[U-Boot-Users] flash driver in u-boot

[Tolunay Orkun <listmember@orkun.us>]

Reeve Yang wrote:

> But cfi_flash.c doesn't work for me. It always complains "flash is 
> busy" when I try to write something. However strata_flash.c works. why 
> is that? By the way, is there anyway to read flash contents in u-boot? md?
Define success! Did you actually verify that strataflash.c worked 
correctly. It might be silently ignoring the issues and giving you false 
impression that it was successful. Did you actually check the flash 
contents  after write? Since you are asking about if md could be used 
for reading the flash it tells me you do not know if strataflash was 
actually successful.

I have got no idea what code base you are using (top of git tree or some 
older version).  What CPU architecture you have? How it is interfaced to 
your CPU? If flash mapped to the address space correctly. Is that memory 
space enabled for write access? Is the timing setup correctly (wait 
states, holds etc?). Which one of many strataflash.c you have used (some 
with different tweaks)?

Many things can go wrong that could prevent normal operation. If you had 
posted actual screen capture from CFI driver and the strataflash.c and 
perhaps someone could provide more hints. Ultimately, the code is there. 
You will need to do some code reading and debugging to find out why 
cfi_flash gives always busy. Or hire someone to do this for you.

All I can say is that cfi_flash.c works with this chip. Cogent csb272 
uses 2 of these chips side by side using cfi_flash.c.

Tolunay

>
> On 10/16/06, *Tolunay Orkun* <listmember@orkun.us 
> <mailto:listmember@orkun.us>> wrote:
>
>     Reeve Yang wrote:
>     > I'm a little confused by flash driver selection in u-boot. My flash
>     > device is intel JS28F128J3, I assume it's not CFI flash so I
>     want to use
>
>     Intel 28F128J3 is a CFI compliant flash chip.
>
>     > strataflash.c. I added such file under my board directory, add
>     it into
>     > Makefile, and undef CFG_FLASH_CFI_DRIVER, but I got link error. If
>
>     strataflash.c driver is a pre-cursor to common cfi_flash.c. Most
>     boards
>     are reworked to use the cfi_flash.c. To use strataflash.c you also had
>     to define CFG_FLASH_CFI_DRIVER (as far as my memory serves). There
>     is no
>     reason to use a custom flash driver nowadays unless your flash is
>     interfaced to the processor bus in a very unusual way (like data bus
>     scrambled -- hardware design bugs)
>
>     > define this macro, the compilation is ok and my flash works. My
>     question
>     > is, if we define this macro, which flash driver being used?
>     cfi_flash.c
>     > or my strataflash.c?
>
>     Use cfi_flash.c
>
>     Tolunay
>
>