[U-Boot-Users] u-boot and NIOS dk 1s10 board

Stephan Linz
2003-11-18T08:27:44Z

Hi Patric and Scott,

Am Montag, 17. November 2003 19:40 schrieb Scott McNutt:
> Patrice,
>
> > It works now...in fact, my reference design for STRATIX
> > configuration was not similar to the IO mapping used by u-boot
> > for NIOS... It works with the Altera's "standard 32" reference
> > design (with the .SREC in the CDKNIOS project and after
> > u-boot recompilation too).
>
> Great news!

Congratulations!

>
> > My student will work on the u-boot APEX port...just an adaptation
> > I think...I may be a good idea that the stratix 1S10 board appears
> > as its own board and not as a cyclone board in the u-boot distro...
>
> I enthusiastically agree :-) It is not simply a good idea, but IMHO
> *essential* that each Nios board have it's own u-boot configuration.
> Since *everything* is configurable with Nios, it's very easy to create
> a monster by having multiple board configs masquerading as one.

Yes, of course. We have to make different configuration files -- one for each
board. But, do we really need different board directories with almost the
same code in it?

Ex.: My current Stratix patch is based on the Cyclone board, because both
boards are equal in context of u-boot basics need. Only the second serial i/f
differs (not needed til now). So there will be more identicalness than
differences for both boards.

But note: this does not apply to the APEX board. The APEX board has different
Flash, less SRAM, only SODIMM SDRAM, no second seriel i/f (in standard32
case), no CF, less LEDs, and ... to many differences and it's right, for APEX
we should make a new board directory with it code inside.

What's your opinion?

FYIO: I plan to make an hardware overview for all known NIOS devkits by
Altera (APEX 20k200, Cyclone 1C20, Stratix 1S20 and 1S40).

br,
Stephan

>
> U-Boot for Nios development kits should always support the
> default "out-of-the-box" Nios configuration (for the altera boards,
> this is typically the "standard 32" config). This is not intended to
> limit creativity, but to avoid confusion and save time. Basically,
> if new users get u-boot running quickly and easily, maintainers
> and contributors will spend less time answering questions. And
> this is a good thing for both the user and contributors :-)
>
> In general, support for custom configurations should be:
>
> 1. disabled by default,
> 2. enabled IAW README (i.e. CONFIG_xxx CFG_xxx),
> 3. supported by an appropriate README file in u-boot/doc.
>
> Congratulations & Best Regards,
> --Scott
> N3ADP
>
>
>
>
> -------------------------------------------------------
> This SF. Net email is sponsored by: GoToMyPC
> GoToMyPC is the fast, easy and secure way to access your computer from
> any Web browser or wireless device. Click here to Try it Free!
> https://www.gotomypc.com/tr/OSDN/AW/Q4_2003/t/g22lp?Target=mm/g22lp.tmpl
> _______________________________________________
> U-Boot-Users mailing list
> U-Boot-Users at lists.sourceforge.net
> https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/u-boot-users

--
Mit freundlichen Gruessen
Stephan Linz

======================================================================
Stephan Linz
Softwareentwicklung

MAZeT GmbH Email: mailto:linz at mazet.de
G?schwitzer Str. 32 Tel. : (3641) 2809-55
D-07745 Jena Fax : (3641) 2809-12

Besuchen Sie bitte unsere Web-Seiten: http://www.MAZeT.de
======================================================================