Gerd Hoffmann Lars Munch malc Paul Brook pbrook Richard Henderson ths hw/marvell_88w8618_audio.c Alexander Graf Andrzej Zaborowski Anthony Liguori Blue Swirl Gerd Hoffmann Jan Kiszka malc Matthew Fernandez hw/max111x.c Alex Williamson balrog Gerd Hoffmann Juan Quintela Paul Brook pbrook hw/max7310.c balrog Dmitry Eremin-Solenikov Gerd Hoffmann Juan Quintela malc Paul Brook pbrook hw/mcf5206.c Alexander Graf Anthony Liguori Avi Kivity blueswir1 Blue Swirl malc Matthew Fernandez Paul Brook pbrook ths hw/mcf5208.c Alexander Graf Alex Williamson aliguori Anthony Liguori aurel32 Aurelien Jarno Avi Kivity balrog bellard blueswir1 Blue Swirl malc Matthew Fernandez Paul Brook pbrook ths hw/mcf_fec.c Alexander Graf aliguori Anthony Liguori Avi Kivity Blue Swirl Jan Kiszka malc Mark McLoughlin Matthew Fernandez Paul Brook pbrook ths hw/mcf_intc.c Alexander Graf Anthony Liguori Avi Kivity Blue Swirl malc Matthew Fernandez Paul Brook pbrook ths hw/mcf_uart.c Alexander Graf Anthony Liguori Avi Kivity balrog Blue Swirl malc Matthew Fernandez pbrook ths hw/mips_fulong2e.c Alex Williamson Anthony Liguori Aurelien Jarno Avi Kivity Blue Swirl Huacai Chen Isaku Yamahata Jan Kiszka Stefan Weil hw/mpcore.c Alexander Graf aliguori Anthony Liguori Avi Kivity blueswir1 Blue Swirl Gerd Hoffmann malc Matthew Fernandez Paolo Bonzini Paul Brook pbrook hw/msix.c Alexander Graf Anthony Liguori Avi Kivity Blue Swirl Isaku Yamahata Jan Kiszka Jes Sorensen malc Michael S. Tsirkin Stefan Weil hw/mst_fpga.c Alexander Graf Alex Williamson aliguori Andrzej Zaborowski Anthony Liguori Avi Kivity blueswir1 Blue Swirl Dmitry Eremin-Solenikov malc Paul Brook pbrook Stefan Weil ths hw/musicpal.c Alexander Graf Alex Williamson aliguori Andrzej Zaborowski Anthony Liguori aurel32 Avi Kivity balrog Benoit Canet blueswir1 Blue Swirl Gerd Hoffmann Jan Kiszka Jan Kiszka malc malc Mark McLoughlin Markus Armbruster Matthew Fernandez Paul Brook pbrook Richard Henderson hw/nand.c Alex Williamson Andrzej Zaborowski Anthony Liguori balrog blueswir1 Edgar E. Iglesias Gerd Hoffmann Jean-Christophe DUBOIS Juan Quintela Juha Riihimäki Markus Armbruster Paul Brook pbrook Peter Maydell ths hw/pc.c Adam Lackorzynski Alexander Graf Alex Williamson aliguori Amit Shah Anthony Liguori Anthony PERARD aurel32 Aurelien Jarno Avi Kivity balrog bellard Bernhard Kohl Bernhard M. Wiedemann blueswir1 Blue Swirl Eduard - Gabriel Munteanu Eduardo Habkost Gerd Hoffmann Glauber Costa Gleb Natapov Isaku Yamahata Jan Kiszka Jan Kiszka Jes Sorensen Jes Sorensen j_mayer Juan Quintela Justin M. Forbes Kevin Wolf Kirill A. Shutemov malc Mark McLoughlin Markus Armbruster Markus Armbruster Michael S. Tsirkin M. Mohan Kumar Pascal Terjan Paul Brook pbrook Richard Henderson Richard W.M. Jones Stefan Weil ths hw/pl011.c Alexander Graf Alex Williamson Anthony Liguori aurel32 Avi Kivity balrog blueswir1 Blue Swirl Gerd Hoffmann Juan Quintela malc Matthew Fernandez Paul Brook pbrook ths hw/pl022.c Alexander Graf Alex Williamson Anthony Liguori Avi Kivity blueswir1 Blue Swirl Gerd Hoffmann Juan Quintela malc Matthew Fernandez Paul Brook pbrook hw/pl050.c Alexander Graf Anthony Liguori Avi Kivity blueswir1 Blue Swirl Gerd Hoffmann malc Matthew Fernandez Paul Brook pbrook Peter Maydell ths hw/pl061.c Alexander Graf Alex Williamson Anthony Liguori Avi Kivity blueswir1 Blue Swirl Gerd Hoffmann malc Matthew Fernandez Paul Brook pbrook Peter Maydell Stefan Weil hw/pl080.c Alexander Graf Anthony Liguori Avi Kivity blueswir1 Blue Swirl Gerd Hoffmann malc Matthew Fernandez Paul Brook pbrook Peter Maydell ths hw/pl110.c Alexander Graf aliguori Anthony Liguori Avi Kivity balrog Blue Swirl Gerd Hoffmann malc Matthew Fernandez Paul Brook pbrook Peter Maydell ths hw/pl181.c Alexander Graf Anthony Liguori Avi Kivity Blue Swirl Gerd Hoffmann Jan Kiszka Jan Kiszka malc Markus Armbruster Matthew Fernandez Paul Brook pbrook Peter Maydell ths hw/pl190.c Alexander Graf Anthony Liguori Avi Kivity Blue Swirl Gerd Hoffmann malc Matthew Fernandez Paul Brook pbrook Peter Maydell ths hw/ptimer.c Anthony Liguori blueswir1 Blue Swirl Juan Quintela Matthew Fernandez Paolo Bonzini pbrook ths hw/pxa2xx.c Alexander Graf Alex Williamson aliguori Andrzej Zaborowski Anthony Liguori aurel32 Avi Kivity balrog bellard blueswir1 Blue Swirl Dmitry Eremin-Solenikov Gerd Hoffmann Juan Quintela Lars Munch malc Matthew Fernandez Paolo Bonzini Paul Brook pbrook Richard Henderson ths Vasily Khoruzhick hw/pxa2xx_dma.c Alexander Graf Alex Williamson Andrzej Zaborowski Anthony Liguori Avi Kivity balrog bellard blueswir1 Blue Swirl Dmitry Eremin-Solenikov malc Matthew Fernandez Paul Brook pbrook hw/pxa2xx_gpio.c Alexander Graf Alex Williamson Anthony Liguori Avi Kivity balrog Blue Swirl Dmitry Eremin-Solenikov malc Paul Brook pbrook ths hw/pxa2xx_keypad.c Alexander Graf Alex Williamson Anthony Liguori Avi Kivity balrog Blue Swirl Juan Quintela malc Paul Brook pbrook Vasily Khoruzhick hw/pxa2xx_lcd.c Alexander Graf Alex Williamson aliguori Anthony Liguori Avi Kivity balrog Blue Swirl Dmitry Eremin-Solenikov Juan Quintela malc Paul Brook pbrook Stefan Weil Vasily Khoruzhick hw/pxa2xx_mmci.c Alexander Graf Alex Williamson Andrzej Zaborowski Anthony Liguori Avi Kivity balrog Blue Swirl malc Paul Brook pbrook hw/pxa2xx_pcmcia.c Alexander Graf Anthony Liguori Avi Kivity balrog Blue Swirl malc Paul Brook pbrook hw/pxa2xx_pic.c Alexander Graf Alex Williamson Andrzej Zaborowski Andrzej Zaborowski Anthony Liguori Avi Kivity balrog Blue Swirl Dmitry Eremin-Solenikov malc Matthew Fernandez Paul Brook pbrook hw/pxa2xx_timer.c Alexander Graf Alex Williamson Andrzej Zaborowski Andrzej Zaborowski Anthony Liguori Avi Kivity balrog blueswir1 Blue Swirl Dmitry Eremin-Solenikov Juan Quintela malc Matthew Fernandez Paolo Bonzini Paul Brook pbrook hw/realview.c Adam Lackorzynski Alexander Graf Alex Williamson aliguori Anthony Liguori aurel32 balrog bellard blueswir1 Blue Swirl Gerd Hoffmann j_mayer malc Markus Armbruster Matthew Fernandez Michael S. Tsirkin Paul Brook pbrook Peter Maydell ths hw/realview_gic.c Alexander Graf Anthony Liguori Avi Kivity Blue Swirl Gerd Hoffmann malc Matthew Fernandez Paul Brook pbrook hw/scsi-disk.c aliguori Anthony Liguori Artyom Tarasenko aurel32 balrog bellard Bernhard Kohl blueswir1 Blue Swirl Christoph Hellwig Gerd Hoffmann Gleb Natapov Hannes Reinecke Herve Poussineau Jan Kiszka Kevin Wolf Laszlo Ast Luiz Capitulino Markus Armbruster Matthew Fernandez Naphtali Sprei Paolo Bonzini pbrook Stefan Hajnoczi ths hw/scsi-generic.c aliguori Anthony Liguori aurel32 Bernhard Kohl Blue Swirl Christoph Hellwig Gerd Hoffmann Hannes Reinecke Jean-Christophe DUBOIS Markus Armbruster Matthew Fernandez Paolo Bonzini ths hw/sh_intc.c Alexander Graf aliguori Anthony Liguori aurel32 Avi Kivity balrog Blue Swirl malc malc Matthew Fernandez Paul Brook pbrook Stefan Weil ths hw/sh_timer.c Alexander Graf Anthony Liguori aurel32 Avi Kivity balrog Blue Swirl malc Matthew Fernandez Paul Brook pbrook ths hw/smbios.c aliguori Anthony Liguori Beth Kon Blue Swirl Stefan Weil hw/smbus.c balrog Blue Swirl Gerd Hoffmann Juan Quintela Matthew Fernandez Paul Brook pbrook ths hw/smc91c111.c Alexander Graf aliguori Anthony Liguori Avi Kivity bellard Blue Swirl Gerd Hoffmann Juha Riihimäki Lars Munch malc Mark McLoughlin Markus Armbruster Matthew Fernandez Paul Brook pbrook Peter Maydell ths hw/spitz.c Alexander Graf Alex Williamson aliguori Anthony Liguori aurel32 Avi Kivity balrog bellard blueswir1 Blue Swirl Dmitry Eremin-Solenikov Gerd Hoffmann Juan Quintela Juha Riihimäki Lars Munch malc Markus Armbruster Paolo Bonzini Paul Brook pbrook Peter Maydell Richard Henderson Stefan Weil ths hw/ssd0303.c aliguori balrog Blue Swirl Gerd Hoffmann Juan Quintela Matthew Fernandez Paul Brook pbrook Stefan Weil hw/ssd0323.c Alex Williamson aliguori balrog Blue Swirl Gerd Hoffmann Matthew Fernandez Paul Brook pbrook hw/ssi.c Blue Swirl Gerd Hoffmann Markus Armbruster Matthew Fernandez Paul Brook hw/ssi-sd.c Alex Williamson blueswir1 Blue Swirl Gerd Hoffmann Markus Armbruster Matthew Fernandez Paul Brook pbrook hw/stellaris.c Alexander Graf Alex Williamson aliguori Anthony Liguori aurel32 Avi Kivity balrog blueswir1 Blue Swirl Engin AYDOGAN Gerd Hoffmann Jan Kiszka Juan Quintela malc Markus Armbruster Matthew Fernandez Paolo Bonzini Paul Brook pbrook Peter Maydell ths hw/stellaris_enet.c Alexander Graf Alex Williamson aliguori Anthony Liguori Avi Kivity Blue Swirl Gerd Hoffmann malc Mark McLoughlin Matthew Fernandez Paul Brook pbrook hw/stellaris_input.c Alex Williamson Anthony Liguori blueswir1 Juan Quintela Matthew Fernandez pbrook hw/strongarm.c Anthony Liguori Dmitry Eremin-Solenikov Markus Armbruster hw/tc6393xb.c Alexander Graf Alex Williamson aliguori Anthony Liguori Avi Kivity balrog Blue Swirl Dmitry Eremin-Solenikov Juha Riihimäki malc Paul Brook pbrook Peter Maydell hw/tosa.c Alex Williamson aliguori Anthony Liguori aurel32 balrog Blue Swirl Dmitry Eremin-Solenikov Gerd Hoffmann Lars Munch malc Markus Armbruster Paul Brook pbrook Richard Henderson hw/usb-msd.c aliguori Anthony Liguori Arnaud Patard (Rtp) aurel32 balrog bellard Blue Swirl Brad Hards Christoph Hellwig Gerd Hoffmann Gleb Natapov Hannes Reinecke Hans de Goede Markus Armbruster Matthew Fernandez Max Reitz Paolo Bonzini Paul Brook pbrook Stefan Hajnoczi ths hw/usb-serial.c aliguori Amit Shah Anthony Liguori aurel32 balrog blueswir1 Blue Swirl Brad Hards David S. Ahern Gerd Hoffmann Hans de Goede Jason Wessel Kevin Wolf Markus Armbruster Matthew Fernandez Paul Brook hw/versatilepb.c Alexander Graf Alex Williamson aliguori Anthony Liguori aurel32 Avi Kivity balrog bellard blueswir1 Blue Swirl Gerd Hoffmann j_mayer malc Markus Armbruster Matthew Fernandez Michael S. Tsirkin Paul Brook pbrook Peter Maydell ths hw/versatile_pci.c Alexander Graf aliguori Anthony Liguori Avi Kivity blueswir1 Blue Swirl Gerd Hoffmann Isaku Yamahata Juan Quintela malc Matthew Fernandez Michael S. Tsirkin Paul Brook pbrook Peter Maydell ths hw/vhost.c Anthony Liguori Anthony PERARD Blue Swirl Jason Wang Marcelo Tosatti Michael S. Tsirkin Mike McCormack mst@redhat.com Stefan Weil hw/vhost_net.c Anthony Liguori Blue Swirl Jes Sorensen Michael S. Tsirkin Michael Tokarev Mike McCormack mst@redhat.com hw/virtio-balloon.c Adam Litke Alexey Kardashevskiy Alex Williamson aliguori Amit Shah Andreas Färber Anthony Liguori blueswir1 Blue Swirl Eduardo Habkost malc Michael S. Tsirkin Paul Brook pbrook hw/virtio-blk.c Alex Williamson aliguori Amit Shah Anthony Liguori Aurelien Jarno blueswir1 Blue Swirl Bruce Rogers Christoph Hellwig Gerd Hoffmann Gleb Natapov hch@lst.de Jan Kiszka Jes Sorensen john cooper Kevin Wolf Luiz Capitulino Markus Armbruster Michael S. Tsirkin Naphtali Sprei Paul Brook Stefan Hajnoczi Stefan Weil Yoshiaki Tamura hw/virtio.c aliguori Amit Shah Anthony Liguori blueswir1 Blue Swirl David Gibson Isaku Yamahata Jan Kiszka Jason Wang Kevin Wolf Luiz Capitulino malc Mark McLoughlin Markus Armbruster Michael S. Tsirkin Paul Brook Stefan Hajnoczi Stefan Weil hw/virtio-console.c aliguori Amit Shah Anthony Liguori blueswir1 Gerd Hoffmann Hans de Goede Markus Armbruster Michael S. Tsirkin Paul Brook hw/virtio-net.c Alex Williamson Alex Williamson aliguori Amit Shah Anthony Liguori Aurelien Jarno blueswir1 David L Stevens Dustin Kirkland Gerd Hoffmann Glauber Costa Gleb Natapov Hannes Reinecke Mark McLoughlin Markus Armbruster Michael S. Tsirkin mst@redhat.com Paolo Bonzini Paul Brook Sridhar Samudrala Stefan Hajnoczi Tom Lendacky hw/virtio-pci.c Alexander Graf Alex Williamson Amit Shah Aneesh Kumar K.V Anthony Liguori Avi Kivity Blue Swirl Christoph Hellwig Gerd Hoffmann Gleb Natapov Isaku Yamahata Jan Kiszka malc Mark McLoughlin Markus Armbruster Michael S. Tsirkin mst@redhat.com Paul Brook Stefan Hajnoczi Venkateswararao Jujjuri (JV) Yan Vugenfirer hw/virtio-serial-bus.c Alexey Kardashevskiy Alex Williamson Alon Levy Amit Shah Anthony Liguori Gerd Hoffmann Hannes Reinecke Luiz Capitulino Markus Armbruster Michael S. Tsirkin hw/vt82c686.c Huacai Chen Isaku Yamahata Paolo Bonzini Richard Henderson Stefan Weil hw/wm8750.c Anthony Liguori balrog blueswir1 Blue Swirl Gerd Hoffmann Juan Quintela malc malc Paul Brook pbrook hw/z2.c Anthony Liguori Avi Kivity Richard Henderson Vasily Khoruzhick iov.c Amit Shah Gerd Hoffmann Hannes Reinecke memory.c Anthony Liguori Avi Kivity Blue Swirl David Gibson Jan Kiszka Michael Walle Richard Henderson migration.c Alex Williamson aliguori Amit Shah Anthony Liguori Chris Lalancette Gerd Hoffmann Glauber Costa Jan Kiszka Jes Sorensen Juan Quintela lirans@il.ibm.com Luiz Capitulino malc Marcelo Tosatti Markus Armbruster Michael S. Tsirkin Paolo Bonzini Uri Lublin Yoshiaki Tamura migration-exec.c aliguori Anthony Liguori Blue Swirl Chris Lalancette Jan Kiszka Juan Quintela lirans@il.ibm.com malc Paolo Bonzini migration-fd.c Anthony Liguori Blue Swirl Jan Kiszka Juan Quintela lirans@il.ibm.com malc Paolo Bonzini migration-tcp.c aliguori Anthony Liguori blueswir1 Blue Swirl Jan Kiszka Juan Quintela Kevin Wolf lirans@il.ibm.com malc Paolo Bonzini Shahar Havivi Stefan Weil Yoshiaki Tamura migration-unix.c Anthony Liguori Blue Swirl Chris Lalancette Daniel P. Berrange Jan Kiszka Juan Quintela Kevin Wolf lirans@il.ibm.com malc Stefan Weil module.c Anthony Liguori Blue Swirl notify.c Anthony Liguori Jan Kiszka pflib.c Anthony Liguori Gerd Hoffmann posix-aio-compat.c Alexandre Raymond aliguori Andrew de Quincey Anthony Liguori Avi Kivity blueswir1 Blue Swirl Christoph Hellwig Frediano Ziglio Jes Sorensen Juan Quintela Kevin Wolf Kirill A. Shutemov malc malc Stefan Hajnoczi Stefan Weil qemu-tool.c aliguori Anthony Liguori aurel32 Blue Swirl Frediano Ziglio Jes Sorensen Juan Quintela Kevin Wolf Luiz Capitulino Markus Armbruster Naphtali Sprei pbrook Stefan Hajnoczi qmp.c Anthony Liguori Luiz Capitulino xen-all.c Anthony Liguori Anthony PERARD Arun Sharma Jan Kiszka Jun Nakajima Luiz Capitulino Stefano Stabellini xen-mapcache.c Anthony Liguori Anthony PERARD Jan Kiszka John Baboval Jun Nakajima Stefan Berger Stefano Stabellini xen-stub.c Anthony PERARD Jun Nakajima Stefano Stabellini Regards, Anthony Liguori > > Regards, > Andreas >